Rumour 2024 Hypothetical trade and FA Thread

[Iceman!]

If you can’t have a laugh at your own expense an internet forum is a really bad place to be. Plus, you’re a Panthers supporter, you’ve had it too damn good for too damn long.

More than happy to laugh at myself, heck i will happily tag myself in these posts when Barrass gets a norm smith medal in the Brown and Gold!

Also i copped us being the laughing stock of the NRL for most of my life before this period! Let me enjoy it while it lasts thank you! I am already dreading going back to the dark days

 

[smish]

Y'all got anymore of those ITK updates

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

Y'all got anymore of those ITK updates

I can confirm we will know more about Battle and Barrass next week. You heard it here FIRST!

 

[Bugs1977]

Y'all got anymore of those ITK updates

Cold turkey for at least another week Smish

 

[Holy Rioli]

Can we not make “likes” on Instagram a story.

What about the part where our club was disappointed in his preseason efforts?

 

[Flukey!]

Y'all got anymore of those ITK

With themessiah34 and projectdingley no longer active, unfortunately all the real insights have dried up.

# willbemissed

 

[butlers hawks]

With themessiah34 and projectdingley no longer active, unfortunately all the real insights have dried up.

# willbemissed

 

[threesixpio]

With themessiah34 and projectdingley no longer active, unfortunately all the real insights have dried up.

# willbemissed

Was hoping he’d have an update on Barrass

 

[Ned Ryerson]

With themessiah34 and projectdingley no longer active, unfortunately all the real insights have dried up.

# willbemissed

He's presently on a Twitter warpath about Ethan Phillips playing this week because he's a definite inclusion should we make week 1 of finals. # HeardItHereFirst

 

[Nugett]

With themessiah34 and projectdingley no longer active, unfortunately all the real insights have dried up.

# willbemissed

There is Celebrity101 doing the rounds on the main board

 

[BIGHAWK23]

He's presently on a Twitter warpath about Ethan Phillips playing this week because he's a definite inclusion should we make week 1 of finals. # HeardItHereFirst

My favourite is Finn is the worst player in the league

 

[threesixpio]

My favourite is Finn is the worst player in the league

Mine was that trading in Barass would cause a hole in the space time continuum. Pretty sure it won’t

 

[Ned Ryerson]

My favourite is Finn is the worst player in the league

And Ward not far behind apparently. Great Hawthorn person talking down our players like that.

 

[hawk for 37]

Not at all, all opinions welcome - just as mine is. Which is - on current form, the list managers are doing great.

Imagine if we landed McKay or Rata..our targets last year. Not sure we would be as glowing. List managers dodged 2 large bullets.

Far bit of good fortune involved.

 

[tl92]

Imagine if we landed McKay or Rata..our targets last year. Not sure we would be as glowing. List managers dodged 2 large bullets.

Far bit of good fortune involved.

Think McKay would be doing fine at the hawks. Esava was bizarre even at the time.

 

[TONYC3163]

Imagine if we landed McKay or Rata..our targets last year. Not sure we would be as glowing. List managers dodged 2 large bullets.

Far bit of good fortune involved.

Fair, though I wonder how McKay would have gone at hawks. I think okay.

 

[PenAndPaper]

Fair, though I wonder how McKay would have gone at hawks. I think okay.

We would want him to dish it off to the runners, problem is the bloke can't hit a handball or kick to save his life.
He's a poor man's Frost.

 

[Ned Ryerson]

Imagine if we landed McKay or Rata..our targets last year. Not sure we would be as glowing. List managers dodged 2 large bullets.

Far bit of good fortune involved.

And we all remember Massimo being in AA form last year playing on the wing for Essendon.

 

[MazHawk]

And we all remember Massimo being in AA form last year playing on the wing for Essendon.

I should post this somewhere else, but since you mentioned Massimo and Essendon go read Cam Rose's article in The Roar.
It's a beautiful thing.

Edit: Sucha great sentence: "Massimo D’Ambrosio was under-developed so far backwards under Scott that he left the club and is now, under a proper coach, knocking on the door of All-Australian contention at Hawthorn."

 

[earthworms]

Y'all got anymore of those ITK updates

situation is 1085% fluid

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

What about the part where our club was disappointed in his preseason efforts?

The first 5 rounds suggests he wasn't on his lonesome.

 

[hfc70]

And we all remember Massimo being in AA form last year playing on the wing for Essendon.

If Mass was still at the scum, he’d be closer to Alcoholics Anonymous than
All-Australian (who could blame him)

Is very close to recruit of the year.

 

[Ned Ryerson]

I should post this somewhere else, but since you mentioned Massimo and Essendon go read Cam Rose's article in The Roar.
It's a beautiful thing.

Edit: Sucha great sentence: "Massimo D’Ambrosio was under-developed so far backwards under Scott that he left the club and is now, under a proper coach, knocking on the door of All-Australian contention at Hawthorn."

Definitely well put. And that’s exactly what I was getting at. We saw something in Mass, and we’ve unleashed it. Saying the list management team made mistakes in targeting Esava and McKay is an unfounded point because we have no idea how well they could have done under our current coaching regime.

 

[kazzooka]

I should post this somewhere else, but since you mentioned Massimo and Essendon go read Cam Rose's article in The Roar.
It's a beautiful thing.

Edit: Sucha great sentence: "Massimo D’Ambrosio was under-developed so far backwards under Scott that he left the club and is now, under a proper coach, knocking on the door of All-Australian contention at Hawthorn."

What's funny is Brad Scott is a decent coach but at a terrible club. Essendon have now got Hird a gig in the VFL to prep for his reinstatement as Essington coach.

 

[bigmaxi]

So the question then is, is he worth a first or second round pick?

No the real question is……How many Instagram followers?