i was sticking up for lovett, i dont no about you but id rather a snack pack than i half eaten banana you moron, no sens of comedy of the billy madison variety??
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Discussion 2008 Trade/Draft/Player List Mega Thread
- Thread starter CHBench
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Banned
- #53
Nope. My mistake. Apologies
- Banned
- #55
Thought you were being facetious. The point stands though. Saints desperately need a midfielder that has elite pace. If Lyon believes you can have a crack at a flag in the next few years then he may be willing to trade for Lovett. Asking price is apparently a late first rounder.not sure if i can forgive you for not understanding adam sandler brilliance...
_Interpol_
Club Legend
All for lovett. scenery change might help him... get him in line..
nobody will be getting any firs rounders here, they are too valuable..
3rd rounder and a player for mine...gee we could do with the pace
which player, umm.....X clarke? change of scenery could help him too.. different game plan or something.. the kid can play, but not at moorabbin
- Banned
- #57
Clarke is a proven dud. Pass. 1st rounders are very valuable this year. Might be unrealistic. Id be hoping for top 25. No point letting him go if we don't get a deal within the top 25. He is contracted after all.
yeh and if him and raph get split up they might stop looking for each other....xav played his best footy when raph wasnt there...harsh but IMO its true..
A page wasted worrying about Lovett for goodness sake!
Come on!
Should we have a go for Cousins? And what would it cost us?
Come on!
Should we have a go for Cousins? And what would it cost us?
well correct me if im wrong but wouldnt we just have to draft cousins,?? due to him not being afl listed so no trade neccesary?? so i dont no how the Pre season draft works so im not sure how we would get him...
ChrisFooty
Premiership Player
Kerr would most likely cost too much and/or would need to give up to much in a trade.
Cousins would most likely not.
Cousins would most likely not.
CHBench
Norm Smith Medallist
- Jan 20, 2008
- 8,991
- 10,441
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- sixers
- Thread starter
- #63
Someone answer me this question.
Which would you rather have?
1. Kosi+Dal+Pick12 with the added extra of Ben Cousins
or
2. Just Daniel Kerr
Would take Ben Cousins with pick 45 over Kerr everyday of the week.
With the new GC team coming in to cherry pick the draft clubs will be stocking up on kids. I am confident no club would take Cousins with their 2nd round pick. 3rd round could be interesting, Collingwood, Richmond, Carlton all have picks before us and could grab him. But do they take the risk? St Kilda have proved they can put a player back on the straight and narrow. M. Gardiner has hardly copped a mention in 2 years. Apparantly too, Ben Cousins was very close to being traded to us last year.... and if Gardi does go on....
Which would you rather have?
1. Kosi+Dal+Pick12 with the added extra of Ben Cousins
or
2. Just Daniel Kerr
Would take Ben Cousins with pick 45 over Kerr everyday of the week.
With the new GC team coming in to cherry pick the draft clubs will be stocking up on kids. I am confident no club would take Cousins with their 2nd round pick. 3rd round could be interesting, Collingwood, Richmond, Carlton all have picks before us and could grab him. But do they take the risk? St Kilda have proved they can put a player back on the straight and narrow. M. Gardiner has hardly copped a mention in 2 years. Apparantly too, Ben Cousins was very close to being traded to us last year.... and if Gardi does go on....
I was of the opinion that Cousins was only allowed to nominate for the pre-season draft, or is it that he can only do the November and not pre-season? I think it's one or the other.
From the game against Geelong, I often though how handy another key defender would be.
Hopefully we regain Maguire next year (signs look promising), however if he can't get back to his best who should we look at come draft time??
IMO the following players should be looked at.
Jon Thompson: 6'4 CHB 91 KG. Aged 18. "Plays CHB in SAFL very agile. Been in the best in the seniors 7 times this season already.
Also very quick and can play on smalls as well as talls. His leap is also one of the best in the SAFL."
Jackson Trengrove:196cm, 77kg
-Good skills
-Good pace/ work rate
-Great contested mark
-Footy smarts/ versitile
Jordan Lisle: 196cm, 87kg
-Good mark
-Good pace
-Good skills/ long kick
-Versitile
All would be an ideal fit in the back half for us, helps to free up Chips, Gram and BJ.
Any thoughts???
Hopefully we regain Maguire next year (signs look promising), however if he can't get back to his best who should we look at come draft time??
IMO the following players should be looked at.
Jon Thompson: 6'4 CHB 91 KG. Aged 18. "Plays CHB in SAFL very agile. Been in the best in the seniors 7 times this season already.
Also very quick and can play on smalls as well as talls. His leap is also one of the best in the SAFL."
Jackson Trengrove:196cm, 77kg
-Good skills
-Good pace/ work rate
-Great contested mark
-Footy smarts/ versitile
Jordan Lisle: 196cm, 87kg
-Good mark
-Good pace
-Good skills/ long kick
-Versitile
All would be an ideal fit in the back half for us, helps to free up Chips, Gram and BJ.
Any thoughts???
We can absolutely use backmen. Ever noticed how the best seem to be the older players? Max, Fletcher, Scarlett....
dan0z
Club Legend
option 1 bench..
i totally agree.
i think we should get the best midfielder we can get with our first draft pick, we lack midfield depth..
You have basically just stated that if you get kerr you have to give up kosi dal pick 12 and cousins. Geez you might of well said option
1. Jesus at FF or
2. lonely old kerr
Kerr = Pick 12 + player.
EVERYONE would take cousins over kerr duh!
How much from the Dogs for Kosi?
I'd say too much, but we all rate our own players higher than other teams, fairer to say? I really rate Kosi and if you brought those fellas into it then I'd say a straight swap for Boyd, plus maybe us give you a 3rd rounder.
yeah that would be fair, nut i can't really see us trading kosi because it would ruin our structure completely, but weirder things have happened
See anything in Farren Ray? Heard you guys are on the look out for a bit more pace, hasn't shown much at the Bulldogs but has potential.
yer i reckon he goes alright but wouldn't give much up to get him.
he lowered his trade value after the weekends game though
played a shocker
If we're talking trade value don't read some of the comments on our board because it might lower it a couple of rounds in the draftyer i reckon he goes alright but wouldn't give much up to get him.
he lowered his trade value after the weekends game though
played a shocker
Similar threads
