List Mgmt. 2024 List Mismanagement and Trading Part 2

[Redline]

I think we’ll live trade draft night using our f1 to go after Dodson

Rowey who probably wouldn't know but Campo who should have a good handle on this year's players think Dodson won't go until the 20's? Our f1 is alot for that kind of pick. There should be a cheaper way of doing it

 

[crow2crow]

Rowey who probably wouldn't know but Campo who should have a good handle on this year's players think Dodson won't go until the 20's? Our f1 is alot for that kind of pick. There should be a cheaper way of doing it

they might split the F1 to get a late first this year and a projected late first next year

 

[Cromulant]

Why waste a first rounder on a ruckman?!?

I take it you've never seen him play

 

[AFC979810]

I take it you've never seen him play

Does he get lots of AFL fantasy points???

I would prefer we get our ruckman from the rookie list or a cheap trade. You know like all of the premiership teams over the past decade have done.

Over the past 10 years - here are your premiership ruckman Darcy Fort, Mason Cox, Rhys Stanley, Max Gawn, Nankervis/Soldo, Lycett/Vardy, Jordan Roughead, McEvoy/Hale. You wanna tell me its a good idea to invest a first round pick into the Ruck position?

 

[whattagun07]

they might split the F1 to get a late first this year and a projected late first next year

Surely no team would do that.
I think it's up to the team who wants in to this draft (known quantity) to overpay for a pick.
Accepting futures which aren't a round earlier, is a huge risk for another club. They don't benefit now, and they might end up looking really silly next year if he other team (in this case is) has a spike.

 

[anonymous Derik]

I take it you've never seen him play

If we trade our future first for GC pick 12 I’m picking another mid or at the very least mid-forward every day of the week. I’m sure Dodson will be a good player but I don’t think we should be reaching with our picks leading up to Tassie entering the comp.

 

[skam85]

He will be top 3 in the B&F eight years in a row.

You keep saying this rubbish as if it's gospel.

He won't be top 3 at all.

 

[skam85]

Does he get lots of AFL fantasy points???

I would prefer we get our ruckman from the rookie list or a cheap trade. You know like all of the premiership teams over the past decade have done.

Over the past 10 years - here are your premiership ruckman Darcy Fort, Mason Cox, Rhys Stanley, Max Gawn, Nankervis/Soldo, Lycett/Vardy, Jordan Roughead, McEvoy/Hale. You wanna tell me its a good idea to invest a first round pick into the Ruck position?

What the premiership ruck list tells me is we need a Geelong reject ruckman

 

[Hodgy]

Does he get lots of AFL fantasy points???

I would prefer we get our ruckman from the rookie list or a cheap trade. You know like all of the premiership teams over the past decade have done.

Over the past 10 years - here are your premiership ruckman Darcy Fort, Mason Cox, Rhys Stanley, Max Gawn, Nankervis/Soldo, Lycett/Vardy, Jordan Roughead, McEvoy/Hale. You wanna tell me its a good idea to invest a first round pick into the Ruck position?

We were going to use a first last year on Taylor Goad, who absolutely smashed it at the combine. Well he struggled to get 3 touches a game in the VFL this year.

Now he might well turn out to be a really good player, but it won’t be for 5 years so I’m glad North trumped us, and If you redid the draft now he wouldn’t go top 40. Trading next years 1st to get Dodson would be absolute folly.

 

[Crow till I die]

If we trade our future first for GC pick 12 I’m picking another mid or at the very least mid-forward every day of the week. I’m sure Dodson will be a good player but I don’t think we should be reaching with our picks leading up to Tassie entering the comp.

The dream would be if we did that, having Travaglia there at that pick

 

[Hodgy]

The dream would be if we did that, having Travaglia there at that pick

Travaglia looks great doesn’t he? Both he and Tauru developed a lot over the year and both might well end up being top 5 players out of this draft.