HumanMeatball
Brownlow Medallist
Elite result. We dominate the super draft
-
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Autopsy Roast, Toast & Changes for Saints
- Thread starter _RT_
- Start date
- Tagged users None
wegetpumped
Norm Smith Medallist
people don't get it yet that this season is going to do more good than it seems.
Broad - Takes nice intercept marks but is borderline best 22 in my opinion.
Balta - Club have ruined him with the chopping and changing of his position. Yze also has no idea where he belongs. Amateur the way he is handled.
Miller - Still hanging onto his game against Curnow but has been abysmal since. Not sold. Too weak a footballer to be the premier full back. Where's Blight?
Trezise - Can't kick the footy at all. Couldn't care less about any other attribute when he's skills are as bad as they are.
Vlastuin - Good player, started the season well. Makes a lot of horrible mistakes also but he's not alone.
Rioli - Good as gone, refused contact. Take the 2 first rounders and run. Has served the RFC well and a Richmond champ but the rebuild is well and truly on.
Ralphsmith - A shining light this season. Whatever he lacks in the skill department he makes up in his endeavor and hard running.
Prestia - Workhorse. Tried hard all day but his skills are waning and his unreliable on the injury front. 1 more year as we need some senior players around the club.
Banks - Doesn't want contact. Jury is out for me.
Mansell - Tries his guts out. But wouldn't get a game at most clubs if we're being honest.
Baker - Gone, served us well but we need the draft picks.
Green - Shame about the injury but was unsighted and until he was injured, I had no idea he was even playing.
Bolton - Terrible game, still want him to stay on but if he's checked out as much as he was today then he's cooked with us.
Martin - Hate to say it but not even a shadow of his prime. It's time.
Kozi - The least of our problems but cannot be our number 1 forward. If Lynch has another season like this year we are ****ed. As a number 2 or 3 he will be a threat.
Nank - Got absolutely smashed all day. Underdone? A worry.
Taranto - Will always win the footy but horrible disposal and often flat footed. GWS had the right players around him, we don't.
Hopper - Again looks flat footed. Might be a fitness issue. Needs a proper pre-season but it didn't look good today
Short - How he won a B&F is beyond me. Gives away a minimum of 3 goals a game. Consistently squibs contests. Shouldn't play another game for the rest of the season.
Brown - Plenty of talent but no edge to his game. Swinging him forward isn't the answer.
Campbell - Runs hard, tries hard, I'm not sure he is really as good as some posters claim.
Jack Graham - I'm honestly surprised West Coast are interested. Crab.
The draft can't come soon enough.
Balta - Club have ruined him with the chopping and changing of his position. Yze also has no idea where he belongs. Amateur the way he is handled.
Miller - Still hanging onto his game against Curnow but has been abysmal since. Not sold. Too weak a footballer to be the premier full back. Where's Blight?
Trezise - Can't kick the footy at all. Couldn't care less about any other attribute when he's skills are as bad as they are.
Vlastuin - Good player, started the season well. Makes a lot of horrible mistakes also but he's not alone.
Rioli - Good as gone, refused contact. Take the 2 first rounders and run. Has served the RFC well and a Richmond champ but the rebuild is well and truly on.
Ralphsmith - A shining light this season. Whatever he lacks in the skill department he makes up in his endeavor and hard running.
Prestia - Workhorse. Tried hard all day but his skills are waning and his unreliable on the injury front. 1 more year as we need some senior players around the club.
Banks - Doesn't want contact. Jury is out for me.
Mansell - Tries his guts out. But wouldn't get a game at most clubs if we're being honest.
Baker - Gone, served us well but we need the draft picks.
Green - Shame about the injury but was unsighted and until he was injured, I had no idea he was even playing.
Bolton - Terrible game, still want him to stay on but if he's checked out as much as he was today then he's cooked with us.
Martin - Hate to say it but not even a shadow of his prime. It's time.
Kozi - The least of our problems but cannot be our number 1 forward. If Lynch has another season like this year we are ****ed. As a number 2 or 3 he will be a threat.
Nank - Got absolutely smashed all day. Underdone? A worry.
Taranto - Will always win the footy but horrible disposal and often flat footed. GWS had the right players around him, we don't.
Hopper - Again looks flat footed. Might be a fitness issue. Needs a proper pre-season but it didn't look good today
Short - How he won a B&F is beyond me. Gives away a minimum of 3 goals a game. Consistently squibs contests. Shouldn't play another game for the rest of the season.
Brown - Plenty of talent but no edge to his game. Swinging him forward isn't the answer.
Campbell - Runs hard, tries hard, I'm not sure he is really as good as some posters claim.
Jack Graham - I'm honestly surprised West Coast are interested. Crab.
The draft can't come soon enough.
The bad news is we lost. The good news is we lost.
We could not hit the side of a barn passing or shooting for goal.
We could not hit the side of a barn passing or shooting for goal.
y not get a chinese massarge and some thai food instead ?
couldnt get ghonnorhea in a brothel in Namibia
Hard to disagree with much of this at all.
Think you’re a tad harsh on Broad and Vlastuin though. Both were pretty handy today.
Aside from that, jeeez pretty spot on with most of it
The_Kraken
Club Legend
Whoever suggested we should shower him with cooked sausages is a genius. But the woke mob won’t let us
campaigners couldnt get a prize if ya shouted em a pick 20 in keno, still somehow miss
couldnt pick a trifecta if there was a late scratching in a four horse race
I thought Broad and Vlastuin were good but it's hard to erase the memory of Broads season overall despite the last 2 weeks. Vlastuin perhaps a little harsh but I'm angry posting.
With the GOAT sitting up on his shoulders!A rotten culture had set in to our club. The rats are leaving the sinking ship. It’s now going to be decades for us to get back.
People want a statue of Gale
Put it all on the Doggies for the Flag!
Short needs a physio trained in stroke rehabilitation to re-teach him to keep his feet. He's constantly blown over by the wind of someone running around him. Also glad we traded for two elite midfielders in Hopper and Taranto who seemingly since they've become 'Richmond men' can't kick in a straight line over 15 metres.
I’m still failing to see how Broad has had a bad of a year as what some say? Think he plays his role pretty well and is a senior head to have down there.
Haha, angry posts are the most honest posts
Groupie_
time to return the traditional Richmond yellow
JGTI is genuinely better than tarranto
- May 20, 2019
- 2,457
- 7,718
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Maybe they will approve of vegetarian fake sausagesWhoever suggested we should shower him with cooked sausages is a genius. But the woke mob won’t let us
Serenity_Now
Club Legend
- Oct 7, 2019
- 1,651
- 6,289
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Philadelphia 76ers
Would rather win the next 5 wooden spoons than have our club play Gangnam Style after some campaigner kicks a goal 
Groupie_
time to return the traditional Richmond yellow
look what the afl did to us after our dynasty
tall poppy syndrome
tall poppy syndrome
Freddy Swift
All Australian
It is embarrassing to come last and get the spoon. There is nothing good about it. It’s all very well to say we’ll get the No.1 pick, but I would put money on it that we will stuff it up anyway and end up with spuds.
Short is absolutely putrid, I never want to see him again. You’d swear sometimes he’s deliberately trying to help the opposition.
I didn’t really want to trade Bolton, but I’m sick and tired of his half-assed efforts. He doesn’t seem to care anymore so we should get the best deal we can for him.
Dusty is beyond cooked and should retire. I can’t see what possible value he would be to GC. They don’t need him anyway. He shouldn’t embarrass himself any further.
Whilst I’m grateful for all he has done for Richmond, I feel that other than the flags and financially, Benny Gale is leaving us in as bad a position as when he took over. That may seem harsh but he said he wanted us to be like Geelong, well run and always contending. Well we’re nothing like that.
Short is absolutely putrid, I never want to see him again. You’d swear sometimes he’s deliberately trying to help the opposition.
I didn’t really want to trade Bolton, but I’m sick and tired of his half-assed efforts. He doesn’t seem to care anymore so we should get the best deal we can for him.
Dusty is beyond cooked and should retire. I can’t see what possible value he would be to GC. They don’t need him anyway. He shouldn’t embarrass himself any further.
Whilst I’m grateful for all he has done for Richmond, I feel that other than the flags and financially, Benny Gale is leaving us in as bad a position as when he took over. That may seem harsh but he said he wanted us to be like Geelong, well run and always contending. Well we’re nothing like that.
I finally concede, my favorite player Jayden Short has to be dropped. He’s a liability out there.
Hopefully get up his confidence in the VFL next week. Why not try him up forward.
Hopefully get up his confidence in the VFL next week. Why not try him up forward.
