Well he needs to stopping yapping at them, he’s getting them offside so they’ll continue to give him nothing if keeps being a smug little prick.
-
LIVE: Geelong v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Cats at 54% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Prelim Finals
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round SF Winner: And_ROOS
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Autopsy Round 19, 2024: Positives and Negatives vs St Kilda
- Thread starter Bender_
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Positives : closer to the number one pick again
Negatives : team is crap and doesn’t improve
Anyone know when the draft is compromised due to Tassie coming in?. Tassie is coming in 2028 is the draft Compromised from 26 ?
Negatives : team is crap and doesn’t improve
Anyone know when the draft is compromised due to Tassie coming in?. Tassie is coming in 2028 is the draft Compromised from 26 ?
Perhaps if the umpires actually adjudicated the rules properly he wouldn't feel the need to 'yap' at them?
Amen.
- Sep 21, 2004
- 39,157
- 29,009
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Norwood & Liverpool.
He plays for West Coast; the umpires aren’t going to look after him. That will come when he inevitably heads to Collingwood or Geelong in a couple of years.
I agree with you though, he’s being scragged at every opportunity. Pyke needs to tell Schofield to mention into the media this week that the club is concerned about the lack of protection he’s getting. Other coaches do it about their superstars so why wouldn’t we?
Pwani Magharibi
Debutant
Have you tried it? Just had a great feed.
Agreed, that injera bread is delicious. Went to a great restaurant in Melbourne near Queen Vic Markets
I think it's more that for those of us born before 1990, Ethiopia hasn't exactly been synonymous with the word 'food'.
Certainly others could have been subbed out but Chesser was having his usual day with a sub par number of disposals and involvement.
I would trade him for a pick around #40 if we could get it (hopeful probably).
Dark Sharks
Premium Kent
Not fot the first time, i finish watching an Eagles game and one of my bigget takeaways, is How ****ing shit is Tim Kelly.
His stats always flatter him. Such a negative when he has the football, let work around stoppages. When he gets it in space, he wastes it. When he gets a clearance, is a dinky shit clearance that doens't benefit the side. Plays for himself.
Don't even get me started on Cripps, jesus christ.
+ Jack Williams. Beggers belief he was ever dropped in the first place. Every time he's played at AFL level i feel like he's held his own and not looked out of his depth.
+ Hunt tried, gets automatic points for that and not giving up. Wasted the footy and did frutstrating things at times, but effort is all fans want and he brought it in spades.
+ Maric was good. 19D, 5 marks and a goal. Didn't waste the ball either, unlike his senior teammates.
+ I suppose you called call Ginbeys game a positive. I got frustrated watching him tbh, he looked panicky and unsure of himself which isn't new, but the fact he's getting his hands on the footy and getting involved for better or worse can only be a good thing. 22 touches, 9 contested, 5 tackles is a good return.
+ Hedwards i thought was one of our better players. Solid game again from hiim.
- Cripps, Kelly, Allen... y'know, our leaders, pathetic. Ryan was also back to his normal self.
- Chesser resumed potato status. Did a couple good things, but his inability to stay involved in a game, either due to role or presence, is just concerning.
- Lack of impact from Ledwards, Culley, Hutchinson.
- Watching Reid get more and more frustrated each week is just depressing. Kelly really is the worst midfield leader of all time. Offers Harley zero protection, zero leadership or encouragement, then burns him over and over again whilst being deadset average himself.
- Jamaine Jones, once again, WHY IS HE STILL ON AN AFL LIST LET ALONE IN OUR STARTING TEAM. Ditto Petrucelle.
- Bailey Williams in the ruck. Eeeeewwww. Brother eewwww. What is that brothaaa. Eeeeewwwww.
His stats always flatter him. Such a negative when he has the football, let work around stoppages. When he gets it in space, he wastes it. When he gets a clearance, is a dinky shit clearance that doens't benefit the side. Plays for himself.
Don't even get me started on Cripps, jesus christ.
+ Jack Williams. Beggers belief he was ever dropped in the first place. Every time he's played at AFL level i feel like he's held his own and not looked out of his depth.
+ Hunt tried, gets automatic points for that and not giving up. Wasted the footy and did frutstrating things at times, but effort is all fans want and he brought it in spades.
+ Maric was good. 19D, 5 marks and a goal. Didn't waste the ball either, unlike his senior teammates.
+ I suppose you called call Ginbeys game a positive. I got frustrated watching him tbh, he looked panicky and unsure of himself which isn't new, but the fact he's getting his hands on the footy and getting involved for better or worse can only be a good thing. 22 touches, 9 contested, 5 tackles is a good return.
+ Hedwards i thought was one of our better players. Solid game again from hiim.
- Cripps, Kelly, Allen... y'know, our leaders, pathetic. Ryan was also back to his normal self.
- Chesser resumed potato status. Did a couple good things, but his inability to stay involved in a game, either due to role or presence, is just concerning.
- Lack of impact from Ledwards, Culley, Hutchinson.
- Watching Reid get more and more frustrated each week is just depressing. Kelly really is the worst midfield leader of all time. Offers Harley zero protection, zero leadership or encouragement, then burns him over and over again whilst being deadset average himself.
- Jamaine Jones, once again, WHY IS HE STILL ON AN AFL LIST LET ALONE IN OUR STARTING TEAM. Ditto Petrucelle.
- Bailey Williams in the ruck. Eeeeewwww. Brother eewwww. What is that brothaaa. Eeeeewwwww.
DeckedOut20
Debutant
- Sep 4, 2023
- 113
- 780
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Positive:
Negative:
- 5 of our players 21 or under are in our top 8.
- The best game of Hunt's 152 game career. 35 disposals, 723m gained & 82.9% disposal efficiency, in a team that was slaughtered.
- Ginbey equalled his record for most disposals in a game, although he had more metres gained (307m) & better efficieny (72.7%) than his last 22 disposal game.
- J.Will second best game of his career.
- Maric most disposals in his 25 game career.
Negative:
- A few names that have us consistently pulling our hair out, featuring in the bottom part of the table.
Last edited:
- Jun 29, 2013
- 3,933
- 6,221
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Positives: Played the kids
Negatives: The kids ain't good
Negatives: The kids ain't good
Proeagle
Team Captain
- Feb 25, 2024
- 337
- 585
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Positives - Im watching it on Ch7 and its now halftime and I just saw the end score. I dont have to sit through the second half smashing.
Not sure if its a positive or negative but Ryan will be suspended. Pity its not that flog Cripps. Hope he joins his buddy Darling in the WAFL.
Not sure if its a positive or negative but Ryan will be suspended. Pity its not that flog Cripps. Hope he joins his buddy Darling in the WAFL.
- Sep 21, 2004
- 39,157
- 29,009
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Norwood & Liverpool.
Kelly's disposal is shocking.
Worm burners or just dinky crap
Sent from my SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
Worm burners or just dinky crap
Sent from my SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
Tim kelly plays similar role to sheed in that he’s he’s a third/fourth on baller that can play hff/wing and can be be damaging. Kelly’s class usually has set him apart from being Sheed but lately Sheed is going as good as sheed was a couple years ago. Gets the ball but no real impact. He’ll end up just like Dom when he struggles to accumulate the ball too.
Assistant coach attempting to play the same gameplan as the departed coach, hoping for different results.
Still trying to play a pressing approach, without anywhere near the amount of pace up forward to execute it.
As stated by others, tackles inside attacking 50 were 23-0 in St Kilda's favour, which is the largest such discrepancy in that statistic that I can ever recall.
Dominated by the Saints in the middle in both ruck and contest. B.Williams is as effective as a sock puppet, Kelly had his typical underwhelming away day, Reid was dragged and bullied out of things and the rot flowed downhill from there.
67-35 inside 50s
28-11 scoring shots
Considering the above, it should have been well over a 100 point loss. Only kept below that due to some of the performances in defence and St Kilda's general incompetence at taking any opportunity.
Unfortunately, the team remains full of players that have no viable future at AFL level.
J.Williams should be persisted with for the remainder of the season.
The death knell for J.Schofield's chances of getting the top job permanently came when he ran out of ideas and tried to park the bus across goal, despite already being eight goals down.
Five more weeks of this holding pattern still to come.
Still trying to play a pressing approach, without anywhere near the amount of pace up forward to execute it.
As stated by others, tackles inside attacking 50 were 23-0 in St Kilda's favour, which is the largest such discrepancy in that statistic that I can ever recall.
Dominated by the Saints in the middle in both ruck and contest. B.Williams is as effective as a sock puppet, Kelly had his typical underwhelming away day, Reid was dragged and bullied out of things and the rot flowed downhill from there.
67-35 inside 50s
28-11 scoring shots
Considering the above, it should have been well over a 100 point loss. Only kept below that due to some of the performances in defence and St Kilda's general incompetence at taking any opportunity.
Unfortunately, the team remains full of players that have no viable future at AFL level.
J.Williams should be persisted with for the remainder of the season.
The death knell for J.Schofield's chances of getting the top job permanently came when he ran out of ideas and tried to park the bus across goal, despite already being eight goals down.
Five more weeks of this holding pattern still to come.
footy_basis
Team Captain
- May 22, 2023
- 316
- 490
- AFL Club
- West Coast
That trade for kelly was just disgusting
Ok, so I was watching but maybe not with full attention, that being said.
Why does Hunt look like he's the only one trying? Genuinely sprinting while everyone else jogs around without intent. Had 9 turnovers but to be fair it looked like he was the only AFL player we had, he's so much better as a backman. Wouldn't mind seeing him paired with Jones down back.
JJ is not a forward, either give him a similar role to Hunt or drop him, at worst make him the sub. Dewar or Burgiel could have taken his spot.
Tim Kelly looked so bad, just give the hands off mate when team mates are streaming forward.
Petruccelle shouldn't have played. Did some nice things but undid a lot of them as well. He had a good mark or two and one really nice kick in particular but **** me he was also frustrating, Dewar should have got the spot.
Luke Edwards, worst game I have seen him play. Some of his kicks were very bad, didn't see him do much right at all.
Maric looks like a good AFL player but I am still unsure on his position due to the whole height issue and it's not like we're dominating the air with contested marks thanks to our talls.
Culley unsighted. Wasn't watching closely, was he playing midfield? If not, why even bring him in?
Rotham selection ... why? Why was he sub? Why bring him in for the sub role, that's a wasted spot because all he will do is come on to replace a defender.
Reid is overcooking some of his kicks. I think we need to take down his TOG a little bit or get more time resting forward to give him that burst and impact. Easier said than done when the midfield is shit because we need him there as well, which is sad as he's a first year with 15 games or something.
Trew had some good handballs, the type of releasing handballs that other players just can't see, the type that opens the game up and allows someone to run onto it rather than panicked 1m handballs. Not as good as last week but neither were the team as a whole.
0 tackles inside 50 and only 3 f50 ground ball gets!
Harry Edwards continues to impress and so does Jack Williams. I still think the forward line would have been better served with Darling replacing Waterman for 1 week with JWill as the resting ruck.
Bailey Williams unfortunately hasn't shown much of anything as a forward, when he does mark it his set shots are crap.
Why does Hunt look like he's the only one trying? Genuinely sprinting while everyone else jogs around without intent. Had 9 turnovers but to be fair it looked like he was the only AFL player we had, he's so much better as a backman. Wouldn't mind seeing him paired with Jones down back.
JJ is not a forward, either give him a similar role to Hunt or drop him, at worst make him the sub. Dewar or Burgiel could have taken his spot.
Tim Kelly looked so bad, just give the hands off mate when team mates are streaming forward.
Petruccelle shouldn't have played. Did some nice things but undid a lot of them as well. He had a good mark or two and one really nice kick in particular but **** me he was also frustrating, Dewar should have got the spot.
Luke Edwards, worst game I have seen him play. Some of his kicks were very bad, didn't see him do much right at all.
Maric looks like a good AFL player but I am still unsure on his position due to the whole height issue and it's not like we're dominating the air with contested marks thanks to our talls.
Culley unsighted. Wasn't watching closely, was he playing midfield? If not, why even bring him in?
Rotham selection ... why? Why was he sub? Why bring him in for the sub role, that's a wasted spot because all he will do is come on to replace a defender.
Reid is overcooking some of his kicks. I think we need to take down his TOG a little bit or get more time resting forward to give him that burst and impact. Easier said than done when the midfield is shit because we need him there as well, which is sad as he's a first year with 15 games or something.
Trew had some good handballs, the type of releasing handballs that other players just can't see, the type that opens the game up and allows someone to run onto it rather than panicked 1m handballs. Not as good as last week but neither were the team as a whole.
0 tackles inside 50 and only 3 f50 ground ball gets!
Harry Edwards continues to impress and so does Jack Williams. I still think the forward line would have been better served with Darling replacing Waterman for 1 week with JWill as the resting ruck.
Bailey Williams unfortunately hasn't shown much of anything as a forward, when he does mark it his set shots are crap.
Bailey williams needs to go at the end of the year. Thats either from the club or starting 22. Need to bringing in a bloke that can ruck majority of the game. At the moment a good Bailey williams game is when he is unsighted and/or close to nullifying the oppo ruckmen. He brings nothing in the ruck, nothing when the ball hits the deck, nothing around the ground, nothing when you need a big reliable clunk from a ruckmen and nothing up foward.
Flynn’s injuries are a concern but surely there’s someone we can get that can shoulder majority of the rucking and actually provide some sort of service for us. Also need to back in Jack Williams now as a key forward that can pinch hit in the ruck. Jack has a future for us but not only does Bailey not have one for us, he doesn’t have one in the comp either
Flynn’s injuries are a concern but surely there’s someone we can get that can shoulder majority of the rucking and actually provide some sort of service for us. Also need to back in Jack Williams now as a key forward that can pinch hit in the ruck. Jack has a future for us but not only does Bailey not have one for us, he doesn’t have one in the comp either
Dark Sharks
Premium Kent
23 to 0 tackles inside forward 50 is absolutely laughable.
Who is the forwards coach??? That kent has a bit to answer for.
Who is the forwards coach??? That kent has a bit to answer for.
Ledwards is as vanilla as they come. Sure he looks good in tight at times but he lacks speed as an outsider and isn’t big or strong to play inside. Skills are also trash. I haven’t been this harsh on him till recently but never understood why he was so liked by mc.
Similar threads
