Preview R18: Changes vs. St. Kilda

[jamesclean]

Out: Murphy

 

[Scorpus]

Out: Murphy, Himmelberg, Smith, Taylor (sub)
In: Taylor, Thilthorpe, Ryan, Schoenberg (sub)

 

[Mutineer]

Out: Murphy, Himmelberg, Smith, Taylor (sub)
In: Taylor, Thilthorpe, Ryan, Schoenberg (sub)

Schoenberg?
You have to be joking.

 

[Scorpus]

Schoenberg?
You have to be joking.

Someone who isn't a debutant who we can dump into the sub role, who doesn't need game time at either level.

Options also include Jones (yuck), Murphy (yuck), McHenry (yuck) and Smith (yuck)

 

[huludicidal]

Should be:

Out:
Rankine (susp), Murphy, Himmelberg (plus Taylor into the 22)

In:
Curtin, Ryan, Thilthorpe, Jones

Sub:
Jones


If Hinge is injured, Jones comes into the 22 and Edwards to sub.

 

[huludicidal]

Out: Murphy, Himmelberg, Smith, Taylor (sub)
In: Taylor, Thilthorpe, Ryan, Schoenberg (sub)

Rankine is gone for 3 weeks

 

[dogs105]

Out: Murphy, Himmelberg, Smith, Taylor (sub)
In: Taylor, Thilthorpe, Ryan, Schoenberg (sub)

Schoenberg was horrendous today. Terrible areas. Agree with all others, but Gollant or Edwards or Jones much better

 

[jackster83]

Rankine, Dawson, Max out
Jones, McHenry and Schoenberg in

Pick 4 is ours.

 

[Scorpus]

Rankine is gone for 3 weeks

Ah yep that's right.

Should revise my changes

Out: Rankine (suspended), Dawson (rested), Walker (rested), Hinge (injured), Dowling

In: McHenry, Jones, Burgess, Gollant, Schoenberg

Taylor retained as sub

Definitely going for the win of course

 

[Crowstar]

BACK THE BOYS IN.

 

[MsTopG]

Out
Nicks, assistants,

 

[dplggr47]

Rankine, Dawson, Max out
Jones, McHenry and Schoenberg in

Pick 4 is ours.

Will that become pick 6 after father sons and academy picks?

 

[MsTopG]

Rankine, Dawson, Max out
Jones, McHenry and Schoenberg in

Pick 4 is ours.

We will find a way to **** it up.

 

[BACCS]

Taylor into the 22 with Rankine suspended (6 touches, 2 clearances and a behind in one quarter, give him a full game!)

RT for Berg (but Berg did play well)

Jones into sub role

Murphy played well as a tagger in the 2nd half on Neale, so if we are stuck with him, use him to lock down on Steele next week. Otherwise, drop him for that horrible first half.

 

[BACCS]

If Hinge is injured, then play Curtin, it should be that simple

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

Will that become pick 6 after father sons and academy picks?

Ashcroft (Lion) and Lombard (GCS) potential top 5 picks.

 

[dogs105]

If Hinge is injured, then play Curtin, it should be that simple

Can we still drop Smith?

 

[aabp1978]

Given ROBs total lack of effectiveness, couldnt we just play Himmelberg and RT as rotating rucks? Much better options around the ground.

Otherwise Rankine (susp), Murphy. Taylor to play a full game.

 

[Executive Landlord]

Highly likely McHenry is in for Rankine

 

[PeterSalt]

If Hinge is injured, then play Curtin, it should be that simple

What about Ryan? He was probably BOG today vs Centrals

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

Play Oscar Ryan for Hinge. Kid looks good.

TT for Himm - Himm is just a bad decision maker.

Taylor comes in for Rank and Jones to sub.

Not even gonna bother with Smurph.

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

Highly likely McHenry is in for Rankine

Like for like…

 

[BACCS]

Play Oscar Ryan for Hinge. Kid looks good.

TT for Himm - Himm is just a bad decision maker.

Taylor comes in for Rank and Jones to sub.

Not even gonna bother with Smurph.

RT will come in, but Himmelberg took 8 marks (3 inside 50 and 3 contested, including a brilliant one hander against Andrews) and kicked 2.1, that’s a good game. Can’t ignore the rest of his game because of one missed kick into the corridor with 2 minutes to go. He had a better game than Fog.

 

[WeeBlake]

My best guess

Out- Rankine (susp), Hinge (inj)

In- Ned, Ryan

I’d prefer to drop Smith and Murphy too but not gonna happen

 

[BACCS]

My best guess

Out- Rankine (susp), Hinge (inj)

In- Ned, Ryan

I’d prefer to drop Smith and Murphy too but not gonna happen

Chayce instead of Ned I reckon, and probably RT for Himmelberg (would be stiff though)