Welcome Welcome to Adelaide: James Peatling - Traded with F3, F4 for F2

[AFC979810]

I don't think Dawson is a natural centre square mid.

Disagree. His 2023 was his best season in the AFL and he played as a center square mid (was All Australian in that role).

 

[Scorpus]

Wouldn't think so. Looking at the past 3 years of drafts - would say 75 - 125 should be the expectation.

Sure - generational talents like Harley Reid (395) & Will Ashcroft (221 before injury) and JHF (199) are in your range but I doubt we are getting one of those at pick 4 this year.

Plenty of others are in the more reasonable 75-150 range.

McCurcher (20), Duursma (0), Jed Walter (11), Sanders (114), Wardlaw (118), Tstatas (17), Humphrey (88), Mackenzie (79), Ward (144), Callaghan (120),Nick Daicos (26), Rachele (21).

Some of these are game time limited though

Sanders for example had a 28% CBA rate which was 114 CBAs, but only played 14 games. Across all 23 games that would be 187 CBAs.

Wardlaw at 48% CBAs over 8 games. That would be over 300 in a full season

Duursma, Walter, Humphrey and Rachele were not drafted as midfielders but mid-forwards or forwards.

If they played a full season (and I believe our pick 4 should play the entire season), guys like Reid, Ashcroft, Horne-Francis, Wardlaw, Sanders, Serong, Ginbey, Ward, Rowell would be all around that 200 to 300 mark. I would hope that in a strong midfield draft we could get a player with the quality of those listed, maybe not Harley Reid but a Wardlaw type would be great.

And there isn't the competition for midfield spots or results on the board to prevent it like there might be in a stacked midfield

 

[Rix31]

So it begs the question, can Peatling play anywhere else besides inside mid?

Kicked a few nice goals in that highlights package.

 

[AFC979810]

Some of these are game time limited though

Sanders for example had a 28% CBA rate which was 114 CBAs, but only played 14 games. Across all 23 games that would be 187 CBAs.

Wardlaw at 48% CBAs over 8 games. That would be over 300 in a full season

Duursma, Walter, Humphrey and Rachele were not drafted as midfielders but mid-forwards or forwards.

If they played a full season (and I believe our pick 4 should play the entire season), guys like Reid, Ashcroft, Horne-Francis, Wardlaw, Sanders, Serong, Ginbey, Ward, Rowell would be all around that 200 to 300 mark. I would hope that in a strong midfield draft we could get a player with the quality of those listed, maybe not Harley Reid but a Wardlaw type would be great.

And there isn't the competition for midfield spots or results on the board to prevent it like there might be in a stacked midfield

Thats because its incredibly tough to expect an 18 year old to play a full season in the middle at AFL level. Reid is truly the exception.

Pick 3 Noah Anderson is another that played 22 games and had 60 CBA's.

Think its terribly tough to expect our pick 4 midfielder to have 200-300 CBA's when the only two to do it from the past 5 drafts are Reid / Ashcroft.

 

[50BC]

So it begs the question, can Peatling play anywhere else besides inside mid?

Kicked a few nice goals in that highlights package.

Wing

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Is he actually best 22 and in the midfield mix when we have a fully fit list?

Does he come off the bench, play forward, or is he legitimately one of our first choice midfielders now along with soligo and rankine?

He’s part of the rotation and can also help with pressure with his speed when resting forward

Some days he might start in centre square depending on form

 

[Scorpus]

Thats because its incredibly tough to expect an 18 year old to play a full season in the middle at AFL level. Reid is truly the exception.

Pick 3 Noah Anderson is another that played 22 games and had 60 CBA's.

Think its terribly tough to expect our pick 4 midfielder to have 200-300 CBA's when the only two to do it from the past 5 drafts are Reid / Ashcroft.

I should have clarified that I meant 200-300 CBAs full season equivalent.

If he's rested a few times or injured and doesn't reach that level that's also acceptable.

If he's playing bulk SANFL or is spending 70%+ time outside the midfield when played, that's not acceptable

 

[Sizzlepack]

 

[ams4crows]

If this is the case why is it taking so long?

 

[PaythePerryman]

If this is the case why is it taking so long?

Probably haggling with Essendon on picks for Stringer/Shiel

 

[PaythePerryman]

Probably haggling with Essendon on picks for Stringer/Shiel

+Need point for Academy Logan Smith...so can't just hand over 53/56

 

[Orange crush]

If this is the case why is it taking so long?

Just be working out the picks we have after stringer /shiel

 

[50BC]

If this is the case why is it taking so long?

Don't panic, it will get done, but maybe not until Tuesday or Wednesday next week

 

[pjcrows]

If this is the case why is it taking so long?

Jostling for other deals. Standard.

 

[Anzacpaul]

If this is the case why is it taking so long?

Probably haggling with Essendon on picks for Stringer/Shiel

+Need point for Academy Logan Smith...so can't just hand over 53/56

Just be working out the picks we have after stringer /shiel

Don't panic, it will get done, but maybe not until Tuesday or Wednesday next week

Jostling for other deals. Standard.

 

[rabidcrow]

I actually think Dawson has less CBAs next year. Some of our younger mids can't play on the wing or half back effectively, but Dawson can. Think we maximise our team output with Dawson attending less CBAs

I think Dawson will be marshalling our defence next year - and being a key part of the ball movement coming out


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[George Kramer]

I think Dawson will be marshalling our defence next year - and being a key part of the ball movement coming out


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Huh? Why? We just brought in Cumming and our midfield still is our weakest link

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Disagree. His 2023 was his best season in the AFL and he played as a center square mid (was All Australian in that role).

Yep ideally he’s centre square mid with a couple of low to the ground ball hunters that have more speed / agility and can feed it out to him

Guys like Soligo Rankine Peatling M Crouch will do me

 

[Jeffcrowe]

I think Dawson will be marshalling our defence next year - and being a key part of the ball movement coming out


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Why ?

 

[Jeffcrowe]

I should have clarified that I meant 200-300 CBAs full season equivalent.

If he's rested a few times or injured and doesn't reach that level that's also acceptable.

If he's playing bulk SANFL or is spending 70%+ time outside the midfield when played, that's not acceptable

Out of the guys on our draft board I’d say Draper is the main one that could play > 50% centre square mid in his first season

Don’t think any of the others although alot can change in one pre season

Not any Harley Reid’s in this draft that’s for sure

Lalor needs to build his body resilience, endurance
Smith needs more strength and size
FOS is a hybrid mid / flanker with class on outside and needs to get his body right
Langford …. Maybe he could too actually , but also think it’s possible he’d play some sanfl

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Thats because its incredibly tough to expect an 18 year old to play a full season in the middle at AFL level. Reid is truly the exception.

Pick 3 Noah Anderson is another that played 22 games and had 60 CBA's.

Think its terribly tough to expect our pick 4 midfielder to have 200-300 CBA's when the only two to do it from the past 5 drafts are Reid / Ashcroft.

It takes an extremely rare player like you say

Harley Reid , Will Ashcroft

The 3 from this draft I would say are possible would be Levi Ashcroft , Leo Lombard and Sid Draper

All have form in centre square mid roles against men already and all have body type for it already

 

[rabidcrow]

Out of the guys on our draft board I’d say Draper is the main one that could play > 50% centre square mid in his first season

Don’t think any of the others although alot can change in one pre season

Not any Harley Reid’s in this draft that’s for sure

Lalor needs to build his body resilience, endurance
Smith needs more strength and size
FOS is a hybrid mid / flanker with class on outside and needs to get his body right
Langford …. Maybe he could too actually , but also think it’s possible he’d play some sanfl

Disagree with Smith. I think he could do more than Draper first up as shown by his VFL performances.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Freshj]

You would imagine they would be fairly careful with Draper given his recent diagnosis with the back issues too?

 

[Cromulant]

Disagree with Smith. I think he could do more than Draper first up as shown by his VFL performances.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Draper's SANFL performances weren't exactly bad....

 

[rabidcrow]

Draper's SANFL performances weren't exactly bad....

Not at all - but Smith wasn’t listed and his performances were at least on par with Draper, probably more prolific in truth


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com