Preview Changes: R19 v Carlton

Ins & Outs?


  • Total voters
    67
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Matt needs to learn defensive running and tackling and should be doing it in the SANFL like Gibbs. 2 tackles tonight for an inside mid is a joke. Atkins, yeah I can understand that, he is pure outside, but for Matt it is shocking
 
Who'd have thunk we'd be staring defeat in the face, coming up against Carlton. Yet here we are.

Carlton are $2.53 for the win. I'll be getting on them before they become too skinny to be worth a bet.

Oh, and before the game even starts, I'm so confident of a loss I'm gonna say "I told you so" right now.

Come at me if we win.
Oh we are lock to lose, their run and energy will kill us.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

End of the year they should make Rory sole captain and say “It’s your team now - lead it”

As good as he’s been it’s time for Tex to step back and let Rory do the job on his own
Yeah right, right up until he’s tagged and he’s a liability.
 
There will be stuff all changes. We need to beat up on Carlton to keep the finals hopes alive.

Out: Knight
In: Douglas or Galluci.
We won't be beating up on Carlton. I feel they are more likely to beat up on us. Carlton are definitely favourites for this match.
 
Out: Tex, Betts, Murphy, Laird, Knight, Mackay, Atkins, Greenwood
In: Himmelburg, Stengle, Fogarty, Jones, Sholl, Galluci, Wilson, CEY

Brown Hartigan Keath
Sholl Talia Kelly
Crouch CEY Smith
ROB Crouch Milera
Sloane Himmelburg Lynch
Fogarty Jenkins Stengle
Wilson Galluci Seedsman
Jones
 
Who'd have thunk we'd be staring defeat in the face, coming up against Carlton. Yet here we are.

Carlton are $2.53 for the win. I'll be getting on them before they become too skinny to be worth a bet.

Oh, and before the game even starts, I'm so confident of a loss I'm gonna say "I told you so" right now.

Come at me if we win.
Go half time Adelaide/full time blues.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

We all know what will happen.

Club is backed into a corner, wins to make finals (because that's our DNA mantra) become more important and the fan outrage means even more conservative selections

In : Douglas
Out : Knight
 
Maybe our coaches need to understand football is best played with emotion. Crowbots wasn't a misnomer 15 years ago and it isn't now

Have some ******* heart and passion

Don Pyke 4 years AFL coaching experience prior to getting our job. 50% under Neil Craig. You can’t be surprised that we’ve ended up back where we were all those years ago.
 
Rightio, it’s battle stations, our spot in the finals is now at risk and Carlton away isn’t looking like the easy win it did a few weeks ago. Not sure who will be making way, but we’ll be looking hard at getting more experience into the side. Every bone in the selector’s bodies will be aching to bring in Otto, Dougie and Sauce. I think only Dougie returns though.
 
Another week, another request for a cleanout.

Out:
Walker - cooked
Jenkins - not good enough
Atkins - not good enough
Mackay - terrible
Hartigan - mediocre
Murphy - zero goal sense for a forward
Laird - found out, awful disposal, terrible season
Greenwood - great for 10% of the game, invisible for 90%
B. Crouch - needs to get fit and run defensively for once. Needs a SANFL stint or trade

In:
Fogarty - should have played at least half the season already
Himmelberg - better than Jenkins
Gallucci - shouldn't have been dropped
Jones - should have played nearly every game
Butts - should get a run given what he's shown, even if it's for just a few games
Hamill - speedy player, give him a go
Stengle - never should have been dropped
Davis - playing only one game was unfair
Ellis-Yolmen - straight back from injury

Most of these ins should have already played significant AFL time this season

B Brown - Talia - Kelly
HB Smith - Keath - Hamill
C Seedsman - Milera - Gallucci
HF Jones - Fogarty - Lynch
F Betts - Himmelberg - Stengle
R O'Brien - Sloane - M. Crouch

I Butts - Ellis-Yolmen - Davis - Knight

Knight and Kelly only saved due to injuries
The fact Jones has not been played since his concussion when he is exactly the player we lack is a bloody discrace and pyke deserved to be gone for this alone. Note to selectors. Murphy is not a footballers backside. Get him out and off our list for all I care. Stengle in. Fogarty in. Mcadam in. Sholl in. Gallucci in. Berg in. Mchenry in(when fit). Cey in. Don't know if Butts, Mcpherson and Hamill are ready but if they are give them a game or two.
 
Last edited:
I think we need to move Milera down back again, looks lost up forward other than the game vs GC which I don't count, he can still have stints in the middle from there, Mackay comes out, Milera down back, and Stengle/Jones/McHenry in is too obvious that the coaches won't see it.

Smith can stay up forward, thought he's been great there, gets him in more attacking positions.

Surprised not much has been said about our rubbish goal kicking, twice in three weeks it's cost us a bigger lead in the first half.

The second half drop offs are really weird considering in both the Giants and Tigers games we won them after pulling away at the end, that to me seems like Pyke has lost the players that they're not willing to go the extra mile, it's only been after our bye it's been an issue, maybe something happened during it?
 
Some bold moves needed after that performance.

Tex - struggling for form and either needs to be replaced or FOG in for added marking ability.

Murphy - not doing enough

Matt Crouch - needs to be dropped after jogging for most parts last night. If Lyke is going to banish Gibbs to the SANFL for lack of defensive pressure, Matt needs to go back. Highlights reel at 1 minute 10 shows Heppel and Shiel run off and Matt just jogs along whilst Sloane actually puts in. Wilson tackles or CEY if fit in for Matt.

Big game today in the SANFL.
 
Some bold moves needed after that performance.

Tex - struggling for form and either needs to be replaced or FOG in for added marking ability.

Murphy - not doing enough

Matt Crouch - needs to be dropped after jogging for most parts last night. If Lyke is going to banish Gibbs to the SANFL for lack of defensive pressure, Matt needs to go back. Highlights reel at 1 minute 10 shows Heppel and Shiel run off and Matt just jogs along whilst Sloane actually puts in. Wilson tackles or CEY if fit in for Matt.

Big game today in the SANFL.
Matt Crouch definitely needs to go at a minimum
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Preview Changes: R19 v Carlton

Back
Top