Search results for query: *

Hard to believe that Collingwood traded Treloar etc just to pay big money for this poor excuse of human being who should end up in jail . They wonder why they get all the bogan jokes.

Hey Bryce you are going to play in finals -- You will play lots of Friday nights etc on key national tv time slots. You will play in front of 50 k people in all home games You will have lots of good players around you . And guess what real forwards and forward structure to kick to...

Really we could go on for ages here about his value etc. But reality is if he still wants to come home then Crows will progress talks and our pick 18 will get the job done . We could of course throw in the extra we got for letting a Brownlow go home in Gore . But it is now or never for Bryce.

Then don't take him , don't you understand we don't want to lose another top 22 player as will lose Lever and already lost Smith for all our most of 2018. We don't want to keep losing key players but if CC wants to go and someone wants to pay right price for we will do right thing .

For crying out aloud not that hard to spell a AFL coaches name especially with 4 letters in it. Think the only reason Pyke re acted is here we are sitting top about to get ready for finals and we get only questions about players future and when 1 is under contract getting too much. I Charlie...

Well one club won't be is Carlton , though we will start talks then do a SOS and storm out.

Much as want to see Gibbs come home I certainly hope they tell SOS to sod off if not happy with 13 plus a little bonus.

Oh yeah lets see how happy he is if this doesn't happen mate. Lots of reasons wants to come to Adelaide.

Ok what was his deal as forgotten.

Not a prime pick then have a look at our last picks around pick 13. Dangerfield. Talia Lever Milera All those will have greater careers than Gibbs with Milera only unknown . Oops their is a Brownlow medalist in there as well,

Much as wanted Gibbs to get his wish to return home and play for Crows , just look at some of trades done so cheaply and look at what Carlton are demanding from Crows and although disappointed if trade didn't happen I would not see as failure by us to walk away . As lets face facts he would be...

My god where did we find you? Those 3 would be rated equal to Gibbs on their own and Talia would be rated more by our club . Think you need to worry whats happening over there than making stupid posts about other clubs. Due to our loyalty both Carlton and us will make lavish statements...

Firstly obviously we would like him especially as he wants to return home to both his and her families, but never expected that we had to go in reverse to achieve that. No like many others even Gibbs supporters like me agree with you now to go for Rockliff and another young mid possibly from...

Yes but he is not going to get 13 plus top players or 2nd rounder with 13 . So he doesn't get anything because there is no point in giving more than 13 for 28 yr old could have been star, maybe might be player. I don't want Lyons to go top Carlton I want the 2 nd round pick we will get from GC...

La Dispute is that what you are all about disputing without reading or thinking . No 1 -- I did not say Lyons was a youngster 2 -- He is 24 which in many cases close to prime e.g. Danger only showed last 2 years any form level with skill value . 3 - And of...

Please think about it Carlton and their supporters why in the hell would we give up pick 13 a possible future 10 plus season star and then give up one of our top youngsters as well for a 28 yr old player where no matter how you rate him even the most one eyed supporter in reality must see is...

Look I really like to see Gibbs playing finally for Crows but will be horrified and upset with Crows if we give up pick 13 plus future stars likeMcGovern, Cameron or Brad Crouch. that is just stupid and short term thinking and don't want to become another North Melb. We payed way over for...

Where you been these last few years if Gibbs wants to come home a deal will have to be done contract or not somewhere close to both parties wishes as apart from McCarthy every go home deal been done . Do you really think we got a good deal for Dangerfield . It simply down to if Gibbs wants...

Yes.

Well simple fact is as confirmed by Roo this morning on radio is that Geelong is his preferred club and discussions have started to get a deal done to please both parties. But he also said that in not even close to assume that the go home factor is the only reason for returning to Victoria but...

Hang on just forget who has the longest . Do you agree with 8 year free agency . And do you agree or not agree that you would have lost players in your glory years to this policy . By this we are responding to post not seeing who is most articulate or who wins .

Well last follow up re this subject . Really no matter how you twist my main point or even whether you disagree . It is simply 8 years and age of 25 is too young to give free agency to and no matter who you are even the great Garry Ablett you DO not get 8 years of good football out of and we...

You are obviously a politician and just spin your stuff , but do not go anywhere near what my post was about . So just read these 2 main points please . A -- A free agent at 25 is too young . B-- And we did not get anywhere 8 good years of football from him . Now again you went...

Well guess first thing to do is repeat a major question you forgot to answer and that is how many premierships you would have won if Voss and Black etc got enticed back home with FA at age of 25 . Guess lucky not around then wasn't you. Here is this game super star that has dominated for 8...

Do you understand never won or most years not even close to winning our B&F. Basically the victorian umpires like him almost as much as Vic media. No not knocking him but point is really still learning how to use his speed etc to teams advantage instead of at bottom of scrum and how many...

What a lot of crap as the guy is just 25 in the prime of his football life and this year first year really lived up to the hype of his extreme talent . He did not move over to join us in 1 st year to finish schooling.

Basically don't care where he goes as long as we get a deserved compensation , and guess what we still hold the cards as we have plenty of cash to splash . Guess what Geelong Fc and their fans if you want to screw us then you might find Danger playing for Hawks or Pies as if you think this...

Nice of you to worry about our clubs reputation Tristan . But 2 things to remember here 1 -- we are not going to let our best player for just a 1st rd draft pick. 2 -- Whilst we are all disappointed Danger might go , we are aware he wants to go for right reasons as a quality family...

But Eddie wasn't a star mate and had even been dropped in last 2 years and Carlton were not desperate to hold onto. Simple fact if want Danger you are going to have to dig deep and work out want Henderson or Danger and unless ready to handover some good young players .

Simple if or when Danger goes it won't be a fee agent deal. Someone is going to have to cough up a player and a 1 st round pick to get job done as he is a restricted free agent and we might be from city of churches but we aren't silly. Yes he will be missed if lose him as he is multi...