Certified Legendary Thread 4th Test Border Gavaskar Trophy December 26-30 1000hrs @ the MCG

Who will win?


  • Total voters
    42
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Happy to say I was there today. Still working my way through the thread, but wonder if our catching had been mentioned. Was really good, took a few tough ones.

The Smith catch to dismiss Reddy in particular. Which got me thinking...

I might be getting ahead of myself a bit here (I am) but hear me out:

Steve Smith currently sits at 192 catches in his Test career, putting him at 6th all time (list: https://www.espncricinfo.com/records/most-catches-in-career-283548)

We've got one more Test left in this series, 2 to come vs Sri Lanka in Feb, WTC in June, 3 Tests against WI shortly after (Jun-Jul) and then the Ashes next summer.

Now if he was to play every one of these Tests and maintain his current catches/matches rate, I've got him retiring at the Sydney Cricket Ground in Jan 2026 at #1 with 212 catches. :cool:

EDIT: As pointed out by Gough a few posts down theres also the minor issue of Joe Root having to completely forget how to catch - which I've got as likely given his trembling hands ahead of the prospect of scoring a century in this great country a year from now.
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

Just on the Jaiswal deflection for the umpteenth time, all of the replays show the right-to-left deviation on the screen.

Lets remember how steeply the ball dipped as well with Carey hitting the deck as he took it.
Sometimes there is a case of using cricket logic in decisions , this was a case in that .
The umpire not getting it right to begin with created the mess afterwards
 
Gough and Saikat are the on field umpires for the SCG test.

Unfortunately Joel Wilson will still be making decisions in this match though, this time as tv umpire.
I'm assuming they will have a back up TV umpire to review Joel's TV decisions also ?
 
Thick edge, clear deviation, close up shows contact.

No one worth listening to could think that is anything but clearly out. Even most Indian fans are saying it’s out. It’s not even worthy of a discussion.
 
Thick edge, clear deviation, close up shows contact.

No one worth listening to could think that is anything but clearly out. Even most Indian fans are saying it’s out. It’s not even worthy of a discussion.

Yes, twitter has actually been more tame then I thought it would be.

A few Indians doing tweets about the cheating Aussies by plenty of Indians saying the Aussies were too good and putting blame on their under performing players.
 
The Smith catch to dismiss Reddy in particular. Which got me thinking...

I might be getting ahead of myself a bit here (I am) but hear me out:

Steve Smith currently sits at 192 catches in his Test career, putting him at 6th all time (list: https://www.espncricinfo.com/records/most-catches-in-career-283548)

We've got one more Test left in this series, 2 to come vs Sri Lanka in Feb, WTC in June, 3 Tests against WI shortly after (Jun-Jul) and then the Ashes next summer.

Now if he was to play every one of these Tests and maintain his current catches/matches rate, I've got him retiring at the Sydney Cricket Ground in Jan 2026 at #1 with 212 catches. :cool:
Joe "never scored an Ashes hundred in Australia" Root has to turf most things that come his way if that's to happen.
 
Can very easily see him become another Clint McKay. Probably not quick enough at international level.

That said, Starc seemed like he was on his last legs and IMO shouldn't play the fifth. But I'd gamble on Richardson (Neser's apparently not available, which is a shame).

Spencer Johnson?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Joe "never scored an Ashes hundred in Australia" Root has to turf most things that come his way if that's to happen.

Shows how good Jaques was...my idol. 3rd in all time career runs. Average over 55. 6th in all time catches as well as 292 wickets to his name.
 
Just before any wickets fell this morning, I decided I couldn't cope watching anymore.

I don't know why I care so much, why it's become like this for me, but it happens with the footy too. I just find it way too stressful.

Instead, I spent the last session mashing the refresh button on this thread to follow the game.

I want to thank you all for providing me with an incredible commentary of the game, far better than anything on radio or TV.
 
Just before any wickets fell this morning, I decided I couldn't cope watching anymore.

I don't know why I care so much, why it's become like this for me, but it happens with the footy too. I just find it way too stressful.

Instead, I spent the last session mashing the refresh button on this thread to follow the game.

I want to thank you all for providing me with an incredible commentary of the game, far better than anything on radio or TV.
I do that too mate sometimes with the footy. Keep myself busy and check scores regularly if i feel like its a game i could go full Steven May at my TV. Ironically i find watching the bloody games anyway is more therapeutic and we win more often than not when i do somehow so my theory is stupid. :tearsofjoy:
 

"However, despite Marsh’s poor form, any decision to leave him out would not be taken likely given he is the nucleus of the dressing room as the ultimate team man."

Oh FFS! :rolleyes:
He can be the team man as ****ing 12th man… the series is still alive… picking him again might cost us this ****ing series yet.
 
I do that too mate sometimes with the footy. Keep myself busy and check scores regularly if i feel like its a game i could go full Steven May at my TV. Ironically i find watching the bloody games anyway is more therapeutic and we win more often than not when i do somehow so my theory is stupid. :tearsofjoy:
I don't feel that edge with cricket like football which means you can more genuinely appreciate the opposition's quality.
Bumrahs bowling in that session 4th day was enthralling
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Certified Legendary Thread 4th Test Border Gavaskar Trophy December 26-30 1000hrs @ the MCG

Back
Top