Out: LeCras (needs a kick up the arse), A Selwood, Embley
In: whoever, doesn't matter
In: whoever, doesn't matter
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Unofficial Preview Changes for Round 11 v St.Kilda @ ES
- Thread starter CursoryMercenary
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Out: being 2nd to every ball
In: being first to every ball
In: being first to every ball
Pace, aggression, hardness, intent and desperation. All sorely lacking tonight. Our defence wasn't very well balanced.
OUT- A. Selwood
IN- Waters
Only change for me. Hutchings played alright IMO and putting Gaff and/or Lecca into the WAFL where they will just annihilate and where we will not benefit from their absence is not a good idea.
IN- Waters
Only change for me. Hutchings played alright IMO and putting Gaff and/or Lecca into the WAFL where they will just annihilate and where we will not benefit from their absence is not a good idea.
Some of you people are shit supporters, where's the faith in Woosha?
This was always going to be a tough game I'm not overly surprised, the team wasn't that great and Tigers have serious pace in every line.
Out:
Adam Selwood (why was he playing?)
Lecca (love him but ****, cast or no cast no excuses, needs to know his spot isn't safe)
In:
Mcginnity (quicker than selwood, kicking skills at the worst are equal, better tackle)
Dick (just to prove a point to Lecca, get someone who wants to get involved)
This was always going to be a tough game I'm not overly surprised, the team wasn't that great and Tigers have serious pace in every line.
Out:
Adam Selwood (why was he playing?)
Lecca (love him but ****, cast or no cast no excuses, needs to know his spot isn't safe)
In:
Mcginnity (quicker than selwood, kicking skills at the worst are equal, better tackle)
Dick (just to prove a point to Lecca, get someone who wants to get involved)
lmach
Naitanui2Yeo
Out: Mackenzie, Masten, Hill, Brown, Kerr, Glass, Shuey, Scooter, Naitanui, Cox
In: Cripps, Dalziell, McGinnity, Hams, Dick, Morton, Carter, Colledge, Smith, McInnes
Come at me.
In: Cripps, Dalziell, McGinnity, Hams, Dick, Morton, Carter, Colledge, Smith, McInnes
Come at me.
Let's face it we have a major attitude problem. It has been visible this year, but tonight it was obvious from about 15 minutes into the game. Pity the others can't show the same level of endeavour and commitment as Josh Hill.
A Selwood and Embley out, LeCras must be close to getting a run in the seconds.
Not sure how McGinnity is playing, but he never stops trying unlike many in our team tonight. Whoever does come in, it should be people who will have a crack, and not stand flat-footed while the oppo mids rip us apart. Some of the lack of effort tonight was unworthy of an AFL side, come to think of it any sports team at any level.
I've been the strongest Woosh supporter even when we got the spoon, but if he can't motivate the players, and maybe show a little bit of imagination when we're facing a 9-goal run against us, then he will come under pressure.
A Selwood and Embley out, LeCras must be close to getting a run in the seconds.
Not sure how McGinnity is playing, but he never stops trying unlike many in our team tonight. Whoever does come in, it should be people who will have a crack, and not stand flat-footed while the oppo mids rip us apart. Some of the lack of effort tonight was unworthy of an AFL side, come to think of it any sports team at any level.
I've been the strongest Woosh supporter even when we got the spoon, but if he can't motivate the players, and maybe show a little bit of imagination when we're facing a 9-goal run against us, then he will come under pressure.
Leave hams out.
Forgot about Waters, would drop Embley.
Forgot about Waters, would drop Embley.
lmach
Naitanui2Yeo
There go our top 4 chances.Did his hammy today
Eastern Rangers
2015 Worsfold Medalist - Rowen Powell
Out: A.Selwood, Priddis, Embley.
In: Lamp, Inanimate Carbon Rod, Broom Stick.
In: Lamp, Inanimate Carbon Rod, Broom Stick.
lmach
Naitanui2Yeo
I hope we get to see some close-ups of the rod!
People can say what they want about McGinnity and Hams on the talent stakes, but you're never in doubt that they are two blokes who. want. the. ball. They should be both seriously considered. I'd rather blokes who are playing for next week than blokes who are playing for their next paycheck. The intent tonight was a joke. Match committee needs to send a message about blokes earning their games.
Inanimate carbon rod will not fit under anyone's salary cap, way too good.
Do not consider Hams, offers nothing, would rather shep playing that role if it came to it.
Shupe
Brownlow Medallist
- Jun 21, 2011
- 13,337
- 10,402
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Indianapolis Colts
Give McGinnity a shot then. Brennan plays poorly in WAFL and surprise surprise, plays poorly in AFL. He can be as hard as you want, but you don't want him to actually get possession. That says a lot.
lmach
Naitanui2Yeo
Hey! He's holding the rod!
Are you suggesting McGinnity is an upgrade on disposing over Brennan?
- Oct 8, 2007
- 13,761
- 9,455
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- FLO-RIDA , PITBULL ,SEAN PAUL
I think Hutchy had trouble picking up pace of game from wafl but laid some good tackles and handball overlaps ,only played his 3rd game so his input is not that cringeworthy as a fringe player
- Sep 24, 2010
- 7,310
- 8,057
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Phili Eagles + Sixers
I agree with Mcginnity but no way should Hams come back into the side (although he will).
Hams is too slow for a small man and he offers no defensive pressure. The only attribute he brings is the shoulder shrug and I think we can do without that one.
We need foot speed.
In: Mcginnity, Waters, Brennan
Out: A.Selwood, Hutchings, Butler
Move Sheppard back to half forward. Hutchings is unlucky as he has been good but offers a lot of what we already have.
Brennan may have been bad in the WAFL but so was Embley last week apparently and he still got selected. We need defenders that can run to counter Milne, Saad and Milera (if selected).
Those 3 ins bring a lot intensity which was desperately missing tonight.
Retain
Kerr: Regardless the score his elite skills shine
JK: Champion
JD: Champion - visible heart and passion
Josh Hill: Gotta love this guy
Woosh: Beaten tonite/this season - but we will benefit from his learnings
Final Warning
Scooter: Lets not pretend that this bloke will ever find the extra half second that his brother Josh has
Andrew Gaff: We know your strengths Andrew. Do you know how to win a contested possession?
Gone
Embley: Thanks for the memories
A. Selwood: Thanks for the memories
Burns: Weight of numbers - stats tell the story and you are a casualty of that story
Kerr: Regardless the score his elite skills shine
JK: Champion
JD: Champion - visible heart and passion
Josh Hill: Gotta love this guy
Woosh: Beaten tonite/this season - but we will benefit from his learnings
Final Warning
Scooter: Lets not pretend that this bloke will ever find the extra half second that his brother Josh has
Andrew Gaff: We know your strengths Andrew. Do you know how to win a contested possession?
Gone
Embley: Thanks for the memories
A. Selwood: Thanks for the memories
Burns: Weight of numbers - stats tell the story and you are a casualty of that story
Out: Downhill skiing
In: Work rate
Please?
In: Work rate
Please?
