Analysis Hawthorn rebuild: are they tanking?

Should Hawks Be Punished?


  • Total voters
    681

Remove this Banner Ad

Only four first round picks in their side tonight. One of them is Scrimshaw acquired for a future fourth. The others are Ward Weddle and Watson

They have plucked this team out of their ass. Probably the most extraordinarily efficient case of list management I can recall.

About to add Battle and Barrass and awaiting Mitch Lewis’ return. They’re flag favourites next year
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Only four first round picks in their side tonight. One of them is Scrimshaw acquired for a future fourth. The others are Ward Weddle and Watson

They have plucked this team out of their ass. Probably the most extraordinarily efficient case of list management I can recall.

About to add Battle and Barrass and awaiting Mitch Lewis’ return. They’re flag favourites next year
having a look at the games experience

Dogs have 14 players with 100+ games
Hawks have 13 with 99 games or less of experience


Really is coach of the year is Sam Mitchell
 
having a look at the games experience

Dogs have 14 players with 100+ games
Hawks have 13 with 99 games or less of experience


Really is coach of the year is Sam Mitchell
At worst Hawthorn will be +10 spots on last year's position. Chris Scott can beat that if the cats make the GF
 
having a look at the games experience

Dogs have 14 players with 100+ games
Hawks have 13 with 99 games or less of experience


Really is coach of the year is Sam Mitchell
Mitchell is the Leigh Matthews of this generation. Makes everything look easy in this sport. Brilliant mind.
 
Only four first round picks in their side tonight. One of them is Scrimshaw acquired for a future fourth. The others are Ward Weddle and Watson

They have plucked this team out of their ass. Probably the most extraordinarily efficient case of list management I can recall.

About to add Battle and Barrass and awaiting Mitch Lewis’ return. They’re flag favourites next year
Next year? They can win it this year.
 
When people remember this season they'll talk about Carlton choking their run home to finals, so yes I call it an almighty choke job over anything else. I don't rate the Hawks whatsoever, just as I don't rate Geelong. They are making up the numbers while the Blues are imploding
Just a reminder of the types of resident experts we have on here.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Cats vs Kens serial finals chokers
Hawks vs Bevos traffic cones

More evidence needed
"Don't rate them whatsoever" = befitting of the two sides that were thrashed as favourites in their week 1 finals.

It simply doesn't fit for the two sides who between them have won 15 of their last 18 games (excluding when they met) and thrashed two of the form sides in the comp in finals.
 
"Don't rate them whatsoever" = befitting of the two sides that were thrashed as favourites in their week 1 finals.

It simply doesn't fit for the two sides who between them have won 15 of their last 18 games (excluding when they met) and thrashed two of the form sides in the comp in finals.
Yeah totally
Sleep Yawn GIF
 
Care to make a friendly wager?

Which team out of Hawthorn and North wins a final first?

If North wins a final first, you agree to have Chief suspend/restrict your BF account for a period (two weeks? 1 month?)
If Hawks win a final first, I'll do the same in reverse.

I love making friendly wagers.

Time to collect.
 
Been saying it for years, draft picks is one thing but Development and Talent acquisition is another.
(ie picking the right players to complement the group)

We aren't alone in these areas, watch WC who don't have a coach shoot up the ladder in the next 2-3 years.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Analysis Hawthorn rebuild: are they tanking?

Back
Top