Autopsy Roast & Toast vs GWS, Rd 3 2019, & changes for Port

Best players vs GWS


  • Total voters
    177
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

The positives
Stack what a find
Balta was good today, chased like a madman and impacted the contest repeatedly
Garth was short of a gallop so the run will do him good
Edwards was very good
Lamborghini busted a nut
Macca tried hard
Lynch looked good Cotch tried hard but didn’t have much impact

The negatives
Markov
Castagna
Butler
Ellis
Graham were all so bad they should be dropped
Dusty looks disinterested and has fumbled more in the first 3 weeks than I’ve seen him fumble over the past 6 years. Stunning
Prestia disposal was horrendous


We look underdone
He looks good doesn't he!
 
I reckon he is a mediocre coach.

This about the 10th year of not helping star players when they are getting rape-tagged
So what do you expect Dimma to do?
Because from where I'm sitting he sent Dusty fwd/back/sideways.
Unless of course you want to go back to the ol days of behind the play stuff.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Every time in our forward 50 when there was a stoppage
Gws had several players on there own defensive side
Easy taps several hand balls and they were away
We need to man up more at clearances
We Also need a ruck who gets first hand on the ball
And who doesn't let his opponent get in front of him
At every boundary throw in
 
Every time in our forward 50 when there was a stoppage
Gws had several players on there own defensive side
Easy taps several hand balls and they were away
We need to man up more at clearances
We Also need a ruck who gets first hand on the ball
And who doesn't let his opponent get in front of him
At every boundary throw in
In: Soldo
Out: Nank
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Can’t use injuries as an excuse. Elite teams cover their injured players. We are not an elite team, certainly better run than we were in the past but not elite. The much vaunted coaching panel has been exposed a bit too. Tired of opposition players playing their best games against us, today it’s Whitfield, previously it’s Sidebottom, the list goes on. Graham was poor today, put him on Whitfield, you’re not getting much out of Graham anyway. Biggest issue I see is the midfield, they have inferior disposal skills to other teams. Cotchin who I am a fan of, Prestia, Lambert do not hit targets regularly enough and just turn the ball over setting up scores for the opposition. Then there are some poorly skilled players who are not worthy of playing in a top 8 AFL team, Castagna, Ellis, Markov, Butler, they’ve all been around for a while, they won’t get better, had enough of all of them, play some kids.
 
So many players who shouldnt get a gig next week will if Dusty is suspended and Cotch is injured. Add the short injury and that’s 3 forced changes before even looking at the Ellis and Butlers of the world
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Autopsy Roast & Toast vs GWS, Rd 3 2019, & changes for Port

Back
Top