Search results for query: *

One of the better posts on bf for a while. Very interesting.

looks like tarzan plays like jane

total crowds for the H&A season; 2011 Collingwood 1,269k Essendon 1.093k Carlton 1,090k next Richmond 895k 2010 Collingwood 1,306k Carlton 1,046k Essendon 1,009k next Geelong 983k 2009 Collingwood 1,189k Carlton 1,099k Essendon 1,089k next Hawthorn 892k 2008...

Carlton, Collingwood, Essendon, West Coast Richmond would be back in there with a little success. Adelaide seems to have gone backwards the last few years but should return with the move to Adelaide Oval. Geelong are next in line of the Vic clubs, Fremantle of the interstate clubs...

agree, travis cloke would be the one the blues would want.

Great thread:thumbsu: Not sure what excuse they will use in 2012 but they need one with their no talent list.

Let me guess; Pendelbury A Wellingham C Dawes C+ Toovey D Jordan Russell C

Fair point. Can I start a poll comparing Earl Spalding to Warren Tredrea as I think this is a more reasonable comparison.

This poll should have been closed as nothing more than a troll. Kernahan is one of the all time greats. Tredrea was a good but not great.

:thumbsu: Spot on. Can not believe some supporters could be so dumb. His disposal is terrible. the WORST 150+ game player ever.

Not so sure. I think the other 3 all have superior finals records.

no pun intended :) just very disappointed in his game. obviously other supporters just accept his disposal. hendo seems to be the whipping boy but he is a young player that can improve. carazzo is not going to get any better and he will cost the blues in september if still getting a...

5 - Heath Scotland 4 - Chris Yarran Daylight 3 - Murphy 2 - Betts 1 - Garlett WOG 5 - Carazzo 4 - Warnock 3 - Henderson 2 - Austin

Good call. The heat certainly needs to be turned onto Carazzo. His disposal is terrible and not getting any better. Needs to be out of the team by September.

Great work. Close to the best post I have seen on BF.

Very interesting stats. Also shows how any "big 3 or 4" can change. In the 50's and early 60's there was a "big 2" Melbourne and Collingwood. By the late 60's through to the 80's the "big 3" were Richmond, Carlton and Collingwood. In the 90's the "big 3" changed to Carlton, Essendon...

Personally I hate any jumper that includes an animal. Hawthorn clash, Adelaide clash, Eagles all, Lions all (their original one with the smaller lion was ok), Bulldogs (please go back to the jumper worn in Ted Whitten's time), Geelong clash

Interesting post. On those numbers you wonder why the AFL has moved Essendon and Carlton to the Docklands. Would make more sense to have Collingwod, Carlton and Essendon all playing out of the MCG.

well written to both of the above. Everytime we do one of these exercises I think you need alternatives rather than just bagging players. For the record I would look at bringing in either Lucas or Armfield for Collins. Obviously Kruezer comes in for Hampson once fit. Also I was...

you obviously have low standards.

and ratten to.. long bombs to eddy betts love it

You nominate who you think should be added and I will confirm either way.:thumbsu:

As per the title :)

anyone who votes for watson obviously does not watch much footy. watson is an excellent ball winner but cannot kick or run murphy can win his own ball, kick and run murphy easy:)

Honestly its Collingwood then a huge gap. Without Anzac Day Essendon would be behind Carlton. To summarise its Collingwood then a gap to Carlton, Essendon and Richmond making up the top 4. Melbourne and Geelong are on the next level followed by Hawthorn and St Kilda.

Since 1897 there have been 132 h&a games that have drawn a crowd of 70k+. There were no games pre-1950's that drew 70k+ as the games were all played at the small suburban grounds aside from Melbourne. In the 1950's Melbourne games against Collingwood at the MCG started to draw large...

Personally I love Collingwood supporters. Provide huge laughs. For the first time in 80 years they have the best team in the comp and rather than enjoy this they complain when they do not win a brownlow???:D Hope their natural negative attitude takes over and ruins what should be a...

Chris Judd the greatest player of our life time!!!!!!!!

Forgot about Luke Hodge being appointed captain. Another mistake. Very ordinary second half of the season. At best he is a HBF otherwise there is no room for him.