Changes for Round 7 vs Hawthorn

[kane249]

Outs: Embley (susp), Masten (inj), Lynch (useless), McKinley (gutless)
Ins: Sheppard, Stevenson, Wilson, Stevens

 

[makaveli01]

Changes for round 7 v Hawthorn

In: Sheppard Stevens Brown Stevenson

Out: Masten(inj) Embley(susp) McKinley Lynch

B: Waters Glass Jones
HB: Sheppard Schofield Hurn
C: Rosa Priddis Ebert
HF: Stevens Kennedy Hams
F: LeCras Brown Naitanui
Ruck: Cox Swift A.Selwood

Int: Stevenson McGinnity Mackenzie S. Selwood

Edit: Beaten to it. Feel free to delete mods

 

[PRANKSTER666]

Re: Changes for round 7 v Hawthorn

I hope Embley doesn't get rubbed out so we can drop his a$$, has been pathetic today, and pretty poor all year.

 

[weagles_fan]

Outs: Embley (shitness thank god he is going to be suspended), Masten (inj), Priddis , McKinley (hack)
Ins: Sheppard, Stevenson, Shuey, Stevens

Priddis because all he does is take up somebody who could be the futures time in the midfield. He offers nothing and when WC are a good team again he will not be in the team so may as well be out now. A Selwood can stay if he's a tagger but otherwise he is the same as Priddis.

 

[NicNatPaddywack]

Outs: Embley (susp), Masten (inj), Lynch (useless), McKinley (gutless)
Ins: Sheppard, Stevenson, Wilson, Stevens

I am in COMPLETE agreeance with this, with a few additions:

OUT: Woosha, Sumich
IN: ANYONE WITH HALF A BRAIN AND THE SLIGHTEST ABILITY TO DEVELOP PLAYERS AND SKILLS.

OUT: A. Selwood, Schofield, Rosa, McKenzie.
IN: Margaret River U/9's.

 

[lewigie]

Can't bring in Wilson.

Either Brown will come in, or Hansen.

Preferably Brown, but we know it will be Hansen..

 

[makaveli01]

In: Sheppard Stevens Brown Stevenson

Out: Masten(inj) Embley(susp) McKinley Lynch

B: Waters Glass Jones
HB: Sheppard Schofield Hurn
C: Rosa Priddis Ebert
HF: Stevens Kennedy Hams
F: LeCras Brown Naitanui
Ruck: Cox Swift A.Selwood

Int: Stevenson McGinnity Mackenzie S. Selwood


Also, how far are Butler and Shuey off?

 

[kane249]

Can't bring in Wilson.

Either Brown will come in, or Hansen.

Preferably Brown, but we know it will be Hansen..

Unfortunately looks like Masten will be moving to the long term injury list

So means we can promote a rookie

 

[dirtyratz]

i am in complete agreeance with this, with a few additions:

Out: Woosha, sumich
in: Anyone with half a brain and the slightest ability to develop players and skills.

Out: A. Selwood, schofield, rosa, mckenzie.
In: Margaret river u/9's.

wtf?

 

[Max zero]

Outs: Embley (susp), Masten (inj), Lynch (useless), McKinley (gutless)
Ins: Sheppard, Stevenson, Wilson, Stevens

Agreed. My only change is to add Adam Selwood to the outs.

 

[wotdoiput]

In: Sheppard, Stevens, Brown, Butler (if fit)
Out: Masten, Lynch, Embley, McKinley.

 

[weagles_fan]

I am in COMPLETE agreeance with this, with a few additions:

OUT: Woosha, Sumich
IN: ANYONE WITH HALF A BRAIN AND THE SLIGHTEST ABILITY TO DEVELOP PLAYERS AND SKILLS.

OUT: A. Selwood, Schofield, Rosa, McKenzie.
IN: Margaret River U/9's.

Schofield and McKenzie did nothing wrong. No way they are going. Schofield was in the top 3-5 Eagles players I reckon.

 

[Schoey31]

I am in COMPLETE agreeance with this, with a few additions:

OUT: Woosha, Sumich
IN: ANYONE WITH HALF A BRAIN AND THE SLIGHTEST ABILITY TO DEVELOP PLAYERS AND SKILLS.

OUT: A. Selwood, Schofield, Rosa, McKenzie.
IN: Margaret River U/9's.

why?

 

[kane249]

Also, how far are Butler and Shuey off?

not too far hopefully, when they do

Outs: McGinnity, Hams (unlucky)
ins: Butler, Shuey

 

[Max zero]

not too far hopefully, when they do

Outs: McGinnity, Hams (unlucky)
ins: Butler, Shuey

Hams out wtf?

 

[Crimson King]

Butler should be available, not so sure about Shuey. Hopefully Sheppard and Stevens get a game.

 

[galen]

In: Lynch, McKinley, MacKenzie

these were the suggested quoted changes by one of the biggest negative posters on this board for this weeks ins.

Todays performance illustrates why these guys, in particular, Lynch and McKinley were not and shouldnt be getting a guernsy.

I'm keen to see your suggested ins for this week sdb4884.

 

[NicNatPaddywack]

why?

Not good enough today, and hasn't been since they started him this year. Just another spud.

 

[lewigie]

Unfortunately looks like Masten will be moving to the long term injury list

So means we can promote a rookie

But would we choose him over Strijk?

 

[kane249]

Hams out wtf?

It's unlucky and I love the guy and the way he plays but who else would you drop for him? the other candidates would be

Ebert
Rosa
S.Selwood
A.Selwood

And I don't see any of them getting dropped before Hams unfortunately

 

[Schoey31]

Not good enough today, and hasn't been since they started him this year. Just another spud.

wtf??

He has been good this year and he had a good game don't know what you're on.

 

[Darkness Falls]

I hope that if Masten goes on the LTI list then we upgrade Strijk. However, with what West Coast has done this year, I wouldn't be surprised if it was Wilson (which wouldn't be that bad as he's in good form, but so has Hansen and we need players with good footskills)

 

[anti_]

out: embley, masten, lynch (he was in better form when we dropped him earlier in the year), brett jones (doesnt offer anything anymore)

in:
sheppard - absolute cert. pencil it in.
stevenson - unsure why he got dropped to begin with, stick him on the wing.
butler - i'd think he's fit now, despite what some think he's actually a very solid defender
nicoski - his earlier season form was not too bad, his recent wafl game warrants selection.

mckinley very lucky to stay in but i really think he needs at least one more game before we completely dismiss him. time to stand up.

 

[kane249]

But would we choose him over Strijk?

It's a good question and a toss of the coin really

Hansen, Brown and Lynch have all tried and failed this year, so do we try Wilson? or go with Strijk in which case he'd be putting some serious pressure on the likes of A.Selwood and Jones i'd imagine

 

[bunsen burner]

Schoey and Hams are showing something.

Out (ie dropped):

A Selwood
Priddis
Rosa
Embley

All are duds and the more they play the more they hurt us. These guys need their cards marked.