2nds 2024 Adelaide Crows SANFL thread

[Cromulant]

Could possibly be on because he told South he was moving to another SANFL club d a couple of weeks ago due to travel....Crows is closer to train.

I thought he was off to Westies ??

 

[Mutineer]

I thought he was off to Westies ??

I don't know, I've retained my Panthers membership/donation and got an email a couple of weeks ago stating what I posted.

 

[Magma]

west announced him about 3 weeks ago

Welcome Jonti Schuback - West Adelaide Football Club

westadelaidefc.com.au

kind of a father son as jacob played some games with us before moving to glenelg

 

[crows dude]

Given our coaching dept has been the source of much frustration I wouldve thought beefing it up more is a good idea. And again, he'd be the perfect player for our SANFL side.

Yep. should have giving him MAdgens role

 

[George Kramer]

Could possibly be on because he told South he was moving to another SANFL club d a couple of weeks ago due to travel....Crows is closer to train.

And Noarlunga oval is a shithole and South a are basket case

 

[Cromulant]

And Noarlunga oval is a shithole and South a are basket case

A+ again

 

[Magma]

And Noarlunga oval is a shithole and South a are basket case

well at least he has moved to a nicer oval with us then

 

[Mostyn]

Not the way it was viewed by him.

He wanted to stay. He was offered a 'FU' contract that was less than his existing contract. It was made very clear they didn't want him.

Again, not being paid what you want isn't necessarily being treated badly.

I've never heard anything from Lyons about being unhappy. That's just football.

 

[Mutineer]

 

[crows dude]

Dam. He turned the Norwood job down.

 

[Cromulant]

Dam. He turned the Norwood job down.

Was more that they came to the party too late.

No doubt the club were caught off guard after Twig resigned.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Dam. He turned the Norwood job down.

To do what?

 

[crows dude]

To do what?

He is back in afl. Waiting for club to announce it. But it’s a Victorian team

 

[Cromulant]

Rumour has been Melbourne with Goody

 

[TBM]

Lyons said in an interview he approached us and some other clubs about coaching but the appropriate possible roles had been filled.

I would've thought Lyons would be an upgrade on Andrew McPherson as a development coach.

Nothing against the kid but surely if there was an option to get Lyons we could've moved McPherson into another role at the club.

 

[adelaidecrows]

I think it was a timing thing - the coaches association say you have to let people know quite early, and that sounds like it was before Lyons started asking the question.

I would have thought becoming a coach in the system would be more networking and headhunting than simple approach. Obviously the exception is some clubs create positions for their own ex players to fill if they want them around the club.

As for Lyons id say he would be best to find a Sanfl club to coach at and work his way into the industry.

 

[adelaidecrows]

I would've thought Lyons would be an upgrade on Andrew McPherson as a development coach.

Nothing against the kid but surely if there was an option to get Lyons we could've moved McPherson into another role at the club.

You have literally just smashed McPherson for literally no reason than a blind assumption.

 

[TBM]

You have literally just smashed McPherson for literally no reason than a blind assumption.

Nothing personal, I literally said "nothing against the kid", I'm aware he is by all reports a cracking bloke...

My point is more if we're trying to beef up our coaching panel with more support - which we've been on record as stating - I would've thought if a 200-game AFL player has (allegedly) approached us, we'd be trying to find a way to fit him in.

 

[adelaidecrows]

Nothing personal, I literally said "nothing against the kid", I'm aware he is by all reports a cracking bloke...

My point is more if we're trying to beef up our coaching panel with more support - which we've been on record as stating - I would've thought if a 200-game AFL player has (allegedly) approached us, we'd be trying to find a way to fit him in.

But the logic you used is equating a player with games experience as an automatic better coach than someone with less games experience. By that logic you could have said Lyons should replace Fagan at Brisbane as his games experience will be telling.

 

[Jeffcrowe]

I would've thought Lyons would be an upgrade on Andrew McPherson as a development coach.

Nothing against the kid but surely if there was an option to get Lyons we could've moved McPherson into another role at the club.

Not sure about this

Feel like McPherson has a future in coaching , very smart lad apparently


Also has a great temperament , would not surprise me if ended up a senior coach

Don’t confuse playing talent with coaching talent

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Have we announced any experienced recruits to sanfl program like port have ?

Any word on what Jaiden Magor is doing next year Mutineer ?

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Another guy I’d add to sanfl squad in a flash if goes undrafted is Demenico from the eagles

Not that we need defenders

 

[Mutineer]

Have we announced any experienced recruits to sanfl program like port have ?

Any word on what Jaiden Magor is doing next year Mutineer ?

Not at this point

 

[Magma]

i ask, respectfully, how on earth are glenelg fitting all these blokes under the cap, with still a few more guys rumoured to be coming in and no significant departures yet?

sorry, forgot snook retired. possibly curran and proud as well?

 

[cleanhands]

i ask, respectfully, how on earth are glenelg fitting all these blokes under the cap, with still a few more guys rumoured to be coming in and no significant departures yet?

Sounds like the paper bag finger pointing is going in the wrong direction