His SANFL form has been poor. His kicking has been especially poor. He can’t hit a target at the moment. He is an inconsistent kick at the best of times, with a lace out pace followed by a kick to grass a fair way off target.
Preview Changes: R4 2019 vs North Melbourne - NO ACL for Seedsman (But Still Injured)
- Thread starter Scorpus
- Start date
- Tagged users None
oldntired
Rookie
- Dec 17, 2016
- 36
- 44
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
I don’t mind dropping Gibbs but this is the issue, we’ve lost two outside players with skill for 2 inside players with average disposal, at Marvel when we’ve been exposed for outside run and poor delivery.
It’s as if we saw the best players sheet and said the 2 best players come in irrespective of position.
Gibbs has taken the Lyons role.
Easy to drop.
God we are pathetic.
Easy to drop.
God we are pathetic.
- Moderator
- #981
Jack is Back
Premiership Player
- Apr 17, 2013
- 4,449
- 10,174
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
I’ll take that bet.
Loser doesn’t post on Bigfooty for two weeks.
Are you willing to put up or shut up.
Unfortunately Gallucci is in poor form.
Not sure who else could come in that is a like for like for Seed.
They picked two guys in form.
Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
Gibbs has missed this week because his disposal was terrible and seemed to not give a f*** last week.
BUT, how can Kelly, Murphy, Jones and Atkins avoid the hammer?
We should have dropped Murphy for Stengle. Still should also have been included at the expense of Hartigan or Kelly. We have Talia, Hartigan, Kelly all with dodgy four skills, that is 1 too many
BUT, how can Kelly, Murphy, Jones and Atkins avoid the hammer?
We should have dropped Murphy for Stengle. Still should also have been included at the expense of Hartigan or Kelly. We have Talia, Hartigan, Kelly all with dodgy four skills, that is 1 too many
I expect we'll push Brad or Sloane out a little, with CEY working on the inside.
I don't mind that.
I don't mind that.
Crowbots are dead
Premiership Player
- Oct 11, 2012
- 3,516
- 4,708
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
What’s your knock on him Pete? Seems like he has clean skills
Good to see Gibbs dropped. But fmd why do it the same week Seedsman is injured? Would've been better off dropping Betts for Stengle if you wanted to send a message.
It’s not even a like for like for Seeds that’s the issue as we played the spare winger up forward, Pohokle to play that role makes sense.
It’s the CEY Gibbs swap. Last week when our midfield was struggling we moved Milera into the middle and Gibbs back. Now we’ve lost that move, so is Milera stuck in defence? Who else could we swap? We’ve basically gone into the game limiting our options and that’s just dumb.
If we were brave it would have been Sholl in and Milera to the midfield.
- Jun 10, 2009
- 29,795
- 44,888
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Panthers, GWV Rebels Beaufort Crows
Betts is still playing like he GAF, nothing at all wrong with his effort.
Yeah he does - just don’t think he has the tools for AFL.
Love to be proved wrong of course
Mr MysteryGuest
Norm Smith Medallist
- Apr 4, 2015
- 9,061
- 9,510
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
nah, we know Gibbs is quality, but we need him to pull the finger out.
Why do they play him if he’s not right? Let CEY cover for a bit instead of working Gibbs into the ground. Groins are problematic, it’s all your kicking power as well as being able to cover kms.
Who would you bring in.
Gooch is struggling at SANFL level.
Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
Here are my thoughts...
I said after the game gibbs is playing shithouse and deserves to be dropped, actually glad they dropped him. His efforts were pathetic.
Poholke and Cey have had a good start to this season in the sanfl. I just dont think they are the right players to replace gibbs and seed.
The balance of the team is already out of wack. Putting 2 slow inside players in the 22 on a fast deck is ludicrous.
They were never going to play fog after his dismal performance playing chb last weekend. But he shouldve already been playing sfl at full forward and jenkins shouldve been in the ruck.
This team is capable of great things but the selection committee has continually crippled it year in year out.
We desperately need another small forward that can kick goals to free up betts, but rely on a kid and a defensive forward to provide us with the answer. Stengle along with fogarty and greenwood is the answer.
I just cant understand what the **** the coaches are doing. Im sure most people on this board agree.
I said after the game gibbs is playing shithouse and deserves to be dropped, actually glad they dropped him. His efforts were pathetic.
Poholke and Cey have had a good start to this season in the sanfl. I just dont think they are the right players to replace gibbs and seed.
The balance of the team is already out of wack. Putting 2 slow inside players in the 22 on a fast deck is ludicrous.
They were never going to play fog after his dismal performance playing chb last weekend. But he shouldve already been playing sfl at full forward and jenkins shouldve been in the ruck.
This team is capable of great things but the selection committee has continually crippled it year in year out.
We desperately need another small forward that can kick goals to free up betts, but rely on a kid and a defensive forward to provide us with the answer. Stengle along with fogarty and greenwood is the answer.
I just cant understand what the **** the coaches are doing. Im sure most people on this board agree.
- May 26, 2013
- 23,164
- 33,513
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Liverpool FC
Absolutely this
I cant believe people are complaining over this.
Gibbs has been swanning around cruising the last two games. As Bicks has said it is a matter of effort and attitude not capability. He needs a reality check. This ain't Carlton.
They pick the two most in form SANFL players. Unfortunately Gooch and Greenwood are not right.
I personally think we need Greenwood in as we lack grunt. CEY is a similar player type.
Poholke is in some great form and is youngish. They are rewarding form.
Seed is not a pacey player. His main weapon is a long accurate kick. That is how he gains meterage. We will miss him. What we need is Smithers to step up.
Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
Gibbs has been swanning around cruising the last two games. As Bicks has said it is a matter of effort and attitude not capability. He needs a reality check. This ain't Carlton.
They pick the two most in form SANFL players. Unfortunately Gooch and Greenwood are not right.
I personally think we need Greenwood in as we lack grunt. CEY is a similar player type.
Poholke is in some great form and is youngish. They are rewarding form.
Seed is not a pacey player. His main weapon is a long accurate kick. That is how he gains meterage. We will miss him. What we need is Smithers to step up.
Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
Is anyone really complaining about Gibbs being dropped? It’s the team balance that’s the issue
Galluci and Greenwood are obvs better choices but not fit
Unfortunately they are a week or more away and we are nowhere near our best side this week - depressing
Gibbs our is a good move he needs to improve some habits , he’s currently not playing the right style of game
Jack is Back
Premiership Player
- Apr 17, 2013
- 4,449
- 10,174
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
