List Mgmt. Contract, Trade and Draft Discussions - 2024 Edition

What should we do with our 1st round draft pick?

  • Finn O’Sullivan

    Votes: 57 19.0%
  • Sid Draper

    Votes: 86 28.7%
  • Josh Smillie

    Votes: 22 7.3%
  • Jagga Smith

    Votes: 34 11.3%
  • Split for best mid and Tobie Travaglia

    Votes: 46 15.3%
  • Split for best mid and Liam Baker

    Votes: 20 6.7%
  • Split for best mid and best KPD

    Votes: 4 1.3%
  • Split for best two mids

    Votes: 9 3.0%
  • Other

    Votes: 13 4.3%
  • Sam Lalor

    Votes: 9 3.0%

  • Total voters
    300
  • This poll will close: .

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.


Quick links:
Player contract status
Draft prospect video highlights (thanks to noobermensch)
AFL retirements and delistings



Latest news and rumours:


 
Last edited by a moderator:
Actually if Gold Coast were smart, they would bring in top line players that could make a difference.

D Rioli is supposedly a priority and that is a start. I actually think the last thing they need is a bunch of new draftees. They had a heap last year and will get a bunch more top end talent in the next 2 drafts.

Who else is on the market?

They should put their hand up for Tom Barrass and offer 6 and 26 if we pay a big chuck of his salary. They would still have the 11 and 20 to trade with Richmond for Rioli (with % of salary paid by Tigers). That would leave them about enough points for Lombard.

The Suns need to use their picks not continue to bank them forward. For a decade, the Suns continue to bank picks and accumulate young talent. Time to change tact and make finals. Rioli and Barrass would help a lot more in 2025 than picks 6 11 20 and 26.

BTW - I am not advocating Tom would want to go there, only that the Suns should be looking to lure talent up north like Brisbane did with Dunkly and Neal
Barrass won't go to gold coast.

Sister moving to Melbourne, brother also slated to move there soon.



On Pixel 6 Pro using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Id like to think like most that Bazzo > H.Edwards anyway would we not?

If H.Edwards goes also we can then just keep Callum Jamieson and hope he has a injury free year. Backups beyond that can then be your Maric/A.Reid people

We dont need Clurrey or H.Edwards. We are not trying to win a flag here, nor does our defense necessarily need any more experienced help. Our defense is fine without either of them

If H.Edwards unlocks Baker trade then lets do it.

Yes it’s all just fine.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

The level of anxiety over this kid is pretty hilarious. He's checks notes again 197cm..... Has 100% played with a knee injury this year, and was started in Defence in the SANFL. Was given 2 games in the seniors and looked a little behind with the speed of the game because checks notes again.. he's 197cm...

Big lads always take a little longer. We've switched him into midfield, and sure it might look a little frustrating for supporters seeing him injected into the game with only 4 mins to go, but we were in with a sniff against Geelong, and Crouch was likely told to play until he was cooked.

My guess is that he'll either start this weekend in the seniors, or be given full minutes in the SANFL.
Putting checks notes in italics like a tosser detracts from your overall point which actually has validity.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

If we’re hoping to match a bid for Malakai with pick 59 we need that bid to come no earlier than pick 45. If a bid came as early as say pick 30 we’d need to add the equivalent of pick 50 to add to 59 to build enough points to match

Probably want to be going into the draft with an extra F3 that we can use to trade back into this years draft to cover a possibly earlier than expected bid
 
Just from a player point of view, Harry's going to have more of a chance of winning a flag with us than the Demons. They've peaked but just don't know it yet.
Yes but when we are considered ready to win a flag, Harry might be at the club but not in our Best 23.

Agree that Demons are in trouble and they have not made the most of Gawn (32), Lever (28), May (32), Viney (30), Oliver (27) , Brayshaw (retired) and Petracca (28). All these players bar Angus are still capable of going around again but the cliff will come fast for the club.
 
Saw Will Brodie raised earlier today - one dimensional, average tank, lacks a defensive game. The exact antithesis of the type of player we should be adding to the list.

At least Graham can kick a snag and can play defensive roles.
 
3 of the young boys named in the 22under22 squad. Hopefully joined by JWill, Hewett and Sid/FOS next year….. but the rebuild hasn’t started.
To be clear, it is a best squad of 40 under 22. That said, your point is still valid.

Hough (draft 21) Ginbey (draft 22) and Harley (draft 23). Hewett (draft 22) has shown enough if fit he is in that league.
 
Here is the AFLPA list of best 40 Squad of players under 22

1723107864734.png

Norf have 5, while Freo and Hawks have 4. Eagles along with Crows, Cats, Suns, Dees and Dogs have 3

Dons and Tigers are the 2 clubs not represented

Since it is 40, I suspect Harley is the only one that is certain to get in the best 22

When you consider Freo with 3 x R1 picks this year and 4 representatives, their list profile is pretty good and they can afford to trade these picks for layers who can get them a flag
 
Here is the AFLPA list of best 40 Squad of players under 22

View attachment 2072357

Norf have 5, while Freo and Hawks have 4. Eagles along with Crows, Cats, Suns, Dees and Dogs have 3

Dons and Tigers are the 2 clubs not represented

Since it is 40, I suspect Harley is the only one that is certain to get in the best 22

When you consider Freo with 3 x R1 picks this year and 4 representatives, their list profile is pretty good and they can afford to trade these picks for layers who can get them a flag
If the voters watched Eagles games, then Hough would be a shoo-in.
 
Ah read that as all 4 would. My bad

I think too early to give up on Flynn. Still not 100% fit as he has mentioned before
We cant go into another season hoping Flynn gets up for every game. If we could rely on him then sure, but we cant.

Need something better than Flynn/BW.

The only suggested ruckman that would push Flynn out for next year is English
 
That is a very Eagles-coloured view of the comparison. Premierships are won in the midfield, A-grade midfielders will always be worth more than even A-grade defenders. And the difference between being at the start of your peak and nearing the end of your peak is probably the mot important reason why Warner is worth more than Barrass.
Too bad Warner is a B grader then eh😏
 
Here is the AFLPA list of best 40 Squad of players under 22

View attachment 2072357

Norf have 5, while Freo and Hawks have 4. Eagles along with Crows, Cats, Suns, Dees and Dogs have 3

Dons and Tigers are the 2 clubs not represented

Since it is 40, I suspect Harley is the only one that is certain to get in the best 22

When you consider Freo with 3 x R1 picks this year and 4 representatives, their list profile is pretty good and they can afford to trade these picks for layers who can get them a flag
Yeah freo are very well set up atm. They can afford to trade in talent while still drafting high.
Not too many holes to plug either

On SM-S921B using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top