List Mgmt. 2019 Trade Thread - Part V

[SaintsSeptember]

I think his brother kept improving each year and goes at the ball a lot harder than ed , We have too many good runners , DMac , Geary , Phillips ect and none of them can get the ball , add Sincs into that list

Geary averages 19 disposals per game. More than Newnes, Webster, Acres or Coffield did. 10th highest disposals per game for the team.
Sinclair averaged 17. He's up and down, best this year 26, worst 9.

Phillips ( 21 YO ) average dropped from 19 last year to 15 this year. Not sure exactly what the role with. His issues are more to do with kicking, disposal and decision making.

McKenzie averaged 11, only small forwards, ( Hind , Parker ) , key defenders, and the delisted average less.

 

[pebblesofsand]

Its always funny reading all the comments about DMac.

After 35 drafts Pick 22 averages 45 games per player. How many games has DMac played so far?

Not spectacular but certainly a contributor.

 

[Mowman]

Every team needs a scapegoat, if we just head into the season willy nilly without at least a B grade scapegoat we could be in for some serious trouble/forum bans

We have plenty of scapegoats without adding Masten

 

[Saints43]

To me people who drive without a license is an indicator of a particular mindset.

Now i'm old school, i harken from the days where you push your luck drink driving and speed, a lot.
I have lost my license, but it would have been a clear other step to then drive without it.
For me it was a wake up call.

Road safety do gooders would tell you that speeding and driving under the influence are very serious crimes indeed, so i'd consider driving unlicensed right up there.

What you did was really bad. But not quite as bad as him. So he's an absolute ****wit.
But you're alright.

 

[cooperg]

I can't honestly say a name but we have a DFA.

Cannot say who. When I can I will.

 

[CaptainRisky]

Geary averages 19 disposals per game. More than Newnes, Webster, Acres or Coffield did. 10th highest disposals per game for the team.
Sinclair averaged 17. He's up and down, best this year 26, worst 9.

Phillips ( 21 YO ) average dropped from 19 last year to 15 this year. Not sure exactly what the role with. His issues are more to do with kicking, disposal and decision making.

McKenzie averaged 11, only small forwards, ( Hind , Parker ) , key defenders, and the delisted average less.

So Geary gets it 19 times a game , how many are to our advantage
Sinclair gets it 17 times as a mid - winger -half forward thats nothing to get excited about i wouldn't think and Phillips you pretty much explained he doesnt get it enough and even when he does get it does nothing with it ,
Im sorry i dont have the love for these blokes as you do but if we are ever going to be a top team none of them will be in the side IMO
The point which i probably didnt make clear is our best runners dont cause any damage ,

 

[SaintsSeptember]

What you did was really bad. But not quite as bad as him. So he's an absolute *******.
But you're alright.

No.
What i did was a mistake and when i was penalised, I took my punishment and didn't do it again.

What he did was a mistake, then he purposely ignored the penalty , made another mistake, was forced to cop a punishment , but carried on regardless.
I didn't make my mistake into a lifestyle.

 

[CaptainRisky]

I can't honestly say a name but we have a DFA.

Cannot say who. When I can I will.

Oh that Girl from high school is back again

 

[CaptainRisky]

Its always funny reading all the comments about DMac.

After 35 drafts Pick 22 averages 45 games per player. How many games has DMac played so far?

Not spectacular but certainly a contributor.

How many would he have played in a good team ,,, not many at all id be guessing

 

[SaintsSeptember]

So Geary gets it 19 times a game , how many are to our advantage
Sinclair gets it 17 times as a mid - winger -half forward thats nothing to get excited about i wouldn't think and Phillips you pretty much explained he doesnt get it enough and even when he does get it does nothing with it ,
Im sorry i dont have the love for these blokes as you do but if we are ever going to be a top team none of them will be in the side IMO
The point which i probably didnt make clear is our best runners dont cause any damage ,

1: Don't know but you said he couldn't get the ball.
2: No nothing to get excited about, but he has good and bad games, his better games mean he's good enough to keep for depth.
3: Ed is 21YO and has had plenty of games where he had more than 20 touches.

Your revised statement is more accurate , except Geary isn't as negative as you may think.
Pretty sure no-one at the club would agree with what you say about Geary not being in a top side.
As for the others, i can't fit them in if Hannebery, Jones, Hill, Billings, Gresham, Steele, etc are all playing. But they are good to have on the list.

 

[CaptainRisky]

No.
What i did was a mistake and when i was penalised, I took my punishment and didn't do it again.

What he did was a mistake, then he purposely ignored the penalty , made another mistake, was forced to cop a punishment , but carried on regardless.
I didn't make my mistake into a lifestyle.

One question , how many times did you drink drive or speed even though you knew it was against the law ?
We have all made mistakes , maybe some dont wake up and go , sh1t i better stop doing that as quick as others , and Ps , yes i have lost my license twice when i was in my late teens for being a d1ck so im not judging you

 

[CaptainRisky]

1: Don't know but you said he couldn't get the ball.
2: No nothing to get excited about, but he has good and bad games, his better games mean he's good enough to keep for depth.
3: Ed is 21YO and has had plenty of games where he had more than 20 touches.

Your revised statement is more accurate , except Geary isn't as negative as you may think.
Pretty sure no-one at the club would agree with what you say about Geary not being in a top side.
As for the others, i can't fit them in if Hannebery, Jones, Hill, Billings, Gresham, Steele, etc are all playing. But they are good to have on the list.

Everyone loves how Gears goes about it no doubt , he just lacks the polish of a top player IMO

 

[BrutThough]

So Geary gets it 19 times a game , how many are to our advantage
Sinclair gets it 17 times as a mid - winger -half forward thats nothing to get excited about i wouldn't think and Phillips you pretty much explained he doesnt get it enough and even when he does get it does nothing with it ,
Im sorry i dont have the love for these blokes as you do but if we are ever going to be a top team none of them will be in the side IMO
The point which i probably didnt make clear is our best runners dont cause any damage ,

Sinclair needs to get it more but he is the perfect example of quality over quantity when it comes to possessions.

Now if he could get back to be a 22 disposals a game player than the 17 disposal player of last year, we would be a better side.

 

[CaptainRisky]

Sinclair needs to get it more but he is the perfect example of quality over quantity when it comes to possessions.

Now if he could get back to be a 22 disposals a game player than the 17 disposal player of last year, we would be a better side.

Correct , he needs to give us minimum 22 per game or he maybe in trouble

 

[St Pauls]

I can't honestly say a name but we have a DFA.

Cannot say who. When I can I will.

Hoping it is one of:

Partington
Hibberd
Archie Smith

 

[Virgin Dog]

Hoping it is one of:

Partington
Hibberd
Archie Smith

I can't honestly say a name but we have a DFA.

Cannot say who. When I can I will.

Lukas Webb from the Dogs could be alright too. Beautiful user of the ball and great overhead, but has struggled with various serious injuries during his time with the Dogs. Was our best VFL player, but couldn't crack into our midfield or half back, and after 5 years it just seems his time was up. I reckon he could do really well at a number of clubs if someone gives him a lifeline

 

[SaintsSeptember]

One question , how many times did you drink drive or speed even though you knew it was against the law ?
We have all made mistakes , maybe some dont wake up and go , sh1t i better stop doing that as quick as others , and Ps , yes i have lost my license twice when i was in my late teens for being a d1ck so im not judging you

I lost my license long enough that i couldn't lose it more than once in my late teens

 

[Johnnyrayflamingo]

DFA coming up folks.

 

[Snailspace13]

DFA coming up folks.

Yep Carlton have given us Newnes back

 

[Saintbloke]

Correct , he needs to give us minimum 22 per game or he maybe in trouble

Sincs, like quite a few of our players, needs to contribute over 4 quarters, not drift in and out of games. If we can get more consistency out of these guys, we will start winning more games.

 

[Premium]

Sinclair needs to get it more but he is the perfect example of quality over quantity when it comes to possessions.

Now if he could get back to be a 22 disposals a game player than the 17 disposal player of last year, we would be a better side.

Sinclair might benefit from Richardson moving on , it might let him become more attacking.
Whatever happens he has to impact the game more or he will find he will be losing his position to one of the younger guys.
Sinclair is one of our best runners and best users of the football, he is now at the age where he could easily have a huge season and show us he is best 22 - I can only hope.

 

[Sir Skid]

DFA coming up folks.

Who we got Scoop?

 

[CaptainRisky]

I lost my license long enough that i couldn't lose it more than once in my late teens

Hey , at least you had a good crack at it

 

[SaintSteele9]

Masten my guess. Totally uneducated one to be clear

 

[CaptainRisky]

DFA coming up folks.

I fail to see what the problem is to spill it , we are not talking about pick 1 in the draft FFS , maybe you just love the attention