Autopsy Roast & Toast SF vs St Kilda & Changes for Port Adelaide

Your best five vs Saints

  • 1: Nick Vlaustin

  • 2: Dylan Grimes

  • 3: Dion Prestia

  • 4: Dustin Martin

  • 7: Liam Baker

  • 8: Jack Riewoldt

  • 9: Trent Cotchin

  • 10: Shane Edwards

  • 11: Jason Castagna

  • 12: David Astbury

  • 14: Bachar Houli

  • 15: Jayden Short

  • 17: Daniel Rioli

  • 19: Tom Lynch

  • 21: Noah Balta

  • 23: Kane Lambert

  • 25: Toby Nankervis

  • 29: Shai Bolton

  • 33: Kamdyn McIntosh

  • 34: Jack Graham

  • 35: Nathan Broad

  • 59: Marlion Pickett


Results are only viewable after voting.

Remove this Banner Ad

some would call me crazy but i actually like astbury in the ruck. Good strength and i reckon he is slow anyway so put him on another slow player
I think Dave was clumsy in the ruck early on, and Balta a bit shaky down back tonight.

I think Astbury needs to play on Dixon and Balta to be second ruck.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I was ropeable when lynch gave the 50 away and to knee him on the way up was nothing other then dumb. Can’t believe he’s put himself in that position

there’s nothing in it but the media will ride us all week. So unnecessary I can’t believe it.

good thing about tonight was we cruised after 1/4 time and have plenty in the tank for next week. Plenty can lift

still feel our mix is slightly off
 
Are people seriously writing us off already for next week?

**** come on guys we are into our 4th Prelim in 4 years. Enjoy the moment. Obviously don't remember the previous 35 years before 2017.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

agree with all except houli, was massive off half back

Poor decisions and execution a lot of the time, killing a lot of chains and had a couple of direct turnovers that lead to goals.
 
some would call me crazy but i actually like astbury in the ruck. Good strength and i reckon he is slow anyway so put him on another slow player
I agree. I think it's another reason to not panic and discuss getting Kreuzer, Bellchambers, Goldstein or other shittrucks in as cover for Soldo & CCj's few weeks next year.
 
Are people seriously writing us off already for next week?

fu** come on guys we are into our 4th Prelim in 4 years. Enjoy the moment. Obviously don't remember the previous 35 years before 2017.

4 years ago we would have killed just to win a final, now some are not happy because we didn't win by 70 points :p
 
solid game overall, could of won by alot more, what i like was we came out pissed off and controlled it from the start. Just a few moments we let them have it easy and made some annoying errors, but i guess that will happen in most games.

we can improve though, its obvious lynch coming in helps us so much, look much more dangerous.
also its so handy to have silky smooth player like shai dominate in mid and also in the fwd line when we need him

shedda dusty and lynch easy best ons, houli, nank, macca also huge

cotch a bit rusty and wasteful but i back him to improve

will be a tough game against port, i feel like if we play like this against port we will lose. we were at about 85% of our best, need to be at least 95% to win

doubt we will have any changes for next week too. the only possible one is pickett out
 
Saints wasteful? They scored 13 behinds. 9 were shots. 4 of them were rushed.

Lynch had 5 behinds himself and put 2 out on the full.

But only the Saints were inaccurate.

Senile old prick.


Toast:

Bolton
Sheds
Macca

Roast:

Cotch and Houli poor.
Calling Houli poor with 32 disposals 6 R50 5 I50 454m gained 6 score involvements 3 clearances 6 intercepts 7 turnovers 75%DE is a fair effort.
 
Saints wasteful? They scored 13 behinds. 9 were shots. 4 of them were rushed.

Lynch had 5 behinds himself and put 2 out on the full.

But only the Saints were inaccurate.

Senile old prick.


Toast:

Bolton
Sheds
Macca

Roast:

Cotch and Houli poor.
Agree with all but Houli was not poor. Made a couple mistakes, so what.
 
Nank excellent
Lynch Edwards Baker Dusty really good
Did well in the centre clearances tonight which is a must going forward..
I know it was dewy tonight but we will really need to clean up our possession against port ,seeing it's in Adelaide the Dew shouldn't be a problem... I like Broad back in the side needs to stay in
Astbury in the ruck worked well I thought he competes hard
I like that Astbury almost plays a tagging role on the Oppo ruckman. Just nullifies him. Nank was huge tonight. Stood up when needed. This was a good hitout for our underdone types like Prestia. Edwards superb. Keeps his feet and his head. If Bolton ever plays a whole game he's best on almost every time. Dusty good. Cotch solid. Bachar everywhere. Made a couple of errors but overall bounced back to form. Baker excellent. Big Tom looks good crashing packs. We were much more Richmondy this week.

Those saying we were shit don't understand the conditions and just don't understand football. Perfection doesn't exist except in the minds of people sitting on the couch with a beer yelling at the tv. This was a massive effort after last week.

Congrats to Dimma. Congrats to Cotch. Club Hall of Famers. Record breaking tyros. We're lucky to witness greatness.

Speaking of, D. Martin. Best.

Not sure how we will go against Port. It will be real backs to the wall stuff. Our best is good enough. Can we put it all together. They'd be more worried about us than we would be about them.

Having Broad back in seemed to give us the balance we lacked last week. Like how he plays in front and attacks the footy. JR doesn't usually play two quiet ones in a row.

Go Tiges.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Autopsy Roast & Toast SF vs St Kilda & Changes for Port Adelaide

Back
Top