Autopsy AFL 2024 Round 19 - Blues v North Sun July 21st 4:40pm AEST (Marvel)

[WalshistheGOAT]

Nah mate

Nah mate, I’m talking like you won’t win a flag in the next couple of years, and after that, times up. You’re just not that good. Case in point, today’s game against a side only just turning the corner you desperately needed some extraordinary umpire intervention to get you over line.

We had like 7 players come off with injuries during the game, had Cripps and Kennedy in the ruck vs Xerri at times and are currently in a form slump... Yet we won by 20...

I'll take that over fighting for 17th spot with Richmond after 5 years of being bottom of the barrel.

 

[sherb]

Nah mate

Nah mate, I’m talking like you won’t win a flag in the next couple of years, and after that, times up. You’re just not that good. Case in point, today’s game against a side only just turning the corner you desperately needed some extraordinary umpire intervention to get you over line.

Another one who would prefer to bag Carlton/umpires rather than give the club he supports credit for a good performance.

 

[CCurnow3votes]

Carlton will be playing tennis in September .

Straights sets baggers.

Not a very convincing team.

Strange take - we won 2 finals LY.

We will have a home final TY - your opinion sucks.

 

[Cripps 'n' Blue Bloods]

How do they miss something that obvious that everyone else could see?

Happens all too frequently.

 

[Chism]

Nah mate

Nah mate, I’m talking like you won’t win a flag in the next couple of years, and after that, times up. You’re just not that good. Case in point, today’s game against a side only just turning the corner you desperately needed some extraordinary umpire intervention to get you over line.

Bit like your namesake and the Mariners?

 

[Ichiro #51]

We had like 7 players come off with injuries during the game, had Cripps and Kennedy in the ruck vs Xerri at times and are currently in a form slump... Yet we won by 20...

I'll take that over fighting for 17th spot with Richmond after 5 years of being bottom of the barrel.

Oh dear. Have you even followed Carlton over the last twenty years?

 

[CCurnow3votes]

Nah mate

Nah mate, I’m talking like you won’t win a flag in the next couple of years, and after that, times up. You’re just not that good. Case in point, today’s game against a side only just turning the corner you desperately needed some extraordinary umpire intervention to get you over line.

pfftt - north.

Thanks for the win.

We played so badly - only against north could we win.

 

[beema limapep]

Yap all i want. Sitting 2nd on the ladder being spoke shit by cellar dwelling campaigners.

North have literally won 2 flags since you last won yours 30 odd years ago, and have finished bottom 3 times less than Carlton.

They have you covered in the afl era.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

North have literally won 2 flags since you last won yours 30 odd years ago, and have finished bottom 3 times less than Carlton.

They have you covered in the afl era.

And yet here we are sitting in 2nd spot while North is 2nd last still... After 4 years of doing so.

We have a good list (Not a great list) that should be set up to contend for a flag over the next 3-4 years with some tinkering and good luck needed along the way. North are where we were 6 years ago.

 

[Cripps 'n' Blue Bloods]

In no world is that HTB. Even with the tighter interpretation. If that had been called against North for the Blues, this place would be in even more meltdown.
Picks up the ball and is immediately tackled as he's kicking. Play on every day of the week.

 

[CCurnow3votes]

North have literally won 2 flags since you last won yours 30 odd years ago, and have finished bottom 3 times less than Carlton.

They have you covered in the afl era.

Who gives a s**t?

Richmond lol - no choice but to live in the past.

 

[CharlieMortdecai]

Of course there is no conspiracy with the umpiring. The issue is that nobody knows how the **** the rules are supposed to be "interpreted" including the umpires.
Four umpires is only beneficial if they are all singing from the same song sheet. It becomes a negative (and completely infuriating to supporters) having four umps if they are all paying them differently.

 

[beema limapep]

And yet here we are sitting in 2nd spot while North is 2nd last still... After 4 years of doing so.

We have a good list (Not a great list) that should be set up to contend for a flag over the next 3-4 years with some tinkering and good luck needed along the way. North are where we were 6 years ago.

So what? You may be going better over the past couple of years but you haven't really achieved anything. And calling a team cellar dwellers who have had 3 less wooden spoons than Carlton and 2 more premierships since their last is a bit rich.

 

[Roosurgence]

It ended with a throw. It's the one handed disposal that has an upward throwing motion.

So what do you call Kennedy getting tackled and dropping it?

Plays for Carlton and it’s in North’s F50, so play on.

The funny thing it wasn’t the worst decision of the day. Jesse Motlop wins that award for the free in front of goal when no one makes contact with you.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

So what? You may be going better over the past couple of years but you haven't really achieved anything. And calling a team cellar dwellers who have had 3 less wooden spoons than Carlton and 2 more premierships since their last is a bit rich.

As opposed to calling us kissed on the dick cheats? It goes both ways Beema.

North fans and 'neutrals' who despise Carlton screeching about umpires and how **** our list is and all the rest of it... What are you expecting Carlton fans to do? Just sit there and agree?

 

[beema limapep]

Who gives a s**t?

Richmond lol - no choice but to live in the past.

Hit a nerve did we? And youve got all you work in front of you

 

[Chism]

So what? You may be going better over the past couple of years but you haven't really achieved anything. And calling a team cellar dwellers who have had 3 less wooden spoons than Carlton and 2 more premierships since their last is a bit rich.

Can understand your sympathy for them considering you will be overtaking their mantle as the shittest team in the comp soon if not already under Yze and in a comp that has a current day Eagles in it that is no mean feat.

Tiger supporters are just about to be put asleep again for another 5 decades and no one cares about you or your team.

 

[carlton_99]

In no world is that HTB. Even with the tighter interpretation. If that had been called against North for the Blues, this place would be in even more meltdown.
Picks up the ball and is immediately tackled as he's kicking. Play on every day of the week.

It's the media/commentators fault - the rule itself is so basic and they keep getting it wrong (like the umpires). If you have prior you have to legally dispose of it BUT if you don't have prior all you have to do is make a genuine attempt. Commentators still don't get the second part

 

[CCurnow3votes]

Hit a nerve did we? And youve got all you work in front of you

Hardly - we're 2nd on the ladder - you're not making much sense.

A Trolling Richmond fan - lol.

 

[CharlieMortdecai]

It's the media/commentators fault - the rule itself is so basic and they keep getting it wrong (like the umpires). If you have prior you have to legally dispose of it BUT if you don't have prior all you have to do is make a genuine attempt. Commentators still don't get the second part

This is an over-simplification, the issue is what is considered "prior" is different in 2024 than it was in 2023, which in itself is different to what it was 5 years ago.

 

[beema limapep]

As opposed to calling us kissed on the dick cheats? It goes both ways Beema.

North fans and 'neutrals' who despise Carlton screeching about umpires and how **** our list is and all the rest of it... What are you expecting Carlton fans to do? Just sit there and agree?

You don't have to answer to me but at least you are being honest about your fellow supporters being disengenuous

 

[Chism]

Hardly - we're 2nd on the ladder - you're not making much sense.

A Trolling Richmond fan - lol.

They have a few and notice that Jordanoirjab bloke or whatever he calls himself has been non existent lately?

 

[King Hansen]

You have won 2 games all season with the games self appointed messiah as a coach.

Yet you get Salty when we beat you.

How many games did Carlton win in 2018 again? For the WHOLE year?

 

[carlton_99]

This is an over-simplification, the issue is what is considered "prior" is different in 2024 than it was in 2023, which in itself is different to what it was 5 years ago.

Kennedy picks it up and immediately goes to kick it - how much faster can he possibly make an attempt? The change in interpretation has not even been around prior opportunity - it is about the "make a genuine attempt" part of the rule.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

How many games did Carlton win in 2018 again? For the WHOLE year?

As many as you did a couple of years ago. But we had a better %