Autopsy Roast & Toast vs Adelaide & Changes for Hawthorn

Best Players vs Adelaide


  • Total voters
    240
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Trial by media,the Nank one.

Disgrace if he gets suspended.

Caddy unfortunately will get suspended but the media will try to add a few weeks on.
If Caddy gets done then we should fight it.
Plain to see what his intent was.Why should he be punished for that?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

off afl site. we find out today

3. Caddy's whack could be costly
Josh Caddy is likely to come under scrutiny by match review officer Michael Christian for a clumsy high shot that left Crow David Mackay concussed. Late in the third term, Mackay collected the ball at half-back and dished off a handball, but as Caddy tried to apply pressure his swinging forearm collected the veteran Crow in the side of the face. Mackay was eventually helped from the field, but played no further part in the game. Fellow Tiger Toby Nankervis could also come under scrutiny for dropping his knees into the back of Matt Crouch early in the first quarter. The Richmond duo won't need to wait long to hear of their fate, with Christian delivering his decision on Friday.

can just tell he will go after reading this. they’ll throw in nank for good measure
 
Caddy shouldn't get done but they will watch it in 1000 frames per second slow-mo and determine he could've pulled out halfway through his attempt at knocking the ball out
 
I thought Riewoldt was not real good when he had the ball. Went back and had a shot from fifty when we had a player on which I thought was strange and out of character.
Lot of blind kicking from the boys last night which I suppose is when you give credit to opposition pressure.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Very disappointing.
I can't believe so many players fumbled so much...right through the game...Adelaide were so clean in comparison
Martin was great for much of the game.
Nankervis battled hard.
Short was ok...his disposal wasn't always as good as I expected...but maybe that was just reflective of the pressure the whole team allowed themselves to be under. Be interesting to see what happens in the next few games.
Cotchin had little effect. I'd think still affected by that migraine and probably shouldn't have played.
Houli will need time coming back from injury.
Will be interested to see how often Rance gets towelled up like that this season. Maybe it's the new norm?
Didn't see Grimes much on camera. But was probably working hard off it I'd expect.
Astbury battled hard but was faltering under pressure.
Graham probably battled hard too, just didn't get any of those finishing opportunities.
McIntosh's improved hardness is great, although didn't see as much of him as the game went on. His disposal looks like it will never improve though.
Grigg fumbled constantly and didn't seem hard enough at it.
Reece Conca is finished - I don't think he'll ever play again.
Cellis looks like he will never make it.
Big question mark again on Bellis if he keeps that up.
Mixed games I felt by Edwards, Caddy and Jack.
The small forwards were missing for much of the night. Bolton was a bit up and down but at least he can say he's not ready yet. He won't take Rioli's spot. But he still seemed more effective than the other two, although you can't always see what they're doing off the ball.
And what is happening with Lambert atm?
Townsend quiet too which he won't want to do too often. At least he converted his one opportunity...as usual...I just love that.
We really missed Broad and Vlastuin I thought. Probably Prestia too.
But then Adelaide had 7 out and lost 2 during the game plus Talia and Sloane injured.
Very interested to see if we learn from that. Always did last season. But is there more for this group to give? Or have we been worked out like the Bulldogs.
Adelaide were very good, as much as I hate to say that, and I hate even more watching a w***er like perkins have a good game against us, likewise mr potato head.
Almost as much as I despise listening to that adelaide apologist bwuce commentate...the sooner he's pensioned off the better.
And it wasn't at the MCG.
 
Last edited:
No way Nank gets anything. What did he actually do? Fall into his back a graze him with his shin? glory be better give him 2.

I can't even understand why that's in the AFL.com.au article he literally just running toward the play and falls over a dude that goes to ground???
 
Will be an interesting week on the selection table.

I hope Caddy doesn't get done for that but I reckon he might.

If Jack Higgins plays a good game for the VFL next week he will debut next Sunday.

Vlastuin, Broad, Rioli & Prestia out of that premiership side really shone through last night.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Autopsy Roast & Toast vs Adelaide & Changes for Hawthorn

Back
Top