List Mgmt. 2024 List Mismanagement and Trading

[Afcprophet]

Lukosious would be great on the wing or a connector up forward. Huge upgrade on Murphy or Mchenry. Nank and Lank on the wings would be pretty handy

 

[Sanders]

Lukosious would be great on the wing or a connector up forward. Huge upgrade on Murphy or Mchenry. Nank and Lank on the wings would be pretty handy

It would be great, but whether it’s the best use of resources is a little more questionable

 

[spenze]

It would be great, but whether it’s the best use of resources is a little more questionable

Especially given our KPD stocks are at crisis levels

 

[Mostyn]

It would be great, but whether it’s the best use of resources is a little more questionable

If we just try to solve one problem at a time, we'll end up exactly where we already are.

Luko as a free agent. Hayward as a free agent. Petty as a free agent.

 

[triggyscrewedus]

Not sure if this has been posed yet;

How much Crowcoin would you be willing to throw at Jamara?

Imagine a forward line with Jamara and Izak.
Tex has retired, and cya Fog (traded for capital)

I'm sure he wouldn't leave Vic, but is it worth a shot? Offer $8M over 6?

Doesn't exactly solve our midfield issues though i guess

The Fog trade should be seriously considered.
Will he actually stand up next year (ideally now!) without Tex or just drift on pretending he's going to put it all together one day.
He has some value now but in 18 months time ?

 

[1990crow]

The Fog trade should be seriously considered.
Will he actually stand up next year (ideally now!) without Tex or just drift on pretending he's going to put it all together one day.
He has some value now but in 18 months time ?

Trouble is we don't have anyone capable of being any better. Gollant isn't it.
Welsh is years away from being ready.
Petty isn't as good.

I hope Burgess wakes and tries to get him to lose a few kegs to be more mobile.

 

[Samcro24]

Hard to know where Fog is at. Was building nicely in 22 and 23.

Reckon Jesus would struggle in this forward line.

 

[1990crow]

Hard to know where Fog is at. Was building nicely in 22 and 23.

Reckon Jesus would struggle in this forward line.

He plays well in teams that rebound quickly from a back fifty flooded I.e. has space to be one on one.

We aren't playing that way, and why Nicks needs to go.

 

[triggyscrewedus]

Trouble is we don't have anyone capable of being any better. Gollant isn't it.
Welsh is years away from being ready.
Petty isn't as good.

I hope Burgess wakes and tries to get him to lose a few kegs to be more mobile.

Yeah the old risk vs reward.
Maybe give the forward line to Filthy as the main man.

The game plan definitely doesn't help.

 

[GreyCrow]

Imagine being a young highly talented kid (top 5) in this years Draft knowing you could end up being taken by the Crows...

Your heart would sink and confidence would be gutted knowing full well you will have to toil away in the Two's and hope to Christ you get lucky to get selected if there's injuries despite smashing it.

 

[FullyBigKPro]

View attachment 1955278

That dejected lifeless look just says it all....

 

[OccamsRazorRay]

The Milera's - We got the WISH version. A comparison at ANY stage of Wayne Milera

30

Wayne Milera

Age

27

Ht

184cm

Wt

88kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

16.9

4star

K

10.0

4star

HB

6.8

4star

M

4.3

4star

T

2.5

4star

MG

265.3

4star

D

15.0

4star

K

8.5

3star

HB

6.5

4star

M

3.5

3star

T

1.0

2star

MG

282.0

4star

D

11.4

3star

K

5.8

3star

HB

5.6

4star

M

3.0

3star

T

1.4

4star

MG

182.0

3star

vs NWM has poor old Wayne getting destroyed. Unlucky with the injury, but for me, despite what the clanger/turnover stats say, has been woeful in the MANNER and location on the ground in which he's coughed the ball up. Up there with Hinge in terms of being a massive disappointment this season.

Wayne Milera and Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera AFL Stats Comparison

Wayne Milera and Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera AFL Stats Comparison.

www.footywire.com

 

[Danger in Texas]

The Milera's - We got the WISH version. A comparison at ANY stage of Wayne Milera vs NWM has poor old Wayne getting destroyed. Unlucky with the injury, but for me, despite what the clanger/turnover stats say, has been woeful in the MANNER and location on the ground in which he's coughed the ball up. Up there with Hinge in terms of being a massive disappointment this season.

Wayne Milera and Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera AFL Stats Comparison

Wayne Milera and Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera AFL Stats Comparison.

www.footywire.com

They were drafted six years apart, why are we comparing them?

 

[bigman]

I reckon former Richnmond Captain and now midfield coach Chris Newman would have a few clues?

His left boot is a bazooka!!

From that article :

Here is Newman’s assessment of McAuliffe . . .

“You look at the size of him . . . he’s a readymade body and plays that inside mid role really well.

“Wins his own ball, and it’s good to see a left-footer in there that’s able to get inside and out.


“The thing that he likes to do is actually win it, but he’s quite good at getting in to out successfully.

“He loves taking on tackles, shrugging tackles and getting clear.

“He’s a really honest worker . . . works hard, which is exactly what we require out of all our mids.

“And his patterns are strong.


“He’s a really good kid, who loves to learn. He’s always in my office and works closely with Sam Lonergan and Jack Ziebell as well with his stoppage craft.

“He’s a really talented kid . . . a beautiful left-foot kick and quite penetrating, too.

“So, he’s got a good leg and he can kick both sides. But he’s quite good at getting on to his left.”

i thought he would have been a great pick for us. Loved the way he played in the game at Ikon Park.

 

[OccamsRazorRay]

They were drafted six years apart, why are we comparing them?

A testament to how bad our drafting has been. They've been drafted 6 years apart, but at no stage has W Milera managed to achieve the sort of stats and impact on a game in his entire career compared to NWM who's only been in the system for 2, entering into his 3rd.

Both Pick 11. Both play the same position. What a dud.

 

[TRP1996]

That dejected lifeless look just says it all....

And McAsey doesn't look pleased either.

 

[Sanders]

If we just try to solve one problem at a time, we'll end up exactly where we already are.

Luko as a free agent. Hayward as a free agent. Petty as a free agent.

And is that location desperately short of speed and quality in the middle?

 

[Sanders]

They were drafted six years apart, why are we comparing them?

The first 2 words of the post give some indication.

What’s with the daft questions all of a sudden?

 

[Crow till I die]

And is that location desperately short of speed and quality in the middle?

I think he means wait for the free agents for the non mid positions but use our draft collateral at the draft or trade table for the mids we need

 

[Doctor B]

Our first picks by year since 2016.

Only Fog 83, Jones 80 and Schoenberg 57 have played more than 50 games from our highest draft picks
Gallucci, Poholke, McPherson, McAsey not playing AFL
Ling and Gould also not playing AFL


Crows drafts since 2016


2016
Round 1 pick 15 Gallucci 27 games played
Rd 3 P 44 Poholke 16 games

2017
Rd 1 P 12 Fogarty 83 games
Rd 3 P 40 McPherson 28 games

2018
Rd 1 P 9 Jones 80 games
Rd 1 P 16 McHenry 63 games

2019
Rd 1 P 6 McAsey 10 games
Rd 2 P 24 Schoenberg 57 games

2020
Rd 1 P 2 Thilthorpe 46 games
Rd 1 P 11 Pedlar 29 games
Rd 1 P 25 Cook 13 games

2021
Rd 1 P 6 Rachele 38 games
Rd 2 P 36 Soligo 41 games

2022
Round 1 P 17 Michaelanney 26 games
Round 2 P 43 Dowling 0 games

Swans

2016
Rd 1 P 11 Florent 147 games
Rd 1 P 21 Hayward 142 games

2017
Rd 1 P 14 Ling 4 games
Rd 2 P 33 T McCartin 115 games

2018
Rd 1 P 10 Blakey 107 games Academy
Rd 2 P 25 Rowbottom 98 games
Rd 3 P 44 McInerney 77 games

2019
Rd 1 P 5 Stephens 43 games
Rd 2 P 26 Gould 4 games
Rd2 P 39 Warner 65 games

2020
Rd 1 P 4 McDonald 49 games
Rd 1 P 5 Campbell 53 games Academy

2021
Rd 1 P 18 Sheldrick 9 games
Rd 2 P 34 Roberts 12 games

2022
Rd 1 P 20 Konstanty 0 games
Rd 2 P 27 Vickery 0 games

 

[Mostyn]

A testament to how bad our drafting has been. They've been drafted 6 years apart, but at no stage has W Milera managed to achieve the sort of stats and impact on a game in his entire career compared to NWM who's only been in the system for 2, entering into his 3rd.

Both Pick 11. Both play the same position. What a dud.

But why those two pick 11s?

And was our drafting meant to be able to predict Milera's injuries?

 

[Danger in Texas]

The first 2 words of the post give some indication.

What’s with the daft questions all of a sudden?

That’s like comparing Bailey Smith to Brodie Smith, what’s the point?

Comparing WMJ to someone from his same draft year who has developed better would make more sense, at least there’s a genuine direct comparison there

 

[Sanders]

That’s like comparing Bailey Smith to Brodie Smith, what’s the point?

Comparing WMJ to someone from his same draft year who has developed better would make more sense, at least there’s a genuine direct comparison there

No. You’re digging in the wrong direction

 

[Ham]

Sounds like we are throwing around some big numbers




On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Viva la Mattner]

Sounds like we are throwing around some big numbers




On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

I like it
Being proactive