kane249
Wibble
- Oct 27, 2006
- 52,767
- 70,858
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Sth Freo, Liverpool, Chicago Bulls
Outs: Ebert, Wilkes, Dalziell, McGinnity
Ins: Swift, Stevenson, Houlihan, Smith
Ins: Swift, Stevenson, Houlihan, Smith
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Changes for Round 14 vs Collingwood
- Thread starter kane249
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Ebert has to go really, dont think he done too many good things today at all...
Out: Ebert, Lynch (forward line too top heavy)
In: Swift, Stevenson
not sure what the deal is on houlihan/masten, if either will be fit enough to play in 2 weeks...
Out: Ebert, Lynch (forward line too top heavy)
In: Swift, Stevenson
not sure what the deal is on houlihan/masten, if either will be fit enough to play in 2 weeks...
A long time to wait for this game.
HeBeast
Debutant
- Oct 25, 2009
- 89
- 0
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Liverpool FC
Ebert clearly needs to be dropped. These kids can't think that their spot in the team is cement! I think Ebert has been good at times, and will become a good player, but he was shithouse today, so drop him, he's not Gary Ablett ffs.
I think Shannon Hurn has been poor for a month now, it appears he was injured during the course of the match.
He's a great kick, but defensively, and that's his primary function, to defend, he is pretty poor.
Other than that based on today's performance Priddis and Ebert should be the first two dropped. Their skills are deplorable.
Matt Rosa is also struggling, I've never seen a player so weak in the legs, he gets tied up in tackles like he's being constricted, as soon as their is touch on him he turns into a ragdoll.
He's a great kick, but defensively, and that's his primary function, to defend, he is pretty poor.
Other than that based on today's performance Priddis and Ebert should be the first two dropped. Their skills are deplorable.
Matt Rosa is also struggling, I've never seen a player so weak in the legs, he gets tied up in tackles like he's being constricted, as soon as their is touch on him he turns into a ragdoll.
- Banned
- #8
Ebert has to go for a rest.
How did Masten go in the WAFL this week? Is he ready? What about Swift?
Strijker and Stevens have to be given a few more games. Strijker was good.
Lynch looks buff. We should just play him on the downhill slopes (Subi) for the rest of the year. Might get a good trade out of him yet.
How did Masten go in the WAFL this week? Is he ready? What about Swift?
Strijker and Stevens have to be given a few more games. Strijker was good.
Lynch looks buff. We should just play him on the downhill slopes (Subi) for the rest of the year. Might get a good trade out of him yet.
- Oct 4, 2007
- 8,695
- 3,442
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Golden State Warriors
IN: Masten, Stevenson, Swift
OUT: Embley (had a-****ing-nuff of this guy. Can't simply pick up a ball in space these days without making a fool of himself), McGinnity, Dalziell/Ebert (clearly one of the worst kicks in the AFL)
OUT: Embley (had a-****ing-nuff of this guy. Can't simply pick up a ball in space these days without making a fool of himself), McGinnity, Dalziell/Ebert (clearly one of the worst kicks in the AFL)
He was woeful again today though. Should have been wearing a Bulldogs jumper with the amount of free kicks and possessions he was sending their way.
The Falcon Strike
Hall of Famer
I've been on the drop Embley bandwagon for a few weeks as well - but don't think he was our worst today.
Would like to see Matera, Kemp and Heady come against the Pies
Selwood and Swift in (Masten another 2 weeks in the WAFL )
Brown and McGinnity out
Would like to see Matera, Kemp and Heady come against the Pies
Selwood and Swift in (Masten another 2 weeks in the WAFL )
Brown and McGinnity out
Embley still has those photos of Woosh, that he doesn't want to see in the papers.....
Woosh said they aren't ready yet.
Thought he started very well, was then back to his old tricks.
Far from the worst out there.
These players do not look AFL quality.
Priddis
Brown
Ebert
Mcginnity
Rosa
Wilkes
Lynch
That's alot to carry.
Will Schofield is really impressive and can be one positive in a dark season thus far.
I was confused by Woosha's use of Sheppard after half time, he was racking the ball up nicely on a wing and through the middle and was one of the only blokes hitting targets, he then pushed him deep in defence?
Why?
In: A.Selwood, Glass, Shuey, Swift,
Out: Ebert, McGinnity, Wilkes, Hurn (inj)
Out: Ebert, McGinnity, Wilkes, Hurn (inj)
Fix the forward line balance. And somehow fix the midfield.
In: Masten, Swift, Stevenson, Houlihan, Shuey(please?)
Out: Ebert, Lynch, Wilkes, Dalziell, McGinnity
Collingwood hardly play the tall KP forwards so 2 is more than enough especially with Brown in the team so Wilkes is out. Ebert had an absolute shocker and as its said, should understand that his place is not assured in the team. Dalziell is a good runner but his deplorable skills makes him lose out. Unfortunately for McGinnity, there will hopefully just be better options available.
Out: Ebert, Lynch, Wilkes, Dalziell, McGinnity
Collingwood hardly play the tall KP forwards so 2 is more than enough especially with Brown in the team so Wilkes is out. Ebert had an absolute shocker and as its said, should understand that his place is not assured in the team. Dalziell is a good runner but his deplorable skills makes him lose out. Unfortunately for McGinnity, there will hopefully just be better options available.
And?
Why take one of your best ball users from the middle and play him deep?
Just dumb, I'm sure he had more options.
generally agree.
Lynch or another key foward must go. To be honest even kennedy isnt doing much. Just one must go.
Watters disposal was pitterful but I would keep him as captain to season end. Unless his disposal improveds enormously he cant be captain in 2011.
Emberley must go.
Hurn must also go as he has had several poor weeks and needs to get himself together mentally and physically.
Bown must make his mark asa defender or he is gone at the end of the season - just not enough from him.
We can't cover all thes outs on merit you say, and I agree - but we must give Notte and co a min of 4 games to show why they should be kept. They may not win games for us but we need to know who has something to offer and who is prepared to have a red hot go. Those that dont cut it can go.
Embley won't go, was alright today one of his beter games for a while. Forgot about Tim Houlihan, he will be a great inclusion.
