Review Dees v the Giants of West Sydney: the Good, Bad & Fugly

Remove this Banner Ad

Hogan is a good footballer, But he's a CHF. Playing out from goals, and rolling up thru midfield, almost exactly like TMc does, at his best.

Na, hes genuinely shit. You put him in that role and he just becomes a terribly skilled and soft midfielder, still no presence or marking ability,
 
Can't blame House Party for going half-arsed in a GWS side that collectively hasn't had a **** to give for half a decade.

I'd trade ten Tom Macdonalds for half a Jesse Hogan.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Defeats the purpose when the ignored people get a little thing saying 'youre ignoring this person'
I ******* know I am why can't you accept it bigfooty
I tried ignoring people but found I was just clicking 'show ignored content' every time. You never know when you're going to miss some all time dribble.
 
On 360 Leon Cameron said the Giant studied 16 of our goals in their review of the game. Can we petition the Giants to release the vid of that meeting?
 
Only watched the last quarter live and watching the replay now.

Hunt's been good! I noticed Jordan doing good things a few times too.

I hope Kozzie bought Fritsch an extra large choccy egg.
Weid has done two or three nice things, which is two or three more nice things that Tom MacDonald has done.

I don't really care much about the umpiring because I know we win by heaps already.
But everyone loves talking about it.
Shit calls: Harmes tackle on Cogniglio, Petty spoil on Hogan, the abuse call against Oliver, hi contact ruck infringement against Gawn. I think Harmes robbed of a HTB somewhere too.
Langdon hands in the back. Harsh but fair.
A few shit calls against us, a few against them. Umpires are shit, the rules are shit, the AFL are shit. Who cares we're so good it doesn't matter.

Crowd numbers, again, who cares.
Wah wah wah Dees got 10,000 less than Richmond did against GWS, so what.
But but they're flag and prime time TV and where are everyone disappointing!

How about go and get ****ed.
Find me a team we're not going to piss on and maybe I'll bother if I don't already have a better offer.
Sorry lads not that keen to watch a training drill on Saturday night, maybe next time hey.

Dees are pretty nice at the moment.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I tried ignoring people but found I was just clicking 'show ignored content' every time. You never know when you're going to miss some all time dribble.
Keep at it. It takes time and effort to finally resist the show ignored content button
 
I tried ignoring people but found I was just clicking 'show ignored content' every time. You never know when you're going to miss some all time dribble.

if there is something worthwhile looking at you'll usually get multiple people replying to the ignored person about the same thing. I tend to have a look then. Otherwise I dont bother.
 
if there is something worthwhile looking at you'll usually multiple people replying to the ignored person about the same thing. I tend to have a look then. Otherwise I dont bother.
When I do that, I used to pretty much discover it was Sweet Jesus
 
Hunt's been good! I noticed Jordan doing good things a few times too.
Hunts enjoying what could be called a breakout season. Imo his best career form. He is now contesting Hibbo for the list spot, imo.

Jordan as well, to; even tho I was looking to drop him in favor of others needing exposure time. such as Weide. Jordan's role seems to be imitating AN-B's game role evolution.

Weid has done two or three nice things, which is two or three more nice things that Tom MacDonald has done.

Weide is finally starting to play as a true tall forward/deep forward, as distinct from TMc's type role, where he would role up thru midfield.
He's getting to more contested aerial contests; and from watching the replays, he is mostly double or triple teamed in the aerial contests.
But he is getting hands to the ball, and spoiling opponents from marking, and the ball spills to a loose ball situation and a ground ball contest inside our f50.
We scored numerous times from these spoils. He had a big impact on our scoring. I think he can work well in tandem with BBB.
.
 
Hunts enjoying what could be called a breakout season.
I thought he had some good games last year but also my eyesight is pretty bad that could have been Langdon I was watching.
 
I thought he had some good games last year but also my eyesight is pretty bad that could have been Langdon I was watching.
I thought he was better last year too, bar that last quarter v GWS at the G. He's had some poor moments this year with the ball but defensively has been ok. When Salem is fit again he'd be on shaky ground to stay in the team.
 
Love how everyone on review shows are saying that the disaster club they support needs to be more like Melbourne. Wild times
It's crazy isn't it?

What I love the most is that we're not winning through some gimmick or radical style of play. Nor are we over-reliant on a particular type of player (freak athletes, laser-legs, mozzie-fleet etc). It's just good honest footy, balanced between attack and defence, that we can maintain at a high standard for longer than our opposition more often than not.

Even when we've been good in the past, it's never felt like this. We were streaky, capable of breathtaking footy, but just as likely to turn in a shocker.
 
I thought he was better last year too, bar that last quarter v GWS at the G. He's had some poor moments this year with the ball but defensively has been ok.

When Salem is fit again he'd be on shaky ground to stay in the team.
I think it will come down to Hunt Hibbo and Rivers, for that position.

Rivers, May, Petty
Bowey, Lever, Salem
 
Hunt has played much better football than he has so far this year. At his worst this year he’s been deplorable (R2, R3) and he’s been inoffensive/gone without notice in the other games which is the best that can be said for him. Hardly having a breakout season, unless this is the ceiling we’ve come to place on him.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Review Dees v the Giants of West Sydney: the Good, Bad & Fugly

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top