-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Goddard remains a Saint
- Thread starter Joffaboy
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- May 1, 2002
- 12,018
- 20,331
- AFL Club
- Carlton
My Opinion is yes.
- Thread starter
- #29
Same dealer as Karl?
JeffDunne
TheBrownDog
I said for Carlton supporters
AW and co was what I was refering to.
Really sounds like you're over him.
No doubt we could give you tips on following a bottom side. Problem is most of us chose to live in the present rather than he past.
- Thread starter
- #32
Fair enough. Who will step up to take you to the premiership in the next year or two?
- Thread starter
- #33
That is a problem for some. Must be the AFL's fault. Them and their pesky rules and such.
- May 1, 2002
- 12,018
- 20,331
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Lets not get into criminal acts now.
thatd be below your club....
in all seriousness, i think you are 2 or 3 walls from a top 8 side, but got a hell of a lot to do before your a Premiership contender.
in all seriousness, i think you are 2 or 3 walls from a top 8 side, but got a hell of a lot to do before your a Premiership contender.
- Banned
- #36
More jokes joffa?
Carlton were one of the power side of the 90's, with some luck we'd have got 3 flags out of this period. 94 we were undoubtedly the best team but injuries at the business end killed us. 95 enough said. 93 and 99 lost grannies. 2000 injuries killed us at the business end. 2001 injuries killed us at the business end. With some half decent luck we could've won both those years. I definitely think we had both Essendon's and Brisbane's measure in 2001. 2000 you take down Hird and Kouta stays fit and it's a different ball game.
And you ridicule the fact that the draft finally caught up with us?
Are you ONLY on BF to rile me, because as we all know your slagging of carlton is only directed at the not so nice carlton supporters around here. What a joke of a man you are.
Goddard is a Saints player. I too wish him all the best - at least until the 30th.
Joffa you have an interesting way of measuring time since when has two or three years constituted a decade?
Joffa you have an interesting way of measuring time since when has two or three years constituted a decade?
- May 1, 2002
- 12,018
- 20,331
- AFL Club
- Carlton
My opinion this would be the side with the astericks being positions required;
Bowyer Thornton ******
Sporn Norman Lappin
Walker Scotland Waite
Camporeale Whitnall Houlihan
DeLuca Fevola Davies
******* Stevens Johnson
Fisher Teague Hulme Simpson
Jury Out: Livingston, O'hAilpin, Mott, Bannister, Wiggins, Prendergast.
** Koutoufides deliberately NOT included.
- Thread starter
- #39
Deej, this was a good news thread about the Saints. You get on it and firstly bring up the same old crap about Hamill, who incidently had not been mentioned once in the thread until you once again insulted him.
You then arrogantly deride the Saints and reckon we will go down the Carlton path to gain a premiership.
You then go back to a decade ago and crap on about being a power steam. Well you one one flag, which is good but certainly not the hallmarks of a power team.
Since the Saints played you in the 1996 pre season final you have won nothing and been involved in one GF. The Saints have won two preseasons (not much but better than Carlton) and made one GF.
However you continue to go on like Carlton are flipping Brisbane.
You came onto an upbeat positive Saints thread and littered it with your negative bile and hatred.
And the ultimate delusion, you think I am here to rile you. You are a nothing to me, and never will be. We all know you are a legend in your own lunch time cause you keep telling us how much money you have, which countries you have visited, what a great businessman you are. Funny how none of this self congratulation has impressed nobody but your own incredible ego and fragile self esteem.
if you dont like what i say, stay off Saints threads, or dont reply. Funnily enough your flawed character will not allow you NOT to respond. It is the type of bitter delusional little nobody you are. (Oh thats right you are worth a whole million dollars aren't you, why dont you tell us all again you gigantic tool
)
- Thread starter
- #40
Fair team on paper.
I take it you aren't just saying you need a back pocket and an onballer to win a flag.
I,m not sure about Whitnall, Sporn and Houlihan being the foundation that a flag is built on though.
How does that compare to us? let alone Brisbane!
FB Hudghton Penny Voss
HB L.Fisher Maguire Jones
C Dal Santo Ball Black
HF Hamill Riewoldt Guerra
F Milne Gehrig Koschitzke
Rucks. Knobel, Hayes, Harvey
IC. Goddard. Blake. Thompson. X.Clarke
Em. Baker. Schwarze. Montagna
- Banned
- #43
Let me get this right, I came onto this thread and littered it with my negative bile and hatred, is that right? RUBBISH. Go back and read it all again in order and you tell me who started the needling of Carlton fans first, and who came on and wished the man well.Originally posted by Joffaboy
Deej, this was a good news thread about the Saints. You get on it and firstly bring up the same old crap about Hamill, who incidently had not been mentioned once in the thread until you once again insulted him.
You then arrogantly deride the Saints and reckon we will go down the Carlton path to gain a premiership.
You then go back to a decade ago and crap on about being a power steam. Well you one one flag, which is good but certainly not the hallmarks of a power team.
Since the Saints played you in the 1996 pre season final you have won nothing and been involved in one GF. The Saints have won two preseasons (not much but better than Carlton) and made one GF.
However you continue to go on like Carlton are flipping Brisbane.
You came onto an upbeat positive Saints thread and littered it with your negative bile and hatred.
And the ultimate delusion, you think I am here to rile you. You are a nothing to me, and never will be. We all know you are a legend in your own lunch time cause you keep telling us how much money you have, which countries you have visited, what a great businessman you are. Funny how none of this self congratulation has impressed nobody but your own incredible ego and fragile self esteem.
if you dont like what i say, stay off Saints threads, or dont reply. Funnily enough your flawed character will not allow you NOT to respond. It is the type of bitter delusional little nobody you are. (Oh thats right you are worth a whole million dollars aren't you, why dont you tell us all again you gigantic tool
Dead set you aren't too bright are you. And really joffa, 'gigantic tool' what in heavens name are you thinking calling me such hideous and offensive things?
- May 1, 2002
- 12,018
- 20,331
- AFL Club
- Carlton
I'm saying in my eyes (Carlton supporters might not even agree) this team is the core we can build on to win a flag with but definitely play finals with.
Underestimate Whitnall, Sporn & Houlihan at your own peril.
- May 1, 2002
- 12,018
- 20,331
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Maguire @ CHB will NOT win you a premiership. Penny might.
Forward line is very good and capable.
Ruck is a weakness and Harvey cannot run out a full game (ala Kouta). You will need Goddard or a Montagna to stand up and replace him, with jury still out on both.
Black might not be around next year......wouldn't be including him in your long term plans.
So in summary, you need a ruckman, CHB and 1 onballer maybe 2 for Black's replacement, to give the premiership a shake.
Brisbane is in a class of there own and no side compares to them. The hope is that they fall away over the next year or two while we improve with our youngsters and depth via drafting.
My two cents and only because you asked.
- Banned
- #48
We have a clear & definite personality clash, but I clash with a lot of people of his ilk.
Go back and read who started the needling, actually i believe it could've been jeffdunne, enthusiastically backed up by your pirhana-like seagull friend.
Similar threads
- Poll
- Poll
- Poll
- Poll
- Poll
