Game Day Round 5: Collingwood v St Kilda, Sunday 16 April, 4.50pm, AO

[jmac70]

Embarrassing for you, nearly 50 years for me, what’s your point???


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

You’d think after 50 years of membership you’d learn to be nice to other members.

 

[KinderSmock]

Looks like Bianco & WHE are not playing in the vfl.

WHE is already out.

Allan isn't playing. Wonder if he may be handed a last-minute debut or something.

 

[swoop42]

Without being an expert on their list I'd say the best 22 players missing for the Saints (based on last season) are:

Webster 20 games in 22.
Steele ave 27 disposals in 22.
^Membrey 34 goals in 22.
King 52 goals in 22.
Jones ave 18 disposals in 22.
Billings ave 17 disposals in 22.

I haven't considered:
Hayes 5 games in 22.
Coffield 0 games in 22.
McKenzie 12 games in 22.

^Now available for senior selection.

For us:
Lipinski ave 22 disposals in 22
Howe ave 16 disposals in 22.
Cameron 20 goals in 22.
*Cox 18 games in 22.
**Hoskin-Elliott 24 games in 22.
***De Goey ave 20 disposals, 18 goals in 22.

*Still to be seen if we go with 2 ruck setup with Johnson and Ginnivan now resuming in the 22.
**Much maligned but still keeps getting selected under 2 coaches.
***Yet to be known if he is out.

I haven't considered:
^Kreuger 5 games in 22.

^Now available for senior selection.

 

[ThePhantom777]

Waiting....

 

[windchimes]

WHE is already out.

Allan isn't playing. Wonder if he may be handed a last-minute debut or something.

He wasn't an emergency so not possible I believe

 

[biggiemediums]

Out of two weeks in BigFooty jail; just in time for the game!

 

[Fat Jesus]

Bro, it's st.kilda. if we can't beat them today then we don't deserve to be in the finals

Agree
We have a few SA boys that will be eager to impress family and friends.
They will feel right at home.

 

[jmac70]

Out of two weeks in BigFooty jail; just in time for the game!

Who did you share a cell with?

 

[Fat Jesus]

Who did you share a cell with?

Bubba

 

[ThePhantom777]

Is DeGoey out?

 

[Harry O]

Is JDG a late out

WHE is already out.

Allan isn't playing. Wonder if he may be handed a last-minute debut or something.

Ed Allan is in Adelaide apparently

 

[Armoooo]

What a load of horse s**t, name the 9???


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

King
Steele
Membrey
Webster

These blokes are all best 22 under RL

Billings
Coffield
Jones

These blokes were all best 22 when last available.

Hayes
Allison

These blokes are unestablished, would have been fighting for the spot that Caminiti has captured.

We had something like 6 or 7 starting players missing ahead of round 1, but despite having more players get injured and none of them being back yet, I believe we're down to only 4 starters missing. This is simply because guys like Owens, Caminiti, Philipou and Stocker have all done enough to be the custodians of best 22 spots.

Give me a full list and personally I would only bring in King, Steele, Membrey and Webster.

Our injury list was always exaggerated by numbers alone.

Given we are missing our key forwards and you guys are missing your rucks (Steele and JDG cancel each other out), I don't think either team has much of an advantage based on availability.

 

[manicpie]

Ed Allan is in Adelaide apparently

He'll do, we won't need JDG to win this

 

[Fat Jesus]

He'll do, we won't need JDG to win this

Is he allowed to play if not named?

 

[ThePhantom777]

Is he allowed to play if not named?

Prob get fined... Worth it

 

[KinderSmock]

Is he allowed to play if not named?

Well if it's a late out, it may be acceptable. Either way, the fine they'll hit us with probably isn't significant.

 

[Fat Jesus]

Prob get fined... Worth it

He has Covid. Damn. There goes the Anzac Day debut I was hoping.

 

[eyeroller]

Ed has covid

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Ed Allan is in Adelaide apparently

Who says Ed is in Adelaide? Others are saying he's ill too... talk about rumour mill

 

[leon123]

That Abba is a gun mate.

And can belt out a tune and a song as well

 

[Fat Jesus]

And can belt out a tune and a song as well

Has two HOT sisters apparently.

 

[Jason22]

How about we all just wait and see re Jordy…feels like the same type of rumour that went around a couple weeks ago about Darc.

If it’s just illness, we won’t know till the last minute anyway.

Either way, got a good feeling today. Great opportunity for some other blokes to step up in JDG absence if so.

 

[Harry O]

He has Covid. Damn. There goes the Anzac Day debut I was hoping.

You can do anything with covid these days

 

[jmac70]

You can do anything with covid these days

Clubs are required to isolate covid positive players.

 

[anshell]

Worst time slot of all time. Sunday football is inconvenient enough, but 10 to 5!

We often get the bum’s steer from the AFL when it comes to timeslots.