Autopsy Roast & Toast vs GWS, Rd 3 2019, & changes for Port

Best players vs GWS


  • Total voters
    177
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

That was brutal. Two beltings in a row. Skills were deplorable.

Out:
Short: injured
Martin: suspended or just plain shit. Take your pick
Ellis: scared footballer who has lost the talent he once has
Butler: only noticed him in the 4th
Garthwaite: not fit. Play Balta down back

In:
Houli: should be right to replace Shrot
Caddy: best 22
Grimes: best 22
Ross/Bolton: give him a go
Moore: play him up forward and Balta down back

Graham and Castagna only lucky so many players were worse
 
This is my side for next week

Broad, Astbury, Garthwaite
Houli, Grimes, Vlastuin
Edwards, Cotchin, McIntosh
Lambert, Lynch, Higgins
Towner, Caddy, Rioli
Nank, Martin, Prestia
Ross, Graham, Stack, Coleman-Jones
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Improvement on the previous week but we aren’t having a good run with injuries and a few players are out of form. I thought we kind of found some form though. Players like Balta, Lynch are still learning how we play etc and it’s harder when stars are out injured or out of form like Dusty
 
I know we're struggling so no point having a melt but what I can't forgive is Dimma's stubbornness and refusal to tag players. I mean, Graham and Ellis are absolute workhorses with serious limitations with the ball yet we don't use them to tag opponents when they get 40+ touches?

Last week we see WCE tag Coniglio and another player (can't remember who) and they totally shut down GWS.... But we are above that? We'd rather let them rack em up and get slaughtered?

Staggering.
 
This is why I wanted us to go in and make 7-8 changes to last week's side. We were not getting the effort required from those down on form last week and they pretty much repeated their performance again this week.

Richmond, don't be gutless and actually make unforced changes this week!
 
All of our leaders need a kick up the arse. Balta and Stack were a real shining light. Dimma needs a plan B. Our 2017 plan got found out halfway through last year, and like 2017 we need a mid season tactial rethink. At least that shit is over and now it's time to watch Victory, a team that's always hungry despite success.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Autopsy Roast & Toast vs GWS, Rd 3 2019, & changes for Port

Back
Top