Preview R10: Changes v GWS

[Wouldbetackler]

Really to beat Giants I think:
Ins: Laird, Brouch, Mrouch
Out: thomo (managed), VB/Cheney, And does dougie have to go back and snag 36 touches?

 

[Bicks]

Really to beat Giants I think:
Ins: Laird, Brouch, Mrouch
Out: thomo (managed), VB/Cheney, And does dougie have to go back and snag 36 touches?

You think we can beat the Giants??

 

[haydo]

You think we can beat the Giants??

We can beat anyone when we're up and about playing our best footy. If this match was in round 3 I would have a lot more confidence, but currently, I do not

 

[billy fragos]

Really to beat Giants I think:
Ins: Laird, Brouch, Mrouch
Out: thomo (managed), VB/Cheney, And does dougie have to go back and snag 36 touches?

No, he was quite solid today.

 

[Bicks]

We can beat anyone when we're up and about playing our best footy. If this match was in round 3 I would have a lot more confidence, but currently, I do not

Not the way our midfield are playing....and Mummy likely to monster Sauce..

 

[Jeffcrowe]

no difference in the rehab of Laird and Brad ......but you have diametrically opposed views of whether straight in the AFL or SANFL ......just a touch inconsistent here Kane

Massive difference - laird had been playing
consistently good football for over 12 months and has missed 2 weeks of running and 3 games

Brad has missed a season , then been niggled up a couple of times for over a month

 

[dogs105]

20 disposals against a severely depleted midfield and only 3 clearances??

Matt could do that in his sleep against such poor opposition.

Only way Lyons plays before Matt Crouch [if fit] is if Thommo is rested.

You'll change your mind when you watch the game.

 

[haydo]

Not the way our midfield are playing....and Mummy likely to monster Sauce..

It's amazing at what the occasion will do to players. Saturday night at home in front of 50+ thousand, the boys will make sure they're cherry ripe for this one. Gee I hope Sauce can have a big one. It'll all start with him on Saturday night

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Hopefully the Giants-Bulldogs game is fast, frenetic and close

 

[dogs105]

Feeling confident about next week.

Out: Cheney Hendo

In: Kelly Brouch

VB for Laird if fit
Maybe Mrouch for Thommo

 

[Bicks]

You'll change your mind when you watch the game.

You're really pushing Baccs for the most optimistic poster on this Board..

One things for sure you'll never be accused of being a pessimist...

 

[haydo]

I don't understand all the Kelly love for next week. One solid game in the SANFL after missing weeks being injured. Needs to string consistent games together to be considered

 

[dogs105]

You're really pushing Baccs for the most optimistic poster on this Board..

One things for sure you'll never be accused of being a pessimist...

You can't have watched the game and want Lyons out.

Surely Hendo, Cheney and VB in line first

 

[dogs105]

I don't understand all the Kelly love for next week. One solid game in the SANFL after missing weeks being injured. Needs to string consistent games together to be considered

Not a position we have heaps of depth at the moment though. It's getting close to anyone-but-Cheney time

 

[Cap]

Do we have another KPD?

 

[dogs105]

Do we have another KPD?

Poor old Shaw would have probably been next in line earlier in the season.

Otten or Kelly could come in. Then probably Ramsey?

 

[1970crow]

Whoever dropped Brad Crouch is a ******* moron. He's clearly too good for SANFL and there's no reason to play him there.

Today he had 36 touches, (19 kicks 17 handballs), 6 marks, 5 tackles, 11 clearances, 3 inside 50s. And he will continue to do so from now until eternity if he remains there.

On top of that we have a bye next week and we just have to keep getting Brad Crouch into good, AFL form

Campo described the despcision as being a "really smart decision". Seriously, could we actually have a more ******ed 2Ic? He's so effing stupid

 

[Tex200]

I don't understand all the Kelly love for next week. One solid game in the SANFL after missing weeks being injured. Needs to string consistent games together to be considered

Was in good form prior to injury

 

[Wouldbetackler]

You think we can beat the Giants??

Yeah I think we can definitely playing our best

 

[Bicks]

You can't have watched the game and want Lyons out.

Surely Hendo, Cheney and VB in line first

Only problem, none of them are midfielders, I don't have a problem with Lyons staying in but not at the expense of B. Crouch & M. Crouch [if fit], Ok with Thompson being rested or Douglas going back to to the Snaffle...you do realise Lyons only managed 3 clearances against a midfield consisting of Prestia and a no name midfield, I thought Lyons was brought in for his "clearance" work??.....

GWS midfield : Mumford, and a mix of Stephen Coniglio, Dylan Sheil, Ryan Griffen, Will Hoskin-Eliott, Josh Kelly, Toby Greene, Jacob Hopper, Callan Ward, Tom Scully, Jack Steele.........scary thought!!

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

Feeling confident about next week.

Out: Cheney Hendo

In: Kelly Brouch

VB for Laird if fit
Maybe Mrouch for Thommo

Kelly won't come in next week

Bookmark it

 

[1990crow]

Out: Cheney, VB, Henderson
In: Kelly, Laird, B.Crouch

 

[Crowmeariver]

In: Laird (if fit), B Crouch, Knight (if fit), CEY
Out: Thommo, VB, Henderson, Cheney

 

[I Lost My Keays]

IN: Laird , B.Crouch
Out: Cheney , Henderson

 

[Crowmeariver]

Hopefully the Giants-Bulldogs game is fast, frenetic and close

Don't think its going to matter, next week could get ugly for the crows!