Autopsy AFL 2024 Round 13 - Hawks v GWS Sat June 8th 1:45pm AEST (Uni of Tassie)

[DT_35]

Let the players decide the outcome of a game not the f****** umps.

The 2 free kicks prior to the last one were a disgrace too. Ginni only playing for the free that was barely there and then Newcombe throwing his head back like there was a sniper in the ground.

Embarrassing

 

[Holden Megroin]

I'd say the most dubious part of the entire thing was Breust managing to get the kick. I'd have backed anyone to have scored at least a point but it was glasses down when it was Breust.

Expecting 100 frees over the next 3 games if that is downfield.

 

[Hawker_85]

Embarrassing

You're probably right. As a Saints supporter you are an authority on embarrassment after all.

 

[MinerBoy]

Expecting 100 frees over the next 3 games if that is downfield.

Well it gets paid all the time so expect it every time you see it. It would 100% have been paid against Sicily if he were the bumper make no mistake

 

[Dewyyyyy]

I'd say the most dubious part of the entire thing was Breust managing to get the kick. I'd have backed anyone to have scored at least a point but it was glasses down when it was Breust.

He and Chol were almost identical distances away, and Chol walked off like he didn’t care about it so Breust was all alone there ready for it

 

[2big sound]

Absolutely, Ginnivan not getting a high free at the end of the first quarter which resulted in a turnover and goal was one of the worst non calls i've seen this year

He did get a free but chose to play on.

 

[2big sound]

When you're a plastic franchise propped up by the league you don't need 'em.

Well it you are going to get personal, lets talk about team colours, or even your dorky song.

 

[Bjo187]

Ginnivan is a disgrace and his little mate moore is close behind him. First thought is always drawing a free kick.

 

[2big sound]

Cmon mate you had 20 picks in the first round for 2 years straight!

So the Giants were just supposed to create a team out of thin air???

 

[Long Live HFC]

lololol.

this thread demonstrates the amount of trauma the 2011-2015 hawks caused to many many opposition fans.

 

[Hawker_85]

Well it you are going to get personal, lets talk about team colours, or even your dorky song.

Go your hardest champ, I'm listening.

 

[Chism]

So the Giants were just supposed to create a team out of thin air???

So you want 20 first round picks and father son picks as well even though you have been around all of 3 minutes in regards to the history of the game.

You get father son picks when you have a history and dont complain about other teams having them cause those teams that do have em never had the access to the first round the expansion teams have had.

 

[Holden Megroin]

Well it gets paid all the time so expect it every time you see it. It would 100% have been paid against Sicily if he were the bumper make no mistake

Doubt it.
Terrible decision and one that should be condoned

 

[Long Live HFC]

Ginnivan is a disgrace and his little mate moore is close behind him. First thought is always drawing a free kick.

ginnivan yes, moore no.

 

[Jimmy84]

Can someone explain something to me. On the Giants final kickout from the Hawks goal, they wanted to go to the left side of the field, but the umpire directed them to go down the right side into the pack turning it over and that was all she wrote.
Since when does the umpire decide what direction they player kicking out goes? Or have I missed something here?

 

[Long Live HFC]

the jealousy is palpable.

 

[Chism]

ginnivan yes, moore no.

Moore has more free kicks than any other forward in the comp to date.

Averages 3 a game nearly and got 6 today.

Most Free Kicks For | 2024 AFL Statistics

Who has won the most free kicks in AFL 2024?

www.zerohanger.com

 

[hk89]

Derm queries all the frees we get and is silent on the ones we don't. We had a ton not paid the last quarter that weer absolutely blatant.

We also had professional umpires suggesting it was a free downfield.


..... so who do we believe?

He was sat down after he kicked it. That's a free downfield every single day

Agreed. The only surprise was Sicily actually receiving a well deserved free. They have to be VERY blatant to go his way - which this one was.

 

[DazalenkoUBewty]

Kelli is absolutely horrendous!!
Fox, please wake tf up!

 

[VernonSpots]

Doubt it.
Terrible decision and one that should be condoned

I definitely condone that decision

 

[Vindicater]

ginnivan yes, moore no.

Moore is in the same mold as Selwood.

Absolutely looks to draw frees but is scrapping hard in case they are not paid.

 

[Mitchell Madness]

All silence on the Ginnivan and Newcombe head flips ??

Gws were doing it too, and got a few. Stop sooking

 

[Long Live HFC]

Moore has more free kicks than any other forward in the comp to date.

Averages 3 a game nearly and got 6 today.

Most Free Kicks For | 2024 AFL Statistics

Who has won the most free kicks in AFL 2024?

www.zerohanger.com

i watch all our games. getting the free is not normally moore's first intent/effort. definitely space between him and ginnivan (or puopolo if we want to ID more hawks players that did it constantly).

 

[Chism]

i watch all our games. getting the free is not normally moore's first intent/effort. definitely space between him and ginnivan (or puopolo if we want to ID more hawks players that did it constantly).

Not saying it is mate and he doesnt play for em like Ginnivan does. Moores first intent when he has the ball is not to look for a free like Ginnivan does.

Fact is the Umps like him and pay them in his favor. You can argue all day if they are right or not.

I only know if Curnow got 6 free kicks in a game this forum would melt down.

 

[Hawker_85]

Well it you are going to get personal, lets talk about team colours, or even your dorky song

Go on mate, what's wrong with our song? Bit old fashioned for your taste? That's a symptom of having joined the league some time prior to lunchtime.