List Mgmt. 2024 Trade Thread - No.3

[BrutThough]

Reid is better than Wilson but are we happy with what Wilson brings to the team?

Wilson would be equivalent to probably any of the top 8-10 this draft. I would just hold 7 & 8

Agreed.

I would consider a deal with 15+16 but thats only because I think Taj Hotton is as good as the top 5 prospects and should be available. But going to the draft with 7+8 is an incredible spot to be in.

 

[Sully111]

As I said before, happy to hold 7 and 8. I don't want to split for later picks

I'd still like to see Macrae happen.

 

[snails13]

Looks like Collingwood and Carlton will be based at the MCG every Rd in 2025

 

[King_Steele]

Looks like Collingwood and Carlton will be based at the MCG every Rd in 2025

Whats new..

 

[akaifu]

Agreed.

I would consider a deal with 15+16 but thats only because I think Taj Hotton is as good as the top 5 prospects and should be available. But going to the draft with 7+8 is an incredible spot to be in.

Lindsay vs Hotton+Hynes

Who are people taking?

 

[Saints TV]

Do North wanna move from 2 to help facilitate Houston?

 

[bergholt]

Hopefully the Eagles just string Carlton along for a few hours and then eventually say "yeah nah just joking, of course we're not doing that".

 

[stavro#4]

hypothetically, Would you do:

2+25 for 8+F1?

They can go land gold coasts 13 or Freo’s 11 with our F1 and land Houston.

Overall: North get Houston + P8



We Get: 2+25

 

[HeavenlySources]

hypothetically, Would you do:

2+25 for 8+F1?

They can go land gold coasts 13 or Freo’s 11 with our F1 and land Houston.

Overall: North get Houston + P8

for

We Get: 2+25

every day of the week

 

[BrutThough]

Lindsay vs Hotton+Hynes

Who are people taking?

In this example, give me the double shot.

 

[RWB4life]

hypothetically, Would you do:

2+25 for 8+F1?

They can go land gold coasts 13 or Freo’s 11 with our F1 and land Houston.

Overall: North get Houston + P8

for

We Get: 2+25

Happily fos or Lalor is worth the upgrade from 8 and a f1

 

[snails13]

That’s one of the worst deals I’ve seen in any sport. Save some coin for Harley in a few years because there’s no way West Coast are getting out of a rebuild any time soon.

They will probably contact Laura Cain for some assistance at end of 2025

 

[Joffaboy]

Lindsay vs Hotton+Hynes

Who are people taking?

If we have 15 and 16 and Hotton is on the board I take the risk. We will have a Smillie/Lalor etc @ 7.

So, in your scenario, I would take Lindsay (as I would take him @ 8 if we have 7 & 8)and probably Hotton.

Smillie
Lindsay
Hotton

from the first round is a haul that I could not argue with. Hotton a risk, but Bailey Smith is coming off an acl and he is a hot item for Geelong.

 

[Moorabbin Ghost]

We’ve made some bad trades in years gone by but giving away Pick 3 for Owies and Graham is just utter madness. Eagles fans should riot.

 

[Significant]

Lindsay vs Hotton+Hynes

Who are people taking?

Depending on what happens up front, and if people throw Murphy Reid in the group of top midfielders.

If 2 of Reid, Smillie, Langford, Smith are available at our picks, then take them. If only one is, I'd trade back.

Never know we could keep sliding Pick 8 for multiple F2, one place at a time, until we are happy or we don't get offers.

 

[marcus1232]

Or are Carlton gonna knock on melbournes door next now they have ammunition for trac ?

 

[Spider Eater]

So Carlton have cut the Eagles lunch and are now selling it back to them in exchange for their dinner.
What a bunch of chumps.

 

[snails13]

If we have 15 and 16 and Hotton is on the board I take the risk. We will have a Smillie/Lalor etc @ 7.

So, in your scenario, I would take Lindsay (as I would take him @ 8 if we have 7 & 8)and probably Hotton.

Smillie
Lindsay
Hotton

from the first round is a haul that I could not argue with. Hotton a risk, but Bailey Smith is coming off an acl and he is a hot item for Geelong.

Shifter Sheahan on Trade Radio this morning said Hotton played 2 of the best games he has witnessed from any of the top15 players before he done his knee

 

[akaifu]

If we have 15 and 16 and Hotton is on the board I take the risk. We will have a Smillie/Lalor etc @ 7.

So, in your scenario, I would take Lindsay (as I would take him @ 8 if we have 7 & 8)and probably Hotton.

Smillie
Lindsay
Hotton

from the first round is a haul that I could not argue with. Hotton a risk, but Bailey Smith is coming off an acl and he is a hot item for Geelong.

Lindsay won't be available at 15

What I meant was:

Lindsay (pick 8)
vs
Hotton+Hynes (pick 15&16)

 

[my name was taken]

Poor Mini, over before it began

 

[Rogue Warrior]

Depending on what happens up front, and if people throw Murphy Reid in the group of top midfielders.

If 2 of Reid, Smillie, Langford, Smith are available at our picks, then take them. If only one is, I'd trade back.

Never know we could keep sliding Pick 8 for multiple F2, one place at a time, until we are happy or we don't get offers.

Can any one explain the practicalities of sliding back.
I.e. if the saints are on the clock with pick 8 and the giants call.
- Can the saints determine the exact player the giants take if we agree to let them trade up? And get them to sign something to ensure they don’t lie and take the player the saints want?

Or is it more based on your educated guess of who they are grabbing? If so, seems a huge risk

 

[marcus1232]

We surely just goto the draft with our 7/8 now

Tried to get 9 failed
Tried to get 3 failed

Is what it is

 

[Joffaboy]

We surely just goto the draft with our 7/8 now

Tried to get 9 failed
Tried to get 3 failed

Is what it is

#13 still a chance with GC

 

[Linton Street Saint]

That deal going through is going to kill Mini's senior coaching career before it even starts. History will show it as dropping generational talent, heavily linked if Reid walks and probably overwhelming seen as nepotism. SURELY like the Port board the Eagles board put a stop to it and threaten to sack the list management team.

I feel like it's ****ing bizzaro world this trade period.

 

[stavro#4]

Happily fos or Lalor is worth the upgrade from 8 and a f1

2+7+25+27