Autopsy Round 22 = Sydney 89-86 Collingwood.

[TW Sherrin]

Does it though?

Bombers don't look too flash to me. Where has it helped them?

And I can't think of many/any games the Cats have won purely on an umpiring decision.

Essendon are I think second on the free kick ladder.

Interesting 4 of the top 6 are interstate teams.

Must be that vicbias.

 

[Knoxy]

You have a very naive view of human behaviour if you don’t think it’s possible

There was an umpire charged last year for releasing details of Brownlow votes

Lots of these guys grow up hating the pies like 80 percent of the football public
It’s not beyond the realm of possibilities to take their conscious bias into a game
Anyway I don’t really care what you think A@$!wipe
I don’t think lateral thinking is your strong point

For every Pies fan complaining about anti Collingwood umpire bias there are many more opposition fans complaining about pro Collingwood bias. Maybe the umpires are just human and make mistakes?

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Gee

Short memory mate

Watch the 2022 qualifying final replay

We would have won that game by 4 goals without Rosebury

There’s even a convenient highlight package of the decisions in question on YouTube

And that was all due to Scott bringing up umpiring decisions in his presser the week before was it?

 

[black is White]

Every one who is sound of mind would realise this but Mr A@&)&wipe is slow on the uptake

There's no real point arguing it here tho it's never going to go down well and what's there to gain? I get the venting and frustration part.

"Its easier to fool people than to convince them that they have been fooled" - Mark Twain

 

[cfc19902010]

And that was all due to Scott bringing up umpiring decisions in his presser the week before was it?

Not sure but Geelong have been kissed on the dick a lot when it comes to umpiring

 

[cfc19902010]

For every Pies fan complaining about anti Collingwood umpire bias there are many more opposition fans complaining about pro Collingwood bias. Maybe the umpires are just human and make mistakes?

And maybe like a footy population sample size 80 percent of them hate Collingwood

 

[black is White]

And that was all due to Scott bringing up umpiring decisions in his presser the week before was it?

Worst part for me was I bloody knew Geelong would go on and win it as soon as that match ended. After losing to Sydney I also said they'd be thumped in the GF and not make the 8 the following year in the YouTube Match highlights and all the syndey supporters lost their minds

 

[sideswipe]

Every one who is sound of mind would realise as a possibility but Mr A@&)&wipe is slow on the uptake

You clearly don’t understand the heavy internal scrutiny the umps face. If they were to bring conscious or unconscious bias onto the field, it would be clearly revealed in their reviews and they would soon be out of a job.

Keeping that job is probably something that might bring on some bias. To do their best to make correct decisions.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Not sure but Geelong have been kissed on the dick a lot when it comes to umpiring

And there are plenty of oppo supporters who say exactly the same about us.

The reality is we won the premiership last year, so the supposed umpiring conspiracy against us didn't work last year did it?

Plenty think Cox jumped forward during McGovern's kick last week. Plenty think North should have got a 50 metre penalty similar to the one McStay didn't get last night.

We were less than a goal behind last night with 4 minutes left. Plenty of time to win it & nothing to do with the umpires.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Worst part for me was I bloody knew Geelong would go on and win it as soon as that match ended. After losing to Sydney I also said they'd be thumped in the GF and not make the 8 the following year in the YouTube Match highlights and all the syndey supporters lost their minds

Swans will get smashed this year too.

 

[cfc19902010]

You clearly don’t understand the heavy internal scrutiny the umps face. If they were to bring conscious or unconscious bias onto the field, it would be clearly revealed in their reviews and they would soon be out of a job.

Keeping that job is probably something that might bring on some bias. To do their best to make correct decisions.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

So all the terrible decisions are all harmless innocent mistakes ???


I don’t think so

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

And maybe like a footy population sample size 80 percent of them hate Collingwood

Are you the bloke who called up sen?

 

[cfc19902010]

And there are plenty of oppo supporters who say exactly the same about us.

The reality is we won the premiership last year, so the supposed umpiring conspiracy against us didn't work last year did it?

Plenty think Cox jumped forward during McGovern's kick last week. Plenty think North should have got a 50 metre penalty similar to the one McStay didn't get last night.

We were less than a goal behind last night with 4 minutes left. Plenty of time to win it & nothing to do with the umpires.

Nothing to do with umpires ???

Last night ???

Jesus

What more can I say

 

[cfc19902010]

Are you the bloke who called up sen?

No

But I wish I had of

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Nothing to do with umpires ???

Last night ???

Jesus

What more can I say

So the umpires stopped us from kicking a goal in the last 4 minutes?

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

No

But I wish I had of

You're not as articulate. He was still equally embarrassing with his umpiring conspiracy theory against Pies and comparing it to racism.

 

[JoinDate]

For every Pies fan complaining about anti Collingwood umpire bias there are many more opposition fans complaining about pro Collingwood bias. Maybe the umpires are just human and make mistakes?

Please stop this rational posting. I'm emotional about our season and want to vent to my hearts desire to the point where I want to believe there's a conspiracy at play, and you're ruining that for me.

 

[black is White]

And there are plenty of oppo supporters who say exactly the same about us.

The reality is we won the premiership last year, so the supposed umpiring conspiracy against us didn't work last year did it?

Plenty think Cox jumped forward during McGovern's kick last week. Plenty think North should have got a 50 metre penalty similar to the one McStay didn't get last night.

We were less than a goal behind last night with 4 minutes left. Plenty of time to win it & nothing to do with the umpires.

My issue is the amount of dropping, throwing and holding the balls they blatantly ignore. I reckon their would of been 30+ all up easily. The umpires clearly aren't up to the task anywho as the 8 or so out of bounds they missed then even had the boundry umpire overrule a field umpire saying throw it in instead of deliberate out of bounds. I'm not even going to mention the rest of the obvious dubious decisions.

 

[cfc19902010]

You're not as articulate. He was still equally embarrassing with his umpiring conspiracy theory against Pies and comparing it to racism.

Thanks your not mark Twain either

 

[cfc19902010]

Thanks your not mark Twain either

You know what’s embarrassing

You Collingwood nuffies towing the company line with everything’s apples

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

My issue is the amount of dropping, throwing and holding the balls they blatantly ignore. I reckon their would of been 30+ all up easily. The umpires clearly aren't up to the task anywho as the 8 or so out of bounds they missed then even had the boundry umpire overrule a field umpire saying throw it in instead of deliberate out of bounds. I'm not even going to mention the rest of the obvious dubious decisions.

Yes, they're consistently poor. Across all games for all teams. You only need to read the comments on other clubs boards & socials.

The AFL needs to make them full-time. Give them a proper football ground to train on. Make them train together & review the matches. And stop changing the interpretations of rules every single week.

That would be a start.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Thanks your not mark Twain either

'You're'. Capital letter for a name .. 'Mark'. Fullstop.

And weren't you the one wanting to drop/trade Darcy Moore?

 

[black is White]

Yes, they're consistently poor. Across all games for all teams. You only need to read the comments on other clubs boards & socials.

The AFL needs to make them full-time. Give them a proper football ground to train on. Make them train together & review the matches. And stop changing the interpretations of rules every single week.

That would be a start.

Can't argue with any of that it's been glaringly obvious for a while now they shouldn't be part timers. It would only be a start tho as the issues seem pretty deep.

 

[cfc19902010]

'You're'. Capital letter for a name .. 'Mark'. Fullstop.

And weren't you the one wanting to drop/trade Darcy Moore?

Another school teacher

?

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Another school teacher

?

Not at all. I just listened to them when I went to school.