I think young forward would be worth a try. Hopefully they leave Miller back and let him establish himself Wonder what stage Bruer is at
Autopsy Roast Toast & Changes for Round 4 Gather round vs St Kilda.
- Thread starter Muddiemoose
- Start date
- Tagged users None
lizard man
Club Legend
- May 27, 2023
- 2,220
- 4,088
- AFL Club
- Richmond
I think we need to give Kosi another chance …. Not like there’s much choice
I thought brown grew over summer is now 206cm?
STRUGGLETOWN EST1885
The reward is in the grind
- Jun 28, 2020
- 6,417
- 25,428
- AFL Club
- Richmond
OK Guys and Gals. Terrible news on the injury front today and I'm sure we are all feeling a bit down after such a high yesterday. However crisis creates opportunity. I'm loving what Adem Yze is doing with his in-game changes. Not scared to throw the magnets around. Logic would say we have to bring in 2 talls up forward to replace Lynch and Balta. But do we ? Me thinks Yze might just go to a wildcard plan B. More speed and being unpredictable in the forwardline. High pressure swarming smalls, 1 or 2 big body mid size contested marking forwards and only the 1 big forward. A semi throwback to 2017. My gut says Yze and the match committee might just have the courage to do something outrageous. It's gonna be a helluva ride. Go Tiges.
- Nov 26, 2013
- 13,903
- 24,896
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Man U, Chicago Bulls, Anaheim Ducks
Bauer has to come straight in now
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Nah…Kosi was pretty insipid in the vfl…2 points (getable) and didn’t offer much else
Ryan 3 goals and Cray 2 were in our bests
Cray has the physicality and mongrel…repeat efforts and sets up play
Is worth looking at combining with Nank to rest forward
The one tall forward worked before because Riewoldt was elite and an all time great.
Kosi/Ryan/Lefau as our sole KPFs and we'll have absolutely zero structure.
We're stuck between a rock and a hard place now.
Any under 23 KPF prospects in the MSD?
- Jul 15, 2014
- 23,263
- 45,186
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Chelsea, LA Lakers, Western United
I’ll give that he had a better game against Sydney in the VFL yesterday, but he just seems like a mile off competing at AFL level. His marking, his efforts, his kicking in front of goal etc. aren’t AFL standard. He’ll just end up a liability if he brings that to AFL level.
If he gets an opportunity, then I hope he proves us wrong. But, I haven’t seen much that makes me believe he will unfortunately.
Naismith is there in case Nank goes down, I can't see the value in playing him ahead of Ryan who we need to have more of a look at anyway. He has gone well when in the ruck at AFL level, remember last year when he had one of the highest hit out to advantage percentages in the comp.
While he's been pretty uninspiring I guess that this is part of the reason we acquired Kosi, key forward depth. Again we need to see if he's worth persisting with at all. He wasn't as bad as the stat sheet would suggest in the VFL, if he had his kicking boots on he could've ended with 3 or 4. You would think he would be keen as mustard to try and take his chance with the knowledge he will probably get a chunk of games if he is picked next week.
This is assuming we want to keep the same structure. Martin as the FF in place of Lynch could be equally as effective or better than Kosi. If Grimes is fit do we think about Broad forward or something? At least he can take a grab and will compete and you're not stunting the development of Miller, Young, Brown.
Whatever the case we will at least find out about a few players over the next month I think.
While he's been pretty uninspiring I guess that this is part of the reason we acquired Kosi, key forward depth. Again we need to see if he's worth persisting with at all. He wasn't as bad as the stat sheet would suggest in the VFL, if he had his kicking boots on he could've ended with 3 or 4. You would think he would be keen as mustard to try and take his chance with the knowledge he will probably get a chunk of games if he is picked next week.
This is assuming we want to keep the same structure. Martin as the FF in place of Lynch could be equally as effective or better than Kosi. If Grimes is fit do we think about Broad forward or something? At least he can take a grab and will compete and you're not stunting the development of Miller, Young, Brown.
Whatever the case we will at least find out about a few players over the next month I think.
- Jul 15, 2014
- 23,263
- 45,186
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Chelsea, LA Lakers, Western United
Archie May from our VFL side would be worth a look IMO
rfctigerarmy
🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆
Agree with all of this. Nank / Ryan / Naismith and pickup someone in the MSD.
rfctigerarmy
🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆
No one even knows if hes still in Australia
Yze said Grimes would be back in…I think it will give us a chance to mix things up particularly with our talls
No point bringing in kosi needs to show more in the ressies, might as well bring in Ryan who kicked 4 or Naismith and perhaps go small forward line ala 2017
Lynch Balta maybe Baker and maybe Banks out maybe KMac out but I doubt it
INS from Ryan, Cray, Dusty, McAuliffe (Grimes bc Yze said so)
INS from Ryan, Cray, Dusty, McAuliffe (Grimes bc Yze said so)
if you've watched naismith in the VFL you can see he's easily able to play as a fwd option. the way he moves and leaps at the ball is top tier for a ruck and he's a big body who can use it. great CHF option
i'd have him come in as fwd ruck alongside ryan. kosi hasn't been in form so he's not the top option
i'd have him come in as fwd ruck alongside ryan. kosi hasn't been in form so he's not the top option
Muddiemoose
Moderator
- Aug 24, 2017
- 28,924
- 105,049
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #693
Ryan has more experience playing forward as well
Did it for a few games last year and looked alright in stages
Baker out..ffs
RICHMOND vice-captain Liam Baker has copped a one-game ban for his high hit on Sydney's Lewis Melican on Sunday at the MCG.
Late in the second term of the Tigers' nail-biting win, Baker went back with the flight of the ball and collected Melican, who was running forward to take a defensive mark. The Swan got to the ball first before being struck in the head by Baker's right arm as the Tiger jumped into the contest.
RICHMOND vice-captain Liam Baker has copped a one-game ban for his high hit on Sydney's Lewis Melican on Sunday at the MCG.
Late in the second term of the Tigers' nail-biting win, Baker went back with the flight of the ball and collected Melican, who was running forward to take a defensive mark. The Swan got to the ball first before being struck in the head by Baker's right arm as the Tiger jumped into the contest.
sante
Emu
careless, medium impact and high contact is the right call
there's no way you could call it low impact, melican is just lucky that his skull is extremely thick so his brain isn't able to rattle around
Baker no one gets hurt but cops a week. George Hewitt of carlscum clips Neale right on the chin with a clenched fist no suspension. Pendlebury too no suspension
GTFO corrupt AFL
GTFO corrupt AFL
Similar threads
