Autopsy Roast & Toast vs Collingwood & Changes for Melbourne

Best vs Pies

  • 1: Nick Vlastuin

    Votes: 45 16.1%
  • 2: Dylan Grimes

    Votes: 264 94.3%
  • 3: Dion Prestia

    Votes: 218 77.9%
  • 4: Dustin Martin

    Votes: 257 91.8%
  • 5: Brandon Ellis

    Votes: 1 0.4%
  • 8: Jack Riewoldt

    Votes: 2 0.7%
  • 9: Trent Cotchin

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 10: Shane Edwards

    Votes: 1 0.4%
  • 11: Jason Castagna

    Votes: 3 1.1%
  • 12: David Astbury

    Votes: 18 6.4%
  • 14: Bachar Houli

    Votes: 85 30.4%
  • 15: Jayden Short

    Votes: 1 0.4%
  • 17: Daniel Rioli

    Votes: 2 0.7%
  • 19: Tom Lynch

    Votes: 253 90.4%
  • 23: Kane Lambert

    Votes: 52 18.6%
  • 29: Shai Bolton

    Votes: 8 2.9%
  • 34: Jack Graham

    Votes: 54 19.3%
  • 35: Nathan Broad

    Votes: 2 0.7%
  • 41: Mabior Chol

    Votes: 6 2.1%
  • 44: Sydney Stack

    Votes: 9 3.2%
  • 47: Ivan Soldo

    Votes: 17 6.1%
  • 48: Liam Baker

    Votes: 1 0.4%

  • Total voters
    280

Remove this Banner Ad

What happened between Gale and Whateley? Saw a few posts mention something but non of the details...

Didn't sound controversial to me??
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Would rather finish fourth so that Scott can whinge about Geelol playing "their" final at the MCG. Hope the AFL gives in it's played at Unskilled Stadium and Geelol get creamed!
I wonder if Ottens will set his silly bell up with the ground PA so the Cats can hear it this time.
 
Yeah he has done nothing for 10 weeks, so it won’t be hard to improve from that form. I just don’t like some players getting free rides while others get dropped at the drop of a hat. Rant over.

Wow.... You really have no idea. Suggest if you attend you watch Rioli contest to contest and see what he does for the team. Not all about getting high disposals...
 
Rioli out, Cotchin inj. Out.
If Balta had the same opportunity as Rioli this year he would have eclipsed him by now, and that wouldn’t be hard.
Kicked 20 goals for the year while Sam Lloyd has kicked 32. 🤪
Balta will get his chance when his fitness gets up but Rioli is building nicely. His pressure is excellent and there's no way Balta could run out games like Rioli. Ditto SL, even comparing those two is farcical. Wonder how their goal assists, score involvements and pressure acts compare...
 
It was funny, the other day Duck said "a media commentator said Lynch was a liability".
He didn't refer to Lloyd by name.
Never tamper with a successful formula.
Can only see Caddy return for 3-4 weeks while Cotch is out.
Duck said tonight that he believes our current team is stronger than anything we fielded in 2017 and 2018. True or not true I feel for Kamdyn given that he is having his best season to date and really hasn't done much wrong. Our depth is off the charts at the moment. An embarrassment of riches one could say
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Toast to Gerard Healy and Paul Roos who just called out Collingwood's "injury crisis" as the furphy that it is!

I agree. It's an absolute con job.
PLAYERS ON INJURY/SUSPENSION LIST (19):

Taylor Adams (hamstring — TBC), James Aish (shoulder — TBC), Dayne Beams (hip — Indefinite), Jordan De Goey (hamstring — 2-3 weeks), Lynden Dunn (knee — Season), Levi Greenwood (hamstring — TBC), Will Kelly (hamstring — TBC), Tom Langdon (knee — season), Darcy Moore (hamstring — 2-3 weeks), Nathan Murphy (back — test), Sam Murray (provisional suspension — TBC), John Noble (calf — test), Tom Phillips (collarbone — test), Isaac Quaynor (foot stress — 3-4 weeks), Ben Reid (hamstring — TBC), Jordan Roughead (concussion — test), Jaidyn Stephenson (suspension — 5 weeks), Daniel Wells (knee — 5 weeks), Brayden Sier (calf — Test) :huh:
 
I agree. It's an absolute con job.
PLAYERS ON INJURY/SUSPENSION LIST (19):

Taylor Adams (hamstring — TBC), James Aish (shoulder — TBC), Dayne Beams (hip — Indefinite), Jordan De Goey (hamstring — 2-3 weeks), Lynden Dunn (knee — Season), Levi Greenwood (hamstring — TBC), Will Kelly (hamstring — TBC), Tom Langdon (knee — season), Darcy Moore (hamstring — 2-3 weeks), Nathan Murphy (back — test), Sam Murray (provisional suspension — TBC), John Noble (calf — test), Tom Phillips (collarbone — test), Isaac Quaynor (foot stress — 3-4 weeks), Ben Reid (hamstring — TBC), Jordan Roughead (concussion — test), Jaidyn Stephenson (suspension — 5 weeks), Daniel Wells (knee — 5 weeks), Brayden Sier (calf — Test) :huh:
Yep definite quantity... not all that much quality though
 
I agree. It's an absolute con job.
PLAYERS ON INJURY/SUSPENSION LIST (19):

Taylor Adams (hamstring — TBC), James Aish (shoulder — TBC), Dayne Beams (hip — Indefinite), Jordan De Goey (hamstring — 2-3 weeks), Lynden Dunn (knee — Season), Levi Greenwood (hamstring — TBC), Will Kelly (hamstring — TBC), Tom Langdon (knee — season), Darcy Moore (hamstring — 2-3 weeks), Nathan Murphy (back — test), Sam Murray (provisional suspension — TBC), John Noble (calf — test), Tom Phillips (collarbone — test), Isaac Quaynor (foot stress — 3-4 weeks), Ben Reid (hamstring — TBC), Jordan Roughead (concussion — test), Jaidyn Stephenson (suspension — 5 weeks), Daniel Wells (knee — 5 weeks), Brayden Sier (calf — Test) :huh:
Who are all these blokes?
 
Balta will get his chance when his fitness gets up but Rioli is building nicely. His pressure is excellent and there's no way Balta could run out games like Rioli. Ditto SL, even comparing those two is farcical. Wonder how their goal assists, score involvements and pressure acts compare...
SL has been taking a quit a few marks as well, it would be interesting to compare stats.
Agree about Balta and his tank and he is a little green still, but overall his game impact in my view would have been greater with less tank than Rioli. Rioli playing in form would be a different story.

Sydney Stack in his first game up forward showed them all how to play, how to run, when to run, where to position when the ball hits the pack and how to score at every opportunity.

If we are to improve and get ‘next level good’ our small forwards have to hit the score board more often.
Nothing hurts more than scoreboard pressure and when we play vs the eagles we are going to need more than RUN and CHASE.
 
Wow.... You really have no idea. Suggest if you attend you watch Rioli contest to contest and see what he does for the team. Not all about getting high disposals...
Wow.... You really have no idea. Suggest if you attend you watch Rioli contest to contest and see what he does for the team. Not all about getting high disposals...
insult much? Your points in regards to his work rate and pressure points are valid and l do appreciate what he does but there are two versions of playing up forwards, Sydney stacks version and Riolis, I’m saying I’d take Sydney stacks version. This is why stack is now playing up forwards, Rioli has to be effective when the ball doesn’t hit the ground and offer another dimension vs strong marking teams. Yes l am being a little harsh on Rioli. We all say things in here that goes off centre sometimes doesn’t mean we have no clue, just means we have different view points.
 
I agree. It's an absolute con job.
PLAYERS ON INJURY/SUSPENSION LIST (19):

Taylor Adams (hamstring — TBC), James Aish (shoulder — TBC), Dayne Beams (hip — Indefinite), Jordan De Goey (hamstring — 2-3 weeks), Lynden Dunn (knee — Season), Levi Greenwood (hamstring — TBC), Will Kelly (hamstring — TBC), Tom Langdon (knee — season), Darcy Moore (hamstring — 2-3 weeks), Nathan Murphy (back — test), Sam Murray (provisional suspension — TBC), John Noble (calf — test), Tom Phillips (collarbone — test), Isaac Quaynor (foot stress — 3-4 weeks), Ben Reid (hamstring — TBC), Jordan Roughead (concussion — test), Jaidyn Stephenson (suspension — 5 weeks), Daniel Wells (knee — 5 weeks), Brayden Sier (calf — Test) :huh:

Spot on mate. Those you listed all minnow spud role players. You had 15 play Friday that played in the PF. We also had 15 from that game so both were missing 7. We were missing two top 5 players tho in cotchin and rance.

Still thumped you in second gear lel
 
Spot on mate. Those you listed all minnow spud role players. You had 15 play Friday that played in the PF. We also had 15 from that game so both were missing 7. We were missing two top 5 players tho in cotchin and rance.

Still thumped you in second gear lel
Caddy, Kmac, Nank, Ross, Marlion all out!
 
I agree. It's an absolute con job.
PLAYERS ON INJURY/SUSPENSION LIST (19):

Taylor Adams
(hamstring — TBC), James Aish (shoulder — TBC), Dayne Beams (hip — Indefinite), Jordan De Goey (hamstring — 2-3 weeks), Lynden Dunn (knee — Season), Levi Greenwood (hamstring — TBC), Will Kelly (hamstring — TBC), Tom Langdon (knee — season), Darcy Moore (hamstring — 2-3 weeks), Nathan Murphy (back — test), Sam Murray (provisional suspension — TBC), John Noble (calf — test), Tom Phillips (collarbone — test), Isaac Quaynor (foot stress — 3-4 weeks), Ben Reid (hamstring — TBC), Jordan Roughead (concussion — test), Jaidyn Stephenson (suspension — 5 weeks), Daniel Wells (knee — 5 weeks), Brayden Sier (calf — Test) :huh:
The bolded names are genuine losses, De Goey, Roughead and Phillips actually played on Friday night which was the context of Roos and Healy's comments.
Acts of stupidity don't belong on injury lists.
The other point that they made is that you are missing none of your best players.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Autopsy Roast & Toast vs Collingwood & Changes for Melbourne

Back
Top