Autopsy Roast & toast vs Melbourne and changes for Gold Coast round 6

Best vs Dees


  • Total voters
    182

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

Hardwick subs out Miller, then moves Balta out of an already depleted back line.

Result. Melbourne newby forward Van Roo dominates the final quarter kicks multiple goals.

Richmond smashed around the ball and in defence following Dimma's shifting the magnets.

Major coaching clanger.
 
Miller was a shocking decision as the player to sub out. Which resulted in the magnets being thrown around unnecessarily when the game was still up for grabs.
Balta was our best defender but then was moved in the ruck and forward. Battled hard in the ruck but our structure behind the ball was completely thrown off.

Also, bad kicking is bad football.
We should have won that game, but our set shot kicking let us down. Again.

Unbelievably frustrating. Again.
 
I'm puzzled by the fact hardick subbed out miller. Why not have miller play back and balta go forward and sub out I don't know mansell who's done very little all game.

Selection committee has lost the plot, I think they've all been invited to hardicks compression session.

Surely Jack Ross gets a game over HRS.

Bolton can't seem to get ball on foot he gets a few fresh air kicks a game.

Dusty has the yips, well everyone does.

Players seems to slip over at crucial moments.

We don't punish teams when they make mistakes but instead we allow them to destroy us and bend us over backwards (no lube)

No namers seem to destroy us, can someone tell me what a chandler and van rumen is?

Sign Jack for one more year.

I think this team will Click in rd 16 when the season is over, we won't loose a game after rd 16 bookmark it.
 
What a dissatisfying season so far , I really honestly thought we would go super close to another flag :(
its very disheartening isnt it? I feel it is for the players too. So much effort for patches of games, get on a roll and theyre up and about. Lots of scoring shots which eventually turn to poo and it sucks the life out of the tea,
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

When is the the flame going to be put on our senior players besides Jack and Rioli alot either went missing that half or killed us with errors all year.
 
We're still there abouts if we make the right changes. We break down a lot given the spuds in the side.

OUT: Ralphsmith, Mansell, Miller, Rioli jnr, Cotchin/Clarke, Brown
IN: Broad, Ross, Soldo, Sonsie, Van Rooyen

Grimes, Young, Broad
Vlastuin, Balta, Baker
McIntosh, Hopper, Pickett
Martin, Ryan, Sonsie
Bolton, Riewoldt, Cumberland
Soldo, Prestia, Taranto
Rioli, Short, Ross, Cotchin/Clarke
Sub: Cotchin/Clarke
 
I'm puzzled by the fact hardick subbed out miller. Why not have miller play back and balta go forward and sub out I don't know mansell who's done very little all game.

Selection committee has lost the plot, I think they've all been invited to a compression session.

Surely Jack Ross gets a game over HRS.

Bolton can't seem to get ball on foot he ball he gets a few fresh air kicks a game.


Dusty has the yips, well everyone does.

Players seems to slip over at crucial moments.

We don't punish teams when they make mistakes but instead we allow them to destroy us and bend us over backwards (no lube)

No namers seem to destroy us, can someone tell me what a chandler and van rumen is.

Sign Jack for one more year.

I think this team will Click in rd 16 when the season is over, we won't loose a game after rd 16 bookmark it.

Is it his high ball drop?
 
Loved Junior's dedication to the chase, his hit on Brayshaw was the highlight of the night. Good to see Jack still going strong but otherwise a bit of a nothing game for me. Melbourne too clean and strong in the end while our ball skills were lacking when we needed them most.
 
What an unfettered shambles the last two quarters were and entirely Dimma and the coaching committee.

Vlastuin’s form has been a disgrace. He’s travelled far enough on his past form and is now giving away goals each week from disgraceful efforts like waiting for Grimes to come across instead of sticking his opponent.

Maurice Rioli is not afl quality at the moment and should not be playing seniors.

Whoever teaches kicking at the club needs to go. We’ve been shocking since Choco left and is it any wonder he’s gone to Melbourne and turned them around?

We’re now too old and too slow. I’d be advocating really gutting the joint if we owned a first round pick.
 
I’d like to know who the people were behind the subbing out of Miller? Atrocious decision as it then took our best tall defender out of the game in Balta bc he was sent in the ruck and exposed Young? Miller was a needed player as we were struggling for height . It should have been kmac a like for like. Another issue was the inconsistency again of the umpiring, but kicking 3.7 after half time with five easy set shots missed is bad football.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top