Rumour 2024 Hypothetical trade and FA Thread

[Snoref]

Why not DGB and a second for Barass

He is young and will fit their need of a rebuild? And going back home might do DGB some good

 

[tl92]

Why not DGB and a second for Barass

He is young and will fit their need of a rebuild? And going back home might do DGB some good

DGB has no value.

 

[Ned Ryerson]

DGB has no value.

This. If you are proposing a trade including DGB you are essentially saying the trade is just whatever the other piece is. Not a shot at DGB - just the reality of his value.

 

[butlers hawks]

DGB has no value.

at this point the second round pick might be seen more favorably sadly

as helpful as the Box Hill reports that Hawthorn put out are to many, every week saying we liked this about Denver but this this and this we want him to work on probably doesnt help

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

at this point the second round pick might be seen more favorably sadly

as helpful as the Box Hill reports that Hawthorn put out are to many, every week saying we liked this about Denver but this this and this we want him to work on probably doesnt help

We might need to move someone anyway to free some spots up.

I'll be honest that he will be involved if push came to shove

 

[eaglevision]

Why not DGB and a second for Barass

He is young and will fit their need of a rebuild? And going back home might do DGB some good

I’d rather just the 2R and keep the list spot open.

 

[FB19]

For Barrass something like
8, f2, DGB for
Barass 23 f3

On current picks and rating DGB as a token eagles 4th rounder that’s around pick 14. Maybe a little light but to me that’s the core of a deal. We still get 2 decent talents in a deep draft plus our KPD and hold our f1.

 

[butlers hawks]

We might need to move someone anyway to free some spots up.

I'll be honest that he will be involved if push came to shove

Not saying he wont be but he will be the sweetener not a major part of the deal

 

[butlers hawks]

For Barrass something like
8, f2, DGB for
Barass 23 f3

On current picks and rating DGB as a token eagles 4th rounder that’s around pick 14. Maybe a little light but to me that’s the core of a deal. We still get 2 decent talents in a deep draft plus our KPD and hold our f1.

if they accept 8, f2 and DGB I cant see much if anything coming back

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

Not saying he wont be but he will be the sweetener not a major part of the deal

Definitely. He is the gravy in the KFC order

 

[jenniferHAWKinS]

if they accept 8, f2 and DGB I cant see much if anything coming back

For a 29 year old (1st game next year)! Madness. Pick 8 is as good as pick 1 this year. Throw a blanket over the top 10 in this draft.

 

[Ned Ryerson]

Definitely. He is the gravy in the KFC order

That's underselling the gravy a bit. The way KFC chips have rapidly declined in quality over the decades the gravy and breadroll is the superior side for mine.

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

That's underselling the gravy a bit. The way KFC chips have rapidly declined in quality over the decades the gravy and breadroll is the superior side for mine.

Potato and Gravy. Small.

Gravy on it's own is actually excellent

 

[LegendLewis]

Definitely. He is the gravy in the KFC order

Hey GG, what is the story behind your avatar?

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

Hey GG, what is the story behind your avatar?

Big Hawk Fan

 

[GinniAndTonic]

If Tom leaves west coast he will be a hawk.

 

[LegendLewis]

Big Hawk Fan

world gone cray cray…she famous now

cheers

 

[butlers hawks]

For a 29 year old (1st game next year)! Madness. Pick 8 is as good as pick 1 this year. Throw a blanket over the top 10 in this draft.

not saying that isnt the case, but based on the hypothetical trade, they are getting a climb in the draft of 15 picks but not otherwise getting anything

in my opinion Hawks would attempt to bring in another pick in the first round between 14-20 to then send to them not pick 8. This could be splitting the pick or it could be trading a future pick into this year but pick 8 with 23 coming back wont get it done.

If you compare it to the key defender trades over the last say 10 years

• Jake Carlisle went to StKilda with Swans in the deal too but StKilda gave up 5 and 24 and got Carlisle and pick 14 but there was also later picks moved so Swans could match the Callum Mills bid
• Jake Lever to Melbourne with picks 35 and a future 3rd for pick 10 and a future 1st and 4th
• Steven May and Kade Kolojashnij to Dees for pick 6
• Dougal Howard + Paddy Ryder + pick 10 and future 4th to St Kilda for picks 12 and 18 and a future 3rd
• Aliir Aliir to Port for a future 2nd
• Robbie Tarrant + pick 40 + a future 2nd to Tigers for Callum Coleman-Jones + picks 40, 42 and a future 4th
• Esava Ratugolea to Port for picks 25, 76 and 93

Few points this raises, firstly not many key backs of this level get traded and secondly, a lot go for high picks. Yes most of these guys are younger but as you can see there very rarely is a slide back of only 15 picks for a guy.

 

[mustang]

Potato and Gravy. Small.

Gravy on it's own is actually excellent

There were Large were really large chips and small chips were small, now the small chips boxes are the large boxes and the small size are half that.

And if you shake the new large box it halves again and becomes a half empty box, of chips,

Which is like giving 2 x first for a 29 year old when we should be adding as much young talent as possible, so hopefully we don’t shake the list.

 

[scrim reaper]

Few points this raises, firstly not many key backs of this level get traded and secondly, a lot go for high picks. Yes most of these guys are younger but as you can see there very rarely is a slide back of only 15 picks for a guy.

Yeah, while it may be nice if he was 26 or 27 instead, it's also Tom ****ing Barrass.

If it is doable for our 1st (mystery burger) + Collingwood 2nd rounder (dinner roll) + future 4th (wet wipe packet) for Barrass and their 3rd (gravy) then it deserves some consideration.

In short,
To Hawthorn:
Zinger Stacker Box (made 15 mins ago but still warm)
Gravy
Wet Wipes

To West Coast:
Mystery fresh burger (could even be a zinger stacker, could be one of the new shitty twisters)
Dinner roll

 

[TylerDurden]

As of now:

Baz is done to Geelong
Battle is staying
Barrass a real chance.
Unsure on Perryman.

 

[GinniAndTonic]

As of now:

Baz is done to Geelong
Battle is staying
Barrass a real chance.
Unsure on Perryman.

No offence TD but are you sure battle is staying? I swear you’ve changed you’re mind 4 times

 

[Mopar Jason]

As of now:

Baz is done to Geelong
Battle is staying
Barrass a real chance.
Unsure on Perryman.

I tend to think if Battle is staying put he would have signed by now.

 

[Ned Ryerson]

No offence TD but are you sure battle is staying? I swear you’ve changed you’re mind 4 times

Don’t think it’s TD changing his mind but the info he’s getting.

 

[smish]

As of now:

Baz is done to Geelong
Battle is staying
Barrass a real chance.
Unsure on Perryman.

Thanks TD. Any snippets of info always make the day that bit more interesting