Which Team would Win

[Bombs Away]

On looking at our injury list - it has hit over 18 (lets be honest when we say hamstrings are that and not general soreness) so I thought I would make a battle of our 2 teams.

I have placed them in roughly their position, remembering that one team has no ruckman to pick. Who do you think will win this match.

Team A

B N-L-M Fletcher Hardingham
HB Hibberd Pears Hooker
C Dempsey Hocking Winderlich
HF Prismall Hurley Myers
F Collyer Gumbleton Lonergan
R Daniher Welsh Zaharakis
I/C Williams Long T Slattery

Daniher in ruck so spine looks better - probably be gumby of hooker


Team B

B Dyson Carlisle McVeigh
HB Heppell Ryder Melksham
C Jetta Watson Ross
HF Monfries Crameri Reimers
F Davey Hille Steinberg
R Bellchambers Stanton Howlett
I/C H Slattery Browne

Have left our Josh Jenkins and Quinn as rookies and Davis rarely played as just back from injury I think

I side has the rucks, the other has the KPP.

Which is better????

 

[Slattery_20]

I have placed them in roughly their position, remembering that one team has no ruckman to pick.

Team A

Hooker

Hooker's a ruckman, durr.

 

[Kong]

You know what's truly said?

We can just about make up a side from players unvailable through injury (incl. Williams).

We're short a ruckman, but other than that..

B: Hibberd, Pears, Fletcher
HB: Dempsey, Hooker, NLM
C: Winderlich, Hocking, Long
HF: Colyer, Gumbleton, Daniher
F: Williams, Hurley, Welsh
R: [xxx] , Lonergan, Prismall

 

[Bombs Away]

You know what's truly said?

We can just about make up a side from players unvailable through injury (incl. Williams).

We're short a ruckman, but other than that..

B: Hibberd, Pears, Fletcher
HB: Dempsey, Hooker, NLM
C: Winderlich, Hocking, Long
HF: Colyer, Gumbleton, Daniher
F: Williams, Hurley, Welsh
R: [xxx] , Lonergan, Prismall

Whomb

I think you might have missed the point - Team A is ALL INJURED, Hardingham, Williams (retired through injury) and T Slattery are injured aswell

 

[Pweter]

I reckon team A would win. That's depressing.

 

[Kong]

At first that's what I thought you were getting at, but when I saw Hardingham, Myers, T Slattery and Zaharakis I didn't really understand.

You can't really count "playing injured" or you'd be listing 70% of AFL players.

The point remains though, of course.

Disgraceful. Is this worse than the end of 2008, where our emergencies included an injured player and a delisted player?

 

[Bombs Away]

At first that's what I thought you were getting at, but when I saw Hardingham, Myers, T Slattery and Zaharakis I didn't really understand.

You can't really count "playing injured" or you'd be listing 70% of AFL players.

The point remains though, of course.

Disgraceful. Is this worse than the end of 2008, where our emergencies included an injured player and a delisted player?

I think that this week and last week we selected injured players.

Due to the fact that the windy hill flu is still rampant I suppose we will never know. Michael Hibberd was dropped due to soreness yet did his hammy at the same time???

Still think we can win a couple more and hopefully get some back this week. I just get frustrated, mainly cause I dont know how good we could be with all the constant injuries

 

[Watson_my_mind]

So sad.. team A the injured mob would win.

 

[whats_at_stake]

NLM is a ruckman as was shown in the final against Adelaide.

 

[daffo]

Go Team Injury!

 

[Synth]

Gumby rucked in u18.

I think the injured team would just get over the line because of its far superior back line.

The rest is fairly even.

 

[deeplivid]

Honestly, a hard one to tip.

Honestly, would tip team A.