Autopsy AFL 2024 Round 12 - Pies v Dogs Fri May 31st 7:40pm AEST (Marvel)

[YeoShuey]

Got to hand it to you, probably the worst post I’ve read this year and there’s been some howlers


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

I’m trying to work out which part didn’t you like?

The fact that Marvel is technically a Bulldogs home game given they play there more than anything?

The comment that Bontempelli is the only good player at the Bulldogs?

Or is it that the Bulldogs were playing a below standard VFL side and didn’t win convincingly?

I don’t see anything objectively wrong here.

 

[windyhill]

He’s not on his own in the black and white.

Every time there’s a pile on the ground or the ball goes over the boundary several of them throw their hands out for a free kick.

Sidebottom the worst.

 

[Occidental]

First loss since March 21. That’s one loss in nine. So no need to panic.
Didn’t find it at all in the last quarter.
Some inexperience and a patchwork forward line meant we played 80, not 100 minutes.
Bulldogs deserved it in the end.

 

[PerthBoy86]

Their defence is still very poor. Collingwood had no forward line tonight and still scored freely until the supply was non existent.

Bulldogs ended up overpowering them through midfield and up forward though. If that forward mix can gel (with some to come back) they will be a dangerous unit.

No doubt they need someone to support Jones.

 

[Joffaboy]

Bont showing Daicos how it’s done

Both are great players but the Bont has been doing this for a decade.

On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

You sound like an AFL umpire that can’t differentiate between htb for Naicos and everyone else.

Bont easily the 3.

Right did you watch the first 2 quarters? Naicos dominated.

 

[Dee Train]

Great result

 

[YeoShuey]

I don't think top 4 is unrealistic if they continue this form, when Libba etc returns. Their defence is 100% better than last year.

I disagree.

Wishy washy team. Will be lucky to make the 8 this year. I think they will lose to both Brisbane and Freo, and Port will destroy them in a few weeks time too.

 

[Joffaboy]

Good effort from Collingwood’s reserves. Luckily the flag isn’t won in May.

The excuses have started.

On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Hippster]

Don’t know how the Dogs managed that with all their outs. Great effort. Imagine if Smith, Naughton, Libba, JJ, Richards, Weightman and a few others were out there tonight.
Pies could have done with Treloar…

 

[Thrawn]

First loss since March 21. That’s one loss in nine. So no need to panic.
Didn’t find it at all in the last quarter.
Some inexperience and a patchwork forward line meant we played 80, not 100 minutes.
Bulldogs deserved it in the end.

Who do you play next week? Lose that one and you'll be behind the pack contesting for top 4.

 

[CobberRodgers]

First loss since March 21. That’s one loss in nine. So no need to panic.
Didn’t find it at all in the last quarter.
Some inexperience and a patchwork forward line meant we played 80, not 100 minutes.
Bulldogs deserved it in the end.

Absolutely no need to panic.

Long season. Pies are still a huge chance. I’d back them against just about eveeyone else in the 8 at the MCG and it’ll matter.

 

[YeoShuey]

You sound like an AFL umpire that can’t differentiate between htb for Naicos and everyone else.

Bont easily the 3.

Yeah…. Let’s give 3 Brownlow points for 1 quarter of dominant play. Yeah no.

 

[cactuscall]

Darcy: "best win I've been a part of..."

Really? Surely not.

 

[Elixuh]

Disagree. A few better this season.

Heeney, Naicos just to name a few.

Bont plays in a lesser team and is able to single handedly win games for the Dogs.

Heeney and Naicos can't do that. Naicos becomes invisible when the Pies have stinkers.

 

[Bushdid911]

Yeah…. Let’s give 3 Brownlow points for 1 quarter of dominant play. Yeah no.

What on earth are you on about.

 

[PerthBoy86]

I disagree.

Wishy washy team. Will be lucky to make the 8 this year. I think they will lose to both Brisbane and Freo, and Port will destroy them in a few weeks time too.

I did call them pretenders earlier in the gameday thread so maybe I am changing my tune too soon...but I just think they're playing below potential. They're a coach away and a key defender from being a real contender.

 

[Hippster]

Funny how Pies supporters scoffed at Carlton missing a dozen players a few weeks back. It’s all about system…
Now it does seem to suddenly matter.
Treloar was great.

 

[Frank Thring]

I’m trying to work out which part didn’t you like?

The fact that Marvel is technically a Bulldogs home game given they play there more than anything?

The comment that Bontempelli is the only good player at the Bulldogs?

Or is it that the Bulldogs were playing a below standard VFL side and didn’t win convincingly?

I don’t see anything objectively wrong here.

15 games at the G not enough?

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

I think i’d rather Lipinski than Treloar to be honest. I think Bulldogs lost out there.

?

Treloar is in AA form.

 

[YeoShuey]

Bont plays in a lesser team and is able to single handedly win games for the Dogs.

Heeney and Naicos can't do that. Naicos becomes invisible when the Pies have stinkers.

He’s in the same position that Lachie Neale is. Huge possession getter who gets votes because the rest of the team is below standard. It is nothing special.

Heeney and Naicos play for teams with many good players. A very different situation.

 

[T2B_]

Funny how Pies supporters scoffed at Carlton missing a dozen players a few weeks back. It’s all about system…
Now it does seem to suddenly matter.
Treloar was great.

BigFooty is a funny place sometimes.

 

[YeoShuey]

15 games at the G not enough?

Answer me this question. Would you want North to go play a home game against Brisbane at the Gabba? If you are consistent, you will say yes. If not, then your comment is irrelevant.

 

[hutchy31]

Daicos is amazing (and I think Josh D is pretty underrated, he’s incredibly good too), and maybe I’m biased but that last quarter from the Bont showed why he’s the best player in the comp.

The Sydney mids are going well too, we saw what Warner could do first hand last week. But they need to do it for a while yet.

Today was concerning as it took that effort to get over what was half a VFL team, but there’s no doubt where the three votes go.

 

[CobberRodgers]

Yeah…. Let’s give 3 Brownlow points for 1 quarter of dominant play. Yeah no.

Points?

Says enough really.