List Mgmt. 2019 Trade Thread - Part V

[Sir Skid]

I nominate Phillips and McKenzie, and probably any of the small forwards.

It was supposed to be one name, not a massacre

 

[St Neil]

Free Agrents we should be targeting next year:

Brad Crouch
Isaac Smith
Robbie Gray
Mitch Duncan
Zac Williams.

Degoey for trade.

De Goey is the one. Match winner. Mercurial. Electrifying. The only concern is his durability.

Go hard and blow Collingwood out of the water so they can’t match. Others may offer more but make sure Collingwood can’t match.

Then hope we’ve had a year where it’s apparent we are quickly on the rise. And sell the allure of Bayside Melbourne, its lifestyle, and the new facilities at Moorabbin.

Getting him would be amazing.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

It was supposed to be one name, not a massacre

its hard to know which ones will play seniors

 

[Sir Skid]

its hard to know which ones will play seniors

And that's a good thing for the players too.
They'll have to extract the digit to get a game from now on. Honeymoons over!

 

[Stewart66]

We can't have a go at Carlton. The last time we played them they beat us. Also, they will be rocket up the ladder over the next 2 years.

Can’t be that great ...still have Simpson , Kreuzer , Murphy , Betts ...all basically finished holding team together
Recycling their list with at least 10 players a year for last 5 years
and please don’t mention Casboult & Jones as champions ..they have a couple of nice players on their list
They only won the game because we in fact threw it away with inept goal kicking .. we will kill them .

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Can’t be that great ...still have Simpson , Kreuzer , Murphy , Betts ...all basically finished holding team together
Recycling their list with at least 10 players a year for last 5 years
and please don’t mention Casboult & Jones as champions ..they have a couple of nice players on their list
They only won the game because we in fact threw it away with inept goal kicking .. we will kill them .

Dammit we have half a dozen small forwards and none of them kick as many as Betts.

 

[NeXus Nick]

Can’t be that great ...still have Simpson , Kreuzer , Murphy , Betts ...all basically finished holding team together
Recycling their list with at least 10 players a year for last 5 years
and please don’t mention Casboult & Jones as champions ..they have a couple of nice players on their list
They only won the game because we in fact threw it away with inept goal kicking .. we will kill them .

I hope you are rightStewart66 but I'm not putting my house on it.
The way I see it, Carlton will go close to playing finals in 2020. In 2021 they will be top 4.

 

[Stewart66]

Dammit we have half a dozen small forwards and none of them kick as many as Betts.

Give it a break .. if Gresham plays as many games as Betts has had then look at it.
Really over the negative , listen to Hill excited to be at StKilda , listen to Howard really excited to be at
StKilda , listen to Jones really excited to be at StKilda , aren’t there yet, but confident additions on field
& off field are significant improvements going forward.

 

[Teflon]

Harley Bennell will be a Saint next year I've been told. Risky move if true.

Sounds cats bound not us..

 

[StCicatriz]

Harley Bennell will be a Saint next year I've been told. Risky move if true.

I'll take things that will never happen for $500 thanks George

 

[tbarker]

De Goey is the one. Match winner. Mercurial. Electrifying. The only concern is his durability.

Go hard and blow Collingwood out of the water so they can’t match. Others may offer more but make sure Collingwood can’t match.

Then hope we’ve had a year where it’s apparent we are quickly on the rise. And sell the allure of Bayside Melbourne, its lifestyle, and the new facilities at Moorabbin.

Getting him would be amazing.

He has been cruising Elwood for years. Off field antics are still a concern


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[austinnn]

Harley Bennell is joining Shane Warne's challenger ticket for the AGM.

Other plans include going all in for Joe Daniher, bringing back SOS and Ken Hinkley as list and footy manager, and poaching the Suns' last CEO. Drain the Swamp.

 

[Mstr Strokesman]

Here’s three opposition players we should think of targeting.
View attachment 770442
View attachment 770443
View attachment 770444

GOLD Grav,well played Sir.

 

[stfan]

So i have written many times about the injury curse i put on players when i choose to be their advocate . Lately its taken another turn . I was trying to work out who to take next year which wont hurt the club as much if they end up being injured all year . My choice came down to either Rice or White . The next day both were delisted . Two days ago i decided on Newnes , and now he has left the club . My options are getting very small now . All i can hope is that whoever i choose breaks my curse. As far as i can work out it will be between Brown , Phillips , Dmac , Marsh or Sinclair . Out of those 5 who can we afford to be without for long periods the most , lol.

Maybe go with Bruce. That way we get to beat the Doggies again

 

[ScrappyDo]

Harley Bennell is joining Shane Warne's challenger ticket for the AGM.

Other plans include going all in for Joe Daniher, bringing back SOS and Ken Hinkley as list and footy manager, and poaching the Suns' last CEO. Drain the Swamp.

The longer you stay away the more socialist you'll become....

 

[Grav]

I hope you are rightStewart66 but I'm not putting my house on it.
The way I see it, Carlton will go close to playing finals in 2020. In 2021 they will be top 4.

Yeah, NAH! After all it is Carlton your talking about.

 

[BrutThough]

Free Agrents we should be targeting next year:

Brad Crouch
Isaac Smith
Robbie Gray
Mitch Duncan
Zac Williams.

Degoey for trade.

I think I'm the only person who doesnt really rate De Goey. For all the hype and talk about him being this 'superstar', I just dont think it is warranted. He is a good player, but I dont think he is worth the amount of money he would demand or what we would need to give up in a trade.

Zac Williams is the one for me that we need to go hard for. He is a gun who goes slightly under the radar since GWS have so many good players. His prelim final playing in the middle was superb. GWS will have a lot on their plate keeping Cameron and Whitfield (with Jelly, Cogs, Greene all already being well paid), so Williams might be gettable for the right price.

 

[Ekomaira]

Harley Bennell is joining Shane Warne's challenger ticket for the AGM.

Other plans include going all in for Joe Daniher, bringing back SOS and Ken Hinkley as list and footy manager, and poaching the Suns' last CEO. Drain the Swamp.

we're due a bit of luck... imagine we get him and he becomes the footballer he was meant to be. long shot I know but still, we're due god dammit!

 

[joop]

I think I'm the only person who doesnt really rate De Goey. For all the hype and talk about him being this 'superstar', I just dont think it is warranted. He is a good player, but I dont think he is worth the amount of money he would demand or what we would need to give up in a trade.

Zac Williams is the one for me that we need to go hard for. He is a gun who goes slightly under the radar since GWS have so many good players. His prelim final playing in the middle was superb. GWS will have a lot on their plate keeping Cameron and Whitfield (with Jelly, Cogs, Greene all already being well paid), so Williams might be gettable for the right price.

De Goey is a game changer. Absolute gun.

 

[mightymalaka]

God i love this place!

I'm just disappointed after being away for a few days that i didn't get to express my opinion on Seb!
I just know you all want to hear it too!

It's good to see that some things never change around here!
Like how some people can't handle any criticism about any of our players! Apparently Seb is a brave warrior
Whose body language is so fierce and determined that he is involved in the same conversation as Nick Riewoldt! lol

Don't dare say anything negative about our Bambi!
And forgive me but isn't Sydney the same unconscionable mob that poached our greatest player? With the league's help of course!
And throw in dubious deals they did in luring Craig O'Brien and finally Barry Hall! But No evidently they are wonderful to deal with
Always so polite and like to get their deals done with a minimum of fuss! WOW we are a very forgiving lot down at St Kilda these days!

Unless you happen to be a Saints tragic who just want to see our side get better and move on from the likes of Seb Ross and the bizarre
Worship that so many on here seem to have for him!

In this fantasy world that's what amounts to treason! And i'm the one seen as the loose unit! lol

 

[gringo2011]

Can’t be that great ...still have Simpson , Kreuzer , Murphy , Betts ...all basically finished holding team together
Recycling their list with at least 10 players a year for last 5 years
and please don’t mention Casboult & Jones as champions ..they have a couple of nice players on their list
They only won the game because we in fact threw it away with inept goal kicking .. we will kill them .

They kicked 11.12 to our 11.8 under Teague. I think we were lucky they didn't kick straight. They lost a lot of games by under 10 points and quite a lot under a goal. They were missing Curnow for a long period. They look ripe to improve drastically. Betts is still a high scoring player.

 

[gringo2011]

I think I'm the only person who doesnt really rate De Goey. For all the hype and talk about him being this 'superstar', I just dont think it is warranted. He is a good player, but I dont think he is worth the amount of money he would demand or what we would need to give up in a trade.

Zac Williams is the one for me that we need to go hard for. He is a gun who goes slightly under the radar since GWS have so many good players. His prelim final playing in the middle was superb. GWS will have a lot on their plate keeping Cameron and Whitfield (with Jelly, Cogs, Greene all already being well paid), so Williams might be gettable for the right price.

Williams for sure. He's hidden at HB, his final game playing mid made you realise he's even better than you thought....and I have always rated him.

 

[BrutThough]

Williams for sure. He's hidden at HB, his final game playing mid made you realise he's even better than you thought....and I have always rated him.

I hate how stacked the GWS midfield is that they can play someone as good a Williams at half back and have Greene spend a significant time forward.
Both would play 90% mid time at almost any other club.

And now get to add another academy player in Greene to their stacked lineup.

 

[Stewart66]

They kicked 11.12 to our 11.8 under Teague. I think we were lucky they didn't kick straight. They lost a lot of games by under 10 points and quite a lot under a goal. They were missing Curnow for a long period. They look ripe to improve drastically. Betts is still a high scoring player.

Find the Carlton are great still baffling to be honest all hype .

Who is the replacement for Simpson ( they don’t have one )
Who is the replacement developing ruckman for Kreuzer ...( and don’t say the bloke from Hawthorn )
Their list management has been all over the shop , recruiting off cuts from the Giants and other clubs .

By the way I think the Saints might have been missing a few players last year.

 

[hayes]

I think I'm the only person who doesnt really rate De Goey. For all the hype and talk about him being this 'superstar', I just dont think it is warranted. He is a good player, but I dont think he is worth the amount of money he would demand or what we would need to give up in a trade.

Zac Williams is the one for me that we need to go hard for. He is a gun who goes slightly under the radar since GWS have so many good players. His prelim final playing in the middle was superb. GWS will have a lot on their plate keeping Cameron and Whitfield (with Jelly, Cogs, Greene all already being well paid), so Williams might be gettable for the right price.

He’s a match winner. Basically another Dustin Martin, I’d kill for someone like him.