I don't know how Simpson is more consistent because he "drives his possessions long ...
I like Foley's attitude, but his kicking is poor, and has always been his Achilles'. By contrast Simmo is an awesome kick, and just a higher grade talent. Do you remember Foley's last 1/4 in the last Blues V Tiges game? He was benched half-way through the last after Stevens ripped him apart and won the game of his own boot. Let's put aside Judd, Stevens, Murph and Gibbs. I'd rate Simmo, Walker, Scotland, Robinson, and Grigg ahead of Foley. What the Tiges really need is 2-3 elite midfielders. Jack Ziebell would have been an ideal draft choice for the Tiges. Right now everything's resting on Cousins shoulders.