Opinion Changes vs Geelong

[CharlieKelly]

OUT: Houston, Amon, Rockliff

IN: Powell-Pepper, Pittard, Atley

 

[PAFC66]

Frampton would make us worse.

Doubt it.

Howard and Westhoff need to be behind the ball. Sitting there live today it was obvious.

 

[Wargreymon90]

Note: being at the game nearly all of Stewart and Stringer’s goals were on Mckenzie bar 1. Clurey played on Daniher who he negated well.

I thought jonas played on Daniher most of the game

 

[PatientMental]

Doubt it.

He got destroyed by a Jarrod Redden who in the past few years has eaten himself. I want him nowhere near the AFL team.

 

[dirty2]

Don't drop anyone of them to the port adelaide magpies.... they don't deserve to play in OUR prison bar Guernsey.. **** it send them to hamley bridge... thats where they will end up with that sort of piss poor effort.

P.s sorry hamley

 

[Sleezy]

Rocky -> SPP
Houston -> Pittard

If Marshall is injured:
Marshall -> Frampton
McKenzie -> Barry
Amon -> Thomas

If Marshall is ok:
McKenzie -> Frampton
Amon -> Barry

FB: DBJ Clurey Jonas
HB: Hartlett Howard Pittard
C: Polec Ebert Westhoff
HF: Motlop Watts Boak
FF: Wingard Dixon Marshall/Thomas
R: Frampton Wines R Gray

Int: Barry Bonner S Gray SPP

 

[Schulzenfest]

Note: being at the game nearly all of Stewart and Stringer’s goals were on Mckenzie bar 1. Clurey played on Daniher who he negated well.

Think you might need to watch a replay there mate because this is completely inaccurate.

 

[PatientMental]

Stop suggesting Frampton, he ain't getting picked.

 

[Nemisis]

IN: Snelling, Frampton, Pittard, Atley.
OUT: Rocky, Marshall (inj), McKenzie, Amon

 

[Schulzenfest]

Also playing an All-Australian dual best and fairest player in the SANFL would be utterly pointless. If Rocky’s body isn’t up to it, give him some time off to rest up for a few weeks. He’d gain more from that than he would from playing in front of three men and a dog at Noarlunga.

 

[Wargreymon90]

It will be two changes max if Marshall is ok.

Out: Amon, Houston
In: SPP, Pittard

 

[PowerBaz]

Stop suggesting Frampton, he ain't getting picked.

Yeah just watched the presser, definitely won't play another ruck all year.

I don't think Ken watched the same game I just did, I would be fuming.

 

[PowerBaz]

Also playing an All-Australian dual best and fairest player in the SANFL would be utterly pointless. If Rocky’s body isn’t up to it, give him some time off to rest up for a few weeks. He’d gain more from that than he would from playing in front of three men and a dog at Noarlunga.

Watch Ken's presser, he won't drop him for form but looks like he might need a spell with a calf injury.

 

[Power Raid]

Out: McKenzie, Amon, Rockliff, Houston
In: Pittard, Hayes, SPP,

Hombsch for McKenzie
Pittard for Rockcliff (play Pittard on the wing)
SPP for Amon
Hayes/ Frampton for Rockcliff

We are then playing one too tall and Westhoff, Watts or Marshall need to sit out for balance. Atley might be the lucky man.

 

[simmo_bc]

Also playing an All-Australian dual best and fairest player in the SANFL would be utterly pointless. If Rocky’s body isn’t up to it, give him some time off to rest up for a few weeks. He’d gain more from that than he would from playing in front of three men and a dog at Noarlunga.

Spot on

 

[El Zorro]

Pittard for Rockcliff
Hayes/ Frampton for Rockcliff

How many Rockcliffs do we have playing?

 

[JimmyBeerCans]

Also playing an All-Australian dual best and fairest player in the SANFL would be utterly pointless. If Rocky’s body isn’t up to it, give him some time off to rest up for a few weeks. He’d gain more from that than he would from playing in front of three men and a dog at Noarlunga.

He can come back through the SANFL though you need to prove something at our club before getting a gold pass, leather poisoning in front of three men and a dog anywhere might not do him any harm at present.

 

[Jonts]

out
Amon- no real reason to be in imo over Barry
McKenzie-we tried and still better than pick 100 or whatever we would've used but not up to it currently
Rockliff- looks lost, was good defensively on Merrett in tree second half but once it leaves the initisl stoppage he got spanked
Houston - not the cool calm guy we knew, needs to find confidence

in
Barry, Pittard, SPP, Frampton Atley

 

[JAlexG]

Ken has pretty much said in his presser we don't have a ruck ready to play and we need to stop calling for it. Saying he won't play people who don't deserve to be out there.
Well sorry, but this is just pathetic from the heirachy then. If you don't have a ready replacement if Ryder goes down and instead bringing in the likes of Thomas, Trengove and McKenzie during the trade period AND send off Lobbe then that is just unacceptable.
That's ****ing amateur hour. How can you think Paddy is going to be bullet proof? This is AFL ****ing football!

 

[Power Raid]

How many Rockcliffs do we have playing?

Perhaps he's twice as bad as I thinking?

 

[Power Raid]

Ken has pretty much said in his presser we don't have a ruck ready to play and we need to stop calling for it. Saying he won't play people who don't deserve to be out there.
Well sorry, but this is just pathetic from the heirachy then. If you don't have a ready replacement if Ryder goes down and instead bringing in the likes of Thomas, Trengove and McKenzie during the trade period AND send off Lobbe then that is just unacceptable.
That's ******* amateur hour. How can you think Paddy is going to be bullet proof? This is AFL ******* football!

fair enough, we must accept our poor planning in the ruck area. but when you know you're going to loose the ruck, why play a slow midfield who react rather than put pressure on the opposition?

Surely you play a couple of fast centres who will run back and defend as well as tackle.

 

[ozph1870]

Stop suggesting Frampton, he ain't getting picked.

I think we should play Frampton.. and hayes

 

[Jonts]

out
Amon- no real reason to be in imo over Barry
McKenzie-we tried and still better than pick 100 or whatever we would've used but not up to it currently
Rockliff- looks lost, was good defensively on Merrett in tree second half but once it leaves the initisl stoppage he got spanked
Houston - not the cool calm guy we knew, needs to find confidence

in
Barry, Pittard, SPP, Frampton Atley

if we don't bring in a ruckman to let Howard go spoil crazy down back than Hombsch in

 

[JAlexG]

fair enough, we must accept our poor planning in the ruck area. but when you know you're going to loose the ruck, why play a slow midfield who react rather than put pressure on the opposition?

Surely you play a couple of fast centres who will run back and defend as well as tackle.

It's not just about the ruck. It's about WHO we are playing in the ruck to stop gap.
We are playing Dixon, Westhoff and Howard, literally the majority of our spine, completely out of position.

 

[tribey]

Saying he won't play people who don't deserve to be out there.

Selecting a clearly physically-finished Redden for the Farrisbowl really did a number on him hey.