Autopsy Roast & toast vs Melbourne and changes for round 21 vs Western Bulldogs

Best vs Dees


  • Total voters
    134

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
No one sugar coat that. It was a poor effort by us, full of simple errors that should not be made in the afl and just stupidity utter stupidity.
It was embarrassing
u miss the umpiring ?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Why the **** would we sub Miller off and move Balta out of the backline? All it did was make it easier for dees to score and easier for Lever and May to intercept. Plus Gawn dominated Balta.

Shocking decision by Mini. Twice he's done that against the dees, twice its hurt us.

EDIT: sorry Dimma did it last time.
 
Last edited:
Overpowered by the Dees and the umps with soft 50s and frees.

Jack Ross has been good on the wing winning contests and composed with his ball use. One of the few positives to take out of the game.
 
Nick Vlastuin basically was our backline
 
Hope this is the nail in the coffin for our season, and Mini as a coach candidate.
Had no ticker at selection, and went unchanged.
Our skills are deplorable. Our midfield has no real plan, and our forward entries are constantly rubbish.
Pickett needs to go immediately.
Cumberland and Bauer need to come in for some more potency up forward.



Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Were winning till umpires intervened against a team who is top 4.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

****, Max Gawn. We couldn’t stop him.
Out: Grimes, Soldo
ins: Short, Nankervis
 
Couldn't believe my eyes in the game day thread when everyone was lauding mini for "moving the magnets" and put Balta forward.

Our defence absolutely went to s**t the moment that move was made. Their key forwards were already having a good game but to move your best KPD out to compound the problem is borderline moronic.

One tin arse goal doesn't mean the move worked at all.

Could be the dumbest coaching move you'll see all season from 18 clubs including West Coast and North Melbourne.

Went into the game with no marking targets when Ryan and Cumberland were available (Miller does not count ) so you need to own that decision. You don't then completely sabotage team structure by moving the #1 intercept marker in the AFL.

Thanks but no thanks Mini. Good luck in the future.
 
Hope that loss really hits the selection committee in the head that a few of the premiership hero’s are done

Grimes and Graham especially
****en diabolical

Drop them and play the kids ffs

Brown, Cumbo, Judson all should play next week
 
Soldo was good. Gave his all.
That’s the issue
He gave it his all but it was just a serviceable game

With Nank the better option and Ryan next in line what’s the point of holding Soldo

Trade bait for mine
 
WTF happened to our recruitment when Miller is our 3rd best KPF option? No disrespect to Miller, but Riewoldt has been toward the end of his career the last 2-3 years. Why were we prioritizing multiple inside mids rather than at least a 30 goal/year KPF?
 
5 goal loss is harsh, we were pretty good but outclassed in the second half plus some dumb umpire decisions which cost us goals.

This. 5 goal loss with an ass reaming from the umpires (3 goals from the top of the square from 3 kicks) against the team that likely finishes second.

If Balta plays just an average game we likely win this game, instead he has an absolute shocker and the quality around him isn't good enough to make up for it.
 
QUESTION - do we get a free kick after halfway during the 2nd Q
ANSWER - YEAH 1 with 2 seconds in the game left.
Viney and Trakka try to bulldoze his way through tackles and traffic x 8 times = 8 ball ups.
Taranto, hopper and broad do the same x 5 times = 5 free kicks to Dees
 
That’s the issue
He gave it his all but it was just a serviceable game

With Nank the better option and Ryan next in line what’s the point of holding Soldo

Trade bait for mine

No doubt, but at least Soldo didn't lay down. Gave his all imo.

Need to develop Ryan as that second ruck because he won't make it as a forward imo
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top