Review Dees v Collingwood: Judgement Day. The Good, Bad & Fugly

[Major Colvin]

By the way of all sides to potentially push us out - ****ing Essendon and West Coast. Jesus

 

[Willo 17]

Tremendous negativity for a first-time poster. You are a quick study, sir.

First time poster, supporter since Barrassi played. Quick study? or Long lessons.

 

[Andy_Mac]

Fugly. The rage isn't subsiding at all and in my anger I've burned off a young lass that was keen to make me feel better. Lucky o git screwed by MFC already today.

I'd have thought tonight was more of a hunt for moby dick type night...

 

[stretcharmstrong]

I say go Essendon and west coast, the boys are clearly hanging out for mad Monday. We shouldn't interrupt their plans. This group doesn't deserve and isn't ready to play finals yet.

 

[ThePuppetMaster]

Payback is a right bitch aint it, for the QB game, revenge is a dish best served cold.

We'll still make finals - you're revenge will just see an average coach keep his job...

 

[KickLongTackleHard]

F*** we were fumbly and indecisive and messy today, we went to water under the pressure and expectation. Very disappointing.

 

[Cromulent1]

I'd have thought tonight was more of a hunt for moby dick type night...

Only if it means being swallowed whole. Too far...? Not today, i/we've all earned it.

 

[Piesnchess]

We'll still make finals - you're revenge will just see an average coach keep his job...

West coast ?? Goodwin was outcoached today, you lost to a team of kids.

 

[jack son 5]

West coast ?? Goodwin was outcoached today, you lost to a team of kids.

Piss off flog.

 

[mrmonkey]

By the way of all sides to potentially push us out - ******* Essendon and West Coast. Jesus

I usually hate essendon but I don't mind this essendon team, they play with a bit of ticker. (I couldn't stand essendon supporters in that 11-14 period when they grossly overrated their team) at least this essendon team is actually good and clean.

 

[demondavey]

That goal Sidebottom kicked from a metre in front while three melbourne players were scratching their nuts in the goal square, **** me.

This. The commentators labelled his 'agility', but we just watched him kick a sitter. One of those typical Melbourne efforts.

 

[Toump Ass]

We won all quarters except the first, just let than sink in.

Pretty simple really; we got overwhelmed by the occasion, our confidence is low because our form has been shit, and we let Collingwood get too far in front.

A month out from finals and one of our our most promising KPDs and two Top 10 draft picks- one of which has played over 150 games- were dropped. Not a great look.

We've sucked since beating the Eagles in Perth, I'm not sure if it's a fitness issue or a mental issue but it feels like we do this every year (ie: Carlton game in 2016). Even when we weren't competing for finals under Roos, we'd build momentum with a couple of gutsy wins late in the year and then lose by 100 against a bottom 4 side.

It's what we do.

 

[Benwah83]

That goal Sidebottom kicked from a metre in front while three melbourne players were scratching their nuts in the goal square, **** me.

Our defence was all at sea today. Every time it went down there we looked shaky.

But yes, that was the worst of the bunch.

 

[KickLongTackleHard]

This. The commentators labelled his 'agility', but we just watched him kick a sitter. One of those typical Melbourne efforts.

The Adams (?) goal off the pack at the other end was equally poor. Hunt and Jones were on the inside in no man's land.

 

[KickLongTackleHard]

The only positive out of this is if it assists in Buckley being re-appointed. Silver linings.

 

[TheDarkDwarf]

That's what I though today vis a vis the Brisbane game.

Hope is a lie. Face the abyss with eyes wide open. Let the darkness consume you.

But be careful, if you look long enough into the abyss, the abyss will look back into you.

 

[PieLebo87]

The Good - Petracca, again. The guy is going to be winning games off his boot on a consistent basis in the near future. He isn't good, he is scary good. Other 'good' is Watts slot right back in, and was serviceable. If finals is on the card, he is best 22.

The bad - It wasn't the loss, it was the manner of it. Allowing for a 32 point deficit in the first quarter. Fighting for a bit, then again giving up a deficit of 40 in the 3rd. Shouldn't be allowing sides those sorts of runs, especially ones against a Pies side missing a few of its guns.

The fugly - That wait between now and 4:40pm tomorrow. From an outsider, it's what makes our great game so exciting, sometimes the fate of your side is in the hands of another's. Enjoy the ride the best you can.

 

[schmuttt]

I laugh at people bagging Watts - I've been as critical as anyone but he was good today and **** I wish we had more players who use the ball like he does.

 

[jack son 5]

The Good - Petracca, again. The guy is going to be winning games off his boot on a consistent basis in the near future. He isn't good, he is scary good. Other 'good' is Watts slot right back in, and was serviceable. If finals is on the card, he is best 22.

The bad - It wasn't the loss, it was the manner of it. Allowing for a 32 point deficit in the first quarter. Fighting for a bit, then again giving up a deficit of 40 in the 3rd. Shouldn't be allowing sides those sorts of runs, especially ones against a Pies side missing a few of its guns.

The fugly - That wait between now and 4:40pm tomorrow. From an outsider, it's what makes our great game so exciting, sometimes the fate of your side is in the hands of another's. Enjoy the ride the best you can.

Thanks for the insight, now **** off smartly.

 

[TheDarkDwarf]

I think this comes down to lack of preparation though. Don't we have a club psychologist - after the last decade we need someone specialising in PTSD - and that's just for the supporters.

LOL, mate I think it is too late, we have regressed to the point that mediocrity is our zenith.

 

[DemonTim]

Thanks for the insight, now **** off smartly.

He was adding discussion mate, don't be a sook just because we lost.

 

[ThePuppetMaster]

West coast ?? Goodwin was outcoached today, you lost to a team of kids.

We were outcoached - but we're also a team of kids.

We had to play horribly and you had to have everything go right to get it done

 

[Toump Ass]

Serious question:
Who gets dropped for Bugg when we play Sydney?

 

[ThePuppetMaster]

Serious question:
Who gets dropped for Bugg when we play Sydney?

Haha imagine that

 

[schmuttt]

We were outcoached - but we're also a team of kids.

We had to play horribly and you had to have everything go right to get it done

I thought two years ago that we may have to wait until Petracca/Hogan/Brayshaw got close to 100 games before we became a good side - unfortunately that might end up being the truth. Our current leaders were just so god damn bad today, I can't emphasize how disappointing that is.