Preview Changes: R3 vs Fremantle

[Scorpus]

Also I don't know what is wrong with Smith, he looks physically fast enough, fit enough.
He's shanking it all over the place and late to contests, weak in defensive actions, fumbly as all hell.

Sort your s**t out man.

He looks slow and lazy to me

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

He looks slow and lazy to me

Whatever his issue, he needs to back to the sanfl & should be 1st dropped after 2 terrible games.

 

[FR0GGY]

Tell smith if we aren’t in finals you can play the 2nd to last round at home as a farewell and if you perform in that game you get your final game as 250th.
Give him all season to work on his game.

 

[CharlieCrow]

He looks slow and lazy to me

Seriously disrespectful. Call him out of form, ready to retire or not up to it anymore but lazy, that's not fair.

 

[I Lost My Keays]

Curtin > Murphy
Dowling > Berry

 

[MsTopG]

Whatever his issue, he needs to back to the sanfl & should be 1st dropped after 2 terrible games.

He's done. It happens to every player.

 

[MRB37]

He's done. It happens to every player.

Yep, he's 32, he was teetering over the cliff last year and another off-season has seen him go all the way over.

The only fear next is Nicks' "experience" philosophy will see us make another Sloane like decision and give him another year.

 

[Ham]

Hamill and Sholl played well




On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[glengowan]

F: Soligo Fogarty McHenry
HF: Curtin Walker Rankine
C: Keays Dawson Hamill
HB: Milera Keane Hinge
B: Michalanney Borlase Worrell
R: O'Brien Crouch Rachele
I: Pedlar Strachan Laird Berry
Sub: Jones

Out: Butts, Smith, Murphy, Burgess, Jones (sub)
In: Borlase, Hamill, Curtin, Strachan, McHenry

It seems Burgess, Gollant, Himmelberg are all pretty useless. Lets try 2 rucks and play one of them forward once in a while to offer a big target. Also might shake our midfield up a bit if Strachan can offer something different to ROB at the taps. Give Hamill a chance on the wing. Smith has been poor and Jones, again, underwhelming. Give Curtin a go - first game in his home state in front of family.

 

[twiggy4PM]

Drop Smith, pick Curtin, move Laird back to the HBF. Get Rochele, Rankine or Sog in at the bounce.

 

[cleanhands]

F: Soligo Fogarty McHenry
HF: Curtin Walker Rankine
C: Keays Dawson Hamill
HB: Milera Keane Hinge
B: Michalanney Borlase Worrell
R: O'Brien Crouch Rachele
I: Pedlar Strachan Laird Berry
Sub: Jones

Out: Butts, Smith, Murphy, Burgess, Jones (sub)
In: Borlase, Hamill, Curtin, Strachan, McHenry

It seems Burgess, Gollant, Himmelberg are all pretty useless. Lets try 2 rucks and play one of them forward once in a while to offer a big target. Also might shake our midfield up a bit if Strachan can offer something different to ROB at the taps. Give Hamill a chance on the wing. Smith has been poor and Jones, again, underwhelming. Give Curtin a go - first game in his home state in front of family.

Not sure why you want to drop Butts

 

[Burtonsgottago]

In: Nankervis; Out: Smith
In: McHenry; Out: Murphy
In: Hamill: Out: Berry

Move Rankine to the mids, play McHenry in the small forward role. Try something at least different.

No way does McHenry enter that F50

 

[Burtonsgottago]

Taylor would be way more effective than murphy in the same role. Nicks just can't figure it out.

I mean what's his excuse gonna be? He's not fit enough to play at half forward? He's not ready? But a pile of s**t murphy with no talent is? No mate, you’re just an incompetent coach.

Hey mate, you may not like a player but the name calling is pretty over the top

 

[Burtonsgottago]

Ins - Outs
Nankervis - Murphy
Curtin - Smith
Taylor - Berry
Cook - McHenry

B: Michalanney, Butts, Keane
HB: Milera, Worrell, Hinge
C: Jones, Crouch, Dawson
HF: Rachele, Walker, Keays
F: Rankine, Fogarty, Burgess
R: O'Brien, Soligo, Laird
I: Curtin, Taylor, Nankervis Cook
Sub: Pedlar

I like this team because Ned and Murphy aren’t in it. Pedlar shows more than Jones though. Jones is a major disappointment and a terrible draft pick.

 

[WetCrow1991]

Also I don't know what is wrong with Smith, he looks physically fast enough, fit enough.
He's shanking it all over the place and late to contests, weak in defensive actions, fumbly as all hell.

Sort your s**t out man.

He is finished and shit, that's what is wrong with him. Nothing to sort out, he is done.

 

[MsTopG]

A team that won't happen:

Max Butts Worrell
Curtin Keane Milera
Nank Dawson Hinge
Rachele Walker Pedlar
Rankine Fogarty Gollant

ROB Soligo Laird

Cook Dowling Edwards Keays

In:
Curtin Nankervis Gollant Cook Dowling Edwards

Out:
Crouch Smith Murphy Jones Berry Burgess

 

[Scorpus]

Seriously disrespectful. Call him out of form, ready to retire or not up to it anymore but lazy, that's not fair.

Some of his efforts on the weekend were pathetic. He's been phoning it in for years, it's absolutely lazy from one of our senior leadership group players.

 

[George Kramer]

Got to say, the depth of our squad is pretty crap. Not a lot of exposed talent.

Out: Murphy, Berry, Smith
In: Nank, Dowling, Cook

Cook up forward to replace Murphy.
Soligo in the middle to replace Berry.
Dowling on the wing to replace Soligo.
Nank half back to replace Smith

Smith to sub, McHenry out.

 

[spenze]

Not sure why you want to drop Butts

Well obviously, he's to blame for the lack of pressure our midfield put on the opposition when they were drilling Hawkins chest

 

[spenze]

Got to say, the depth of our squad is pretty crap. Not a lot of exposed talent.

Out: Murphy, Berry, Smith
In: Nank, Dowling, Cook

Cook up forward to replace Murphy.
Soligo in the middle to replace Berry.
Dowling on the wing to replace Soligo.
Nank half back to replace Smith

Smith to sub, McHenry out.

I dunno, top 3 pick on talent from last year, generational midfield tall...he seems depth

 

[Danger in Texas]

Got to say, the depth of our squad is pretty crap. Not a lot of exposed talent.

Out: Murphy, Berry, Smith
In: Nank, Dowling, Cook

Cook up forward to replace Murphy.
Soligo in the middle to replace Berry.
Dowling on the wing to replace Soligo.
Nank half back to replace Smith

Smith to sub, McHenry out.

Smith does not deserve to be anywhere near the AFL side this week, not even sub

Put Curtin or Taylor in and make Pedlar sub. Shit, even Sholl would be a better option right now

 

[George Kramer]

I dunno, top 3 pick on talent from last year, generational midfield tall...he seems depth

Oh shit, I forgot about Curtin!! I was thinking Edwards and Ryan from last year.

Would love to know how he got through yesterday.

 

[WetCrow1991]

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

I want Murphy and smith out as much as anyone.

But it’s pointless discussing changes whilst this stupid slow down the line game plan persists.

No player changes will matter.

 

[Redleg Crow]

Out: Smith, Laird, Berry, Murphy, McHenry (sub)
In: Curtin, Nankervis, Edwards, Taylor, Cook (sub)

Would love to see this.

It’ll likely be Ned and Murphy swap