List Mgmt. 2019 Trade Thread - Part IV

[bergholt]

My thoughts exactly. Hope it’s correct!

Yeah, it'd be fantastic for us. That would mean our trade period overall would be:

IN: Hill, Howard, Ryder
OUT: 6, future second

That would be a great result considering our original offer for Hill was 6 and the future second!

 

[SaintsSeptember]

nup ... my money is on they are waiting for maximum exposure for the announcment ... will come once WA wake up and get their day started ... all clubs will want the maximum exposure of it across the country

Well wake them up...make some noise.

 

[sauce_head]

The club.

I don’t hear that anywhere. Sounds like crap to me.

 

[Mat Mann]

There's another brother?!?!?

Wan. the lost triplet is Wan

 

[triggering bro]

I assume that worst case we use 12 (or get 10) and a future 1st with potentially something back.

I would be annoyed with that as Lethers has said we haven’t used future first, and also I think that it’s overs. But I’ve accepted this as a possibility and that we get the contracted player we chased.

But my fingers are crossed that it’s 12 (or 10) and something smaller than a 1st as we have all been discussing.

Latest reporting states “Freo will have a multiple 20’s picks”. They already have one so I assume they are getting pick 29 from Port in the deal.

 

[Saintos The ITK]

HERE WE GO!!!!!!!!!

 

[Aussieviking1]

IMO Longy's kicking style is susceptible. He drops the ball with two hands when kicking a drop punt so it is a slow technique. He seems to be better roosting it than directing it. I love Longy. Campaigner. However his lack of possessions and kicking style may be the reason he is being talked about as a trade.

Possible this is true my fellow concerned supporter however, is this not the reason the Saints recruited a particular chap from Hawthorn who was touted as the man who changed their game style, skill level etc.
Times are changing and I think issues such as you have presented will become opportunities.

 

[sauce_head]

Gee thanks for that , the point was we need to worry about getting the blokes who are going to make us a better team and a chance at finals in years to come , not a bloke that may or may not ever play for us again , you want to keep Stuv if he plays 3 games next year again do you ?
We all love the bloke but sometimes you just need to let it go

We can worry about more than one thing at once.

if it’s pick 57 I’d certainly prefer three games out of him for the year. Chances are Pick 57 will end up being nothing, not even three games worthy of a four time best and fairest winner.

 

[StCicatriz]

If we give up the future first with this year's first in the Hill trade we have absolutely lost all sense on a players worth.

I can't see it happening

 

[SaintSteele9]

I’d find it strange that Lethers would be so adamant that our 2020 1st will not be involved, then cough it up. Backing Satan on this

 

[AaronSCHQ]

There’s certainly the potential that Freo get their 2 firsts without us trading next year’s.

Several clubs involved so pick and player swaps may result in Freo getting 2 firsts, us not overpaying and all clubs being happy.

 

[triggering bro]

If we give up the future first with this year's first in the Hill trade we have absolutely lost all sense on a players worth.

I can't see it happening

Based on latest reporting I doubt we are giving up a future 1st. Marc McGowan’s mail been pretty good this trade period.

 

[2ballz]

Hm, what would that be overall?

Saints OUT: 12, 18, future second
Saints IN: Hill, Howard, Ryder

Port OUT: 10, 29, Howard, Ryder
Port IN: 12, 18, future second

Freo OUT: Hill
Freo IN: 10, 29

Seems to value Howard and Ryder combined at about pick 19, which is vaguely fair? https://www.draftguru.com.au/pick-value-calculator#Howard,Ryder,10,29|12,18,25

Reckon you're on the money here

 

[Coconut_twirl]

We can worry about more than one thing at once.

if it’s pick 57 I’d certainly prefer three games out of him for the year. Chances are Pick 57 will end up being nothing, not even three games worthy of a four time best and fairest winner.

Sam Fisher was a pick 55 odd. Maybe the next Plugger could be at pick 57. You can never discount it.

 

[LiterallyNobody]

I’d find it strange that Lethers would be so adamant that our 2020 1st will not be involved, then cough it up. Backing Satan on this

Me too

In Satan we trust


Why do you guys call him Satan btw?

 

[BrutThough]

Based on latest reporting I doubt we are giving up a future 1st. Marc McGowan’s mail been pretty good this trade period.

We better be getting something good back in this deal.

In no scenario is Brad Hill worth two top 10 picks.

 

[triggering bro]

Me too

In Satan we trust


Why do you guys call him Satan btw?

He’s a fallen angel sent to us by god?

 

[LiterallyNobody]

He’s a fallen angel sent to us by god?

Sounds about right.

 

[Saint Shags]

I feel like one of my kids....


Are we there yet?

 

[mob]

Yeah, it'd be fantastic for us. That would mean our trade period overall would be:

IN: Hill, Howard, Ryder
OUT: 6, future second

That would be a great result considering our original offer for Hill was 6 and the future second!

This would be my favorite scenario, if we could pull it off, Freo board will not be happy.

 

[LiterallyNobody]

We better be getting something good back in this deal.

In no scenario is Brad Hill worth two top 10 picks.

He won't be getting two top ten picks IMO - He'll get 10 and whatever and Port will get 12 and 18

 

[SaintSteele9]

He’s a fallen angel sent to us by god?

It’ll be exactly that if he pulls all of this off. I recall many Ameet avis after the Hawks pick swap, so expecting big things from us if it all gets done

 

[Groater]

HERE WE GO!!!!!!!!!

Here we don't. Seriously, every time someone says this I tune back into trade radio at the start of an ad break.

Wasn't this meant to go down this morning? What's the hold up?

I hope we're working on a backup plan.

 

[WRFL Indentity]

Simple. Ins costs add up to outs costs. Only big deal last was Hannaberry. No other big deals. Sorry

You asked someone about passing math?

 

[St Neil]

rumor that long is part of the bruce trade, do we want that?

Makes sense. They love him.

It depends on the picks involved. Not sure.